News  of 6th April  2007

National | Shillong | International | Editorial | Regional | Sports 

EC files FIR against Rajnath, Lalji Tandon
Anti-Muslim CD haunts BJP

New Delhi/Lucknow: BJP's controversial CD came to haunt the party on Thursday as FIRs were filed against party chief Rajnath Singh and others on the orders of the Election Commission for circulating "inflammatory campaign material" against Muslims ahead of the Uttar Pradesh assembly polls.

Following demands that the party be derecognised, the Commission also issued a notice to the BJP asking why action should not be taken against it under the Election Symbols (Reservation and Alootment) Order of 1968 for releasing the CD that contained rude remarks against Muslims and references to the Babri mosque and Godhra train burning.

The FIR was filed at Hazratganj police station in Lucknow against BJP office-bearers and workers under different sections of IPC and the Representation of the People Act after the Commission directed that action should be taken against Rajnath Singh, Lalji Tandon and others.

Citing the model code of conduct, the Commission said it has been brought to its notice that leaders and workers of the BJP released, displayed and distributed the CD containing "inflammatory campaign material derogatory to the sentiments of certain community".

The CD could have the effect of "aggravating existing differences or creating mutual hatred or causing tension between different castes and communities, religious or linguistic" and contained " an appeal to caste or communal feelings for securing votes".

The Congress reacted by asking the Commission to derecognise the BJP and prevent it from contesting the polls.

Caught on the backfoot, the BJP claimed the CD was never publicly released after objections from the poll panel. It said it would respond to the Commission in an appropriate manner. The Commission asked the BJP president to reply by 3 pm on Friday, failing which it would take appropriate action.(PTI)

Muslim leaders to challenge decision in Supreme Court
HC: Muslims no more minority in UP

Allahabad: In a judgement of far reaching political and social consequences, the Allahabad High Court on Thursday ruled that Muslims in Uttar Pradesh can no longer be treated as a religious minority.

The landmark verdict was given by Justice S N Srivastava after applying the twin criteria i.e population and strength of a religious minority and relying on the Census reports of 1951 and 2001. Muslims account for roughly 18.5 per cent of the population in Uttar Pradesh.

Shortly after the verdict was given, the UP Advocate General SMA Kazmi said the judgement will be challenged by the UP Government. The judgement, which is likely to cause polarisation among political parties, came two days ahead of the first phase of the crucial Assembly elections in UP starting on Saturday.

"The court finds that muslims have ceased to be a religious minority community in the State of Uttar Pradesh on the consideration of the material on record which include various census reports including those of 1951 and 2001," the judge said.

The Court directed the UP Government to treat members of the Muslim community on par with the non-minority communities without discrimination in accordance with law. The judgement was given on a writ petition filed by a Madarasa in Ghazipur district, challenging out of turn grant-in-aid to certain other minority institutions.

On the timing of the judgement, Justice Srivastava said he had considered it appropriate to pronounce the operative part of his verdict on Thursday since he is scheduled to sit in the Lucknow bench from April 9. The detailed part of the verdict will be given later.

Justice Srivastava said he had applied "the twin criteria, i.e, population and strength of a religious community as laid down by the founding fathers of the Constitution of India, as is clear from the proceedings of the Constituent Assembly, to determine any religious community as a religious minority."

The Judge further said "The UP Government should treat any member of Muslim community equal to other non-minority religious communities without discriminating in any respect in accordance with law being an integral part of citizenry of India."

The Court also asked the UP Government to treat all Muslim institutions applying for grant-in-aid at par with non-minority institutions without any discrimination.

Justice Srivastava also issued a notice to the Centre and the UP Government to take appropriate steps to modify an October 23, 1993 notification issued by the Central Government on grant of minority status. Allowing the writ petition challenging out-of-turn grant-in-aid to certain institutions, Justice Srivastava took note of the petitioners' allegations of corruption.

The Judge directed the UP Chief Secretary to initiate an inquiry into the allegations and said that it should cover all the orders passed since 2003 recognising institutions for grant-in-aid.

"The inquiry will be conducted by an officer not below the rank of Principal Secretary and completed within three months of the presentation of a certified copy of this order," Justice Srivastava said.

Meanwhile Muslim religious leaders reacted sharply to the High Court decision taking away the minority status of Muslims in the State and said they would challenge it in the Supreme Court.

"We will approach the apex court challenging the Allahabad High Court decision that denies minority status to Muslims in Uttar Pradesh," Shahi Imam of Jama Masjid Syed Ahmad Shah Bukhari said.

Asserting that the court's decision would send a negative message among the Muslim community, he said "the cleric heads of all major Muslim organisations will sit together to take an unanimous decision in the matter."

Describing it as an "unfortunate" verdict, the Imam of Fatehpuri mosque Mufti Mohammed Mukaram said, "Muslims are in a minority in the country and they should get all the benefits of their minority status."

Mukaram questioned the criteria for the data relied upon the Allahabad high court.

"The census of 2001 was incomplete and at that time itself we had raised objections about its credibility. We want the Government to order a fresh census to decide about the minority status of Muslims," he added.

On the other hand, Jamat-e-ulema-al Hind leader Mahmood Madani said Muslims are not in a minority in the country and should be treated as majority.

"We are the second largest majority in India and we ourselves are against minority status for Muslims. But, then we should get equal rights, facilities and opportunities being enjoyed by non-minority communities," said Madani. (PTI)

Bachchan did ad for UP only for money, claims Shatrughan

Kanpur: Launching a broadside against Amitabh Bachchan for appearing in a controversial advertisement promoting Uttar Pradesh's ruling Samajwadi Party, BJP leader and actor Shatrughan Sinha alleged that the megastar had featured in the commercial only because of his "love for money".

Referring to Bachchan's appearance in the advertisement "UP men hai dam, jurm hai kam" (UP has power because of less crime), Sinha said he could not claim that there were fewer crimes in Bihar during former Chief Minister Lalu Prasad's tenure than in Chief Minister Mulayam Singh Yadav's rule in Uttar Pradesh.

"If Bachchan had love for UP, he would have never appeared in such an advertisement. But since he has love for money, he is appearing in such advertisements for his birth place just like (actor) Aamir Khan does advertisements for Coca-Cola," he told PTI.

Sinha was here for campaigning BJP candidates contesting the UP assembly elections. He said despite being a Bihari by heart, mind and birth, he could not claim that "Bihar main hai dam, jurm hai kam."

"In fact there are fewer crimes in Bihar now than during Lalu Prasad's rule," he said.

Sinha claimed Bachchan's advertisement for his native place were no different from his commercials for various products. He said even after the Nithari serial killings, Bachchan had said there were few crimes in UP. Whether this was right or wrong could be decided by Bachchan's "inner soul", Sinha said.

Sinha said after Uttarakhand and Punjab, the BJP was going to wipe out Congress in Delhi Municipal Corporation and UP elections. (PTI)

‘Mulayam Govt misused Central funds’
up elections

Kanpur: Congress president Sonia Gandhi on Thursday asked the people of Uttar Pradesh to seek details from the State Government about the misuse of funds sanctioned by the Centre for undertaking development works.

Addressing a poll rally at Moti Jheel grounds, Gandhi said the State is facing severe crunch due to the misuse of central funds. She accused the Mulayam Singh Yadav Government of "dividing people, encouraging corruption and protecting criminals".

The UPA chairperson said there was a time when Uttar Pradesh used to set examples for the entire country and claimed only a Congress Government can restore the old glory. She said it was necessary to bring back the Congress to power "to end mafia rule and lead the state to development".

Leader of Congress Legislative Party Pramod Tiwari urged the Election Commission to ban BJP from contesting the assembly elections for circulating a CD that allegedly refers to Babri mosque demolition and Godhra train arson.

"BJP wants to win the elections by dividing the people of the state," Tiwari said.

Union Minister of State for Home Sriprakash Jaiswal, state Congress president Salman Khursheed and senior party leader Ashok Gehlot were also present in the public meeting.

FIR against SP minister for inflamatory speech.

A police case has been registered against Samajwadi Party minister Mohammad Azam Khan for allegedly delivering an inflamatory speech during an election rally at Ferozabad on Tuesday.

An FIR was lodged at Rasoolpur police station in Ferozabad by the district administration on the directives of the Election Commission, Additional Chief Electoral Officer M Narayan told reporters here on Thursday. (PTI)

BSP predicted to take lead

New Delhi: An Opinion Poll conducted by NDTV channel in Uttar Pradesh says that BSP leader Mayawati is set to take the lead in the elections which may produce a hung Assembly. Results of NDTV's opinion poll shows that BSP is set to emerge as the single largest party.

The poll which covered a sample size of nearly 16,000 voters in 133 constituencies across the state shows that BSP is expected to get 150-160 seats followed by Mulayam Singh Yadav-led Samajwati Party 140-150, BJP 55-65, Congress 30-40 and others 10-20.

The poll conducted for a month from March two, shows that 40 per cent of the voters feel Mayawati would make the best Chief Minister and 36 per cent voters favouring Yadav. BJP strongman Kalyan Singh is ranked third bagging 24 per cent of the votes, a press release issued by the news channel said.

Asked whether Congress MP Rahul Gandhi's road shows would make a difference, 54 per cent of the voters say yes. But there seems to be few takers for Rahul's comments on the Babri Masjid issue with 72 per cent saying that the comments were not in good taste, the release said. While 65 per cent of the BJP voters say that Ayodhya was no longer an election issue, 49 per cent of the voters felt that Yadav was the preferred choice for espousing the cause of the Muslims. (PTI)

PM hopeful on Siachen talks

New Delhi: Ahead of the official-level Indo-Pak talks on Siachen, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Thursday sounded optimistic on its outcome amid Pakistani media reports that Islamabad has agreed to authenticate present troops positions in the icy region.

"I am hopeful," Singh told reporters here when asked whether he expected any positive outcome from the two-day Defence Secretary-level talks in Islamabad from tomorrow.

"There are immense opportunities. We are working together to resolve our differences," Singh said at Rashtrapati Bhavan on the sidelines of the civil investiture ceremony.

The Prime Minister's remarks came after he chaired a meeting of Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS), which cleared the brief for the Indian side for the talks that will also cover Sir Creek issue.

Earlier, a media report in Pakistan said that Islamabad was ready to authenticate the present troop positions at Siachen if New Delhi agrees not to use it to make a legal claim over the icy region in future.

Top Indian officials said a number of proposals are under consideration but made it clear that any breakthrough can be achieved only when both sides agree to proper authentication and how to undertake it.

The two countries have agreed in principle to demilitarise Siachen but India has been insisting on proper authentication as it wary of redeploying its forces in view of the Kargil experience.

On the SAARC Summit, which concluded yesterday with a strong statement on terrorism, the Prime Minister said the regional grouping was poised to set new trends.

"There are immense opportunities for cooperation," he said when asked what impact the statement on terror would help India.

Noting that "differences" in the past had not allowed the SAARC to realise its potential, Singh said "I am hopeful. We are setting a new trend."

In a move that could address India's concerns, SAARC countries, including Pakistan, committed themselves to suppress fund-raising activities by terror outfits through their frontal groups as part of efforts to check the scourge.

At the two-day Summit, the eight-nation grouping agreed to establish a Convention on Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters at regional level that would equip them to deal with terrorism in a better manner. (PTI)

Bhagwati, Nooyi honoured with Padma

New Delhi: Former Chief Justice of India PN Bhagwati, eminent economist Raja Chelliah, Pepsico CEO Indra Nooyi and Bharti telecom Chairman Sunil Mittal were on Thursday honoured with prestigious Padma awards along with 50 other eminent personalities from a cross-section of society.

Noted lyricist Javed Akhtar, former Supreme Court judge KT Thomas and IIM (Ahmedabad) Director Bakul Dholakia were also among those to receive the awards from President A P J Abdul Kalam at a glittering function held at Rashtrapati Bhavan.

The recipients of the awards represented business, law and justice, journalism, art, film, science, medicine, and education.

Among the recipients was 106-year-old Hakim Syed Mohd Sharfuddin Quadri, who got Padma Bhushan for unani medicine, at the function attended by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, Lok Sabha Speaker Somnath Chatterjee and several Cabinet ministers.

The President came down from the dais to confer awards to six recipients, who were either on wheel-chairs or unable to walk properly due to old age.

Along with Bhagwati and Chelliah, eminent surgeon Balu Sankaran and renowned international physicist E C G Sudarshan were bestowed with the Padma Vibhushan awards.

Besides Nooyi, Mittal, Akhtar and Thomas, Padma Bhushan awards were presented to Kavalam Narayana Panikkar (playwright), Captain L Z Sailo (poet), Saroj Ghose (science), Shiv Kumar Sarin (Medicine), Vaidya Shriram Sharma (Medicine), Tapan Kumar Raychaudhuri (Historian) and Tyeb Mehta (artist).

The Padma Shri awards were conferred on 36 outstanding personalities, including two posthumously.

They are A P Mishra (education), Amitav Ghosh (novelist), A Sivasailam (business), Astad Aderbad Deboo (dance), Atul Kumar (medicine), B Paul Thaliath (medicine), Balbir Singh (medicine), Baldev Raj (science), Pandit G N Singh (music), Rajmata Goverdan Kumari (conservation of ancient properties), K S Valdiya (geology), Lalit Pande (environment), Lama Thupten Phunstsok (education) and Mahadev Prasad Pandey (ayurveda).

Mira Salganik (history and culture), Mushirul Hasan (education), Naina Lal Kidwai (business), Narmada Gupta (medicine), P Gopinathan (handicraft), P R Thilagam (music), Pannuru Sripathy (art), Rabinder Gokaldas Ahuja (youth development), Rajinder Gupta (business), Runa Banerjee (social work), Rybakov Rostislav (history), Shanti Hiranand (music), Shekhar Pathak (history), S B Tibrewal (medicine), Sonam Lepcha (cultural music), Sudhir Kumar Sopory (science), Temsula Ao (education), T K Alex (space science), Vijai Dan Detha (literature) and Y M Pathan (education) also received the Padma Shri awards.

Devindra Rahinwal (journalism) and Ravindra Dayal (publication) were honoured posthumously. (PTI)

Zero bribe for corrupt officials

Chennai: Corrupt bureacrats long used to making lives of ordinary citizens miserable by demanding bribes for clearing files pertaining to everyday affairs will have to brace themselves for a rude shock - the next time they resort to their old tactics.

A Chennai-based organisation in its bid to fight corruption has launched a novel 'non-co-operation movement' to assist ordinary citizens against those who want their palms greased.

Whenever an official seeks gratification for his otherwise free service, the commoner could flaunt the zero rupee and make his anti-bribe stance clear, says Vijay Anand, president of Fifth Pillar, a rights group, that has mooted the idea.

Though designed like a 50 rupee note with all details including Mahatma Gandhis picture printed on one side. The note displays in place of the RBI Governors promise the words "I promise to neither accept nor give bribe."

"You may call it a sort of Gandhigiri. The zero rupee is a non-cooperation movement against bribery," says Anand, president of Fifth Pillar, a rights group, which has also set up dedicated RTI centres for the first time in India to help people get info under Right to Information Act.

Tamil Nadu State Information Commissioner G Ramakrishnan says he feels that the "zero rupee is a symbol to express refusal to grease the palms of officials.

The organisations ambitious plan is to undertake a campaign through schools, colleges and youth movements.

Suhasini Maniratnam, actress, film director and social activist, who terms herself a 'well-wisher' of Fifth Pillar says, "the zero Rupee is a sort of emotional blackmailing of bribe seekers."

Anand points out that 25 RTI centres that have opened in and around the city would educate public on using the provisions of the Act, filing applications and how to go about so that their grievances were addressed on time.

"Since the Act came into existence in 2005, there have been many RTI activists in states, including Maharashtra, Kerala, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu, but this is the first time in India that RTI-related services have been institutionalized", says Ramakrishnan.

"This is indeed a positive step" he says adding these centres are expected to provide them direction as to how to get required information from Central and State Governments, local bodies and non-governmental organisations getting public funds.

Within a span of three days since its inception last week, around 200 people have sought their help. "Preparing of the questions in the petition and referrence about the RTI Act is important. Otherwise it could be dumped as any other petition", says Anand. Since the Act came into force, Tamil Nadu has made tremendous progress with regard to the number of petitions and their disposal, he says.

"In the eleven months ending December 2006, we were receiving at an average 750 petitions a month. From January, 2007, the numbers have shot up to 1,330", adds Ramakrishanan. Almost all the cases have been disposed off in five days in a single sitting with no adjournments, he adds.

The Commission has issued show-cause notices to over 100 officials in the state for failing to respond to the petitioners, who had sought information under the Act, Ramakrishnan said. (PTI)


 

 Police to learn manner lessons
In Assembly

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Realising that police should maintain a people-friendly attitude, the State government is planning to impart manner training to the men in uniform. A private agency is likely to be given the responsibility of conducting this training , Chief Minister DD Lapang informed the Assembly on Thursday.

Earlier, moving a Zero Hour notice, PT Sawkmie (MDP) said the Wahlang Committee had earlier made recommendations on the re-organsation of the State Police. He suggested that the State government should look into the aspect of having better police control room, computerisation of police stations and upgradation of weapons.

In his reply, the Chief Minister said that Government was committed to look after the interest of the police personnel.

Replying to Mr Sawkmie's question, the Mr Lapang said efforts were initiated by the government to modernise the police force including upgradation of weapons. 

He also said since many police personnel are posted in remote areas, the government is thinking of providing hostel facilities for them and residential schools for their children. He, however, praised the police force for its contribution and said that Meghalaya police is one of the best in the country.

State happy with NEIGRIHMS progress

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Health and Family Welfare Minister Mrs Deborah Marak said even though the State does not have much say on the functioning of NEIGRIHMS, the State government was happy with its progress.

In reply to a question by PT Sawkmie (MDP), Mrs Marak told the Assembly that as NEIGRIHMS being a Central project, the State has its own limitations.

According to Mrs Marak, there was delay in procuring equipment due to change of technology, limitations of local vendors supplying equipment in the North-East. The project cost Rs 422.60 crore includes a 500-bed referral hospital with teaching at postgraduate level.

‘Resolve HSRP, stop public harassment’

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Expressing indignation over repeated public agitations over High Security Registration Plate (HSRP)Independent legislator Manas Chaudhuri asked the government to ensure that the public did not suffer due to the stand-off between the government and the NGOs on the issue.

Moving a call attention motion regarding the implementation of HSRP, Mr Chaudhuri said that the judgement of the Gauhati High Court says that common people should not be affected by the agitations called by the NGOs regarding the matter. He urged the government to see to it that the rate of the HSRP is reviewed to benefit the people.

According to Mr Chaudhuri, the government should make sure that the scheme is implemented without further loss of time, so that the NGOs are unable to take the public for a ride.

Replying to the motion, Transport Minister Mrs Deborah Marak said the government was in favour of reviewing the HSRP rate. She said a committee headed by Chief Minister DD Lapang met on March 26 and decided that the rates of HSRP could be reviewed.

However, Mrs Marak said the State was compelled to go ahead with the implementation of HSRP due to the direction of Gauhati High Court. She said that the doubts related to the HSRP as raised by the NGOs are a non-issue.

According to the Minister, if a person can buy the vehicle worth several lakh rupees, he or she can afford HSRP.

Rights body moves SAARC heads over killing of Garo leader in B’desh

From Our Spl Correspondent

NEW DELHI: The Asian Centre for Human Rights has appealed to the Heads of the states and Governments of the SAARC countries to intervene into the killing of a prominent Garo leader Choles Ritchil in Bangladesh.

Mr Ritchil's body, which was handed over to the family members recently, bore several torture marks. Though deceased's wife had filed a complaint with the Modhupur Police Station no FIR was registered even after lot of protest, Mr Suhas Chakma, Director of the renowned human rights body said.

Many NGOs in Bangladesh protested against the inhuman killing of the Garo leader. Incidentally, Bangladesh has substantial Garo population specially in the hill tracts and some of the Garos have made it to high echelons of the society including the Bangladesh parliament.

Mr Ritchil who was killed last month has been targeted for opposing the construction of an Eco-Park over 3,000 acres of Modhupur forest under Tangail district of Bangladesh inhabited by the Garo indigenous people. About 25,000 indigenous Garo people faced eviction because of the Eco-Park.

Earlier, one more Garo Piren Snal was killed on the spot and 25 others including women and children were injured in police firing on the controversial issue. After the declaration of the state of emergency in January this year, the Forest Department officials restarted the construction of the controversial boundary wall for the Eco-Park but had to abandon following protest by indigenous peoples led by Mr Ritchil.

Deborah for curb on illegal tollgates

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Transport Minister Deborah C Marak said stern action was needed to deal with the increasing number of illegal tollgates along highways and other roads of the State.

Answering to the incident of torching of several check gates belonging to various Government departments and private parties in Garo Hills on Wednesday, Mrs Marak said she was awaiting the report on the matter.

"I admit the presence of illegal toll gates and this problem should be dealt with firm hands," Mrs Marak said.

Most of the illegal tollgates reappeared after being dismantled by police in various districts of the State.

No invitation from Govt: Kharshanlor
CCIB firm on agitation

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: The CCIB has decided to go ahead with its proposed office picketing on April 10 and 11 and 48-hour road blockade from April 12 morning till there is "concrete evidence" of suspension of border fencing work by the NBCC in Umkiang-Rattachera sector of Jaintia Hills.

The government on Wednesday had asked the NBCC to keep in abeyance the fencing work along the State's international border with Bangladesh.

"We saw in the newspaper that the government had asked the NBCC to keep the border fencing work in abeyance but so far there is no proof that the work has really been suspended," Coordination Committee on International Border (CCIB) spokesman GH Kharshanlor on Thursday said.

The CCIB also informed that the Government is yet to invite them to discuss the fencing issue despite the announcement of agitations.

The Government-constituted Coordination Committee on Border Fencing (CCBF) headed by Deputy Chief Minister Dr Donkupar Roy will hold a meeting on April 12 and the CCIB has been served a notice in this regard.

However, the CCIB refused to accept it as a formal invitation for talks stating -- "We have not received any official invitation for talks. The notice that I received on Wednesday evening is only about the CCBF meeting which has nothing to do with our agitation and demand," Mr Kharshanlor clarified.

He also said that the government should not consider the notice served to the CCIB to attend the CCBF meeting as an invitation for talks.

Chief Minister DD Lapang and Jaintia Hills DC Frederick Roy Kharkongor are "feigning ignorance" about the ongoing fencing work in Jaintia Hills, he alleged.

Govt to ask NBCC to halt fencing: Meanwhile, the State government has decided to ask the NBCC to suspend all kinds of border fencing work in all the disputed areas along the State's international border with Bangladesh until problems like loss of agricultural lands, alienation of people and land compensation are solved.

The decision was taken on Thursday at an emergency meeting convened by the Deputy Chief Minister Dr Donkupar Roy, who is also the Chairman of the Coordination Committee on Indo-Bangladesh Border Fencing (CCIBBF). The meeting was attended by five ministers, BSF officials, NBCC officials and DGP BK Dey Sawian.

Speaking to reporters after the meeting, newly appointed Chief Secretary Ranjan Chatterjee said that the government had asked the NBCC to stop the fencing work in Umkiang and other disputed areas where farmers are unhappy over loss of agricultural land due to the fencing.

Meanwhile, the CCIB has exempted the NEHU from the purview of the office picketing, according to PRO of NEHU Kynpham Nongkynrih.

BL Joshi new Governor of Meghalaya

New Delhi: Lieutenant Governor of Delhi BL Joshi will be the new Governor of Meghalaya. He will replace MM Jacob.

The 73-year-old Joshi, who was appointed as Delhi's Lt Governor on June 9, 2004, has been appointed as Governor of Meghalaya with effect from the date he assumes the post, a Rashtrapati Bhavan Communication said here on Thursday.

Mr Jacob was first appointed as the Governor of Meghalaya in 1995. He was appointed for another term in 2000.

Former IAS officer Tejendra Khanna will be the new Lieutenant Governor of the national capital. An official source said Khanna has been appointed as the new Lt Governor with effect from the date he assumes charge of the office. Khanna is likely to be sworn in on Friday.

Governor of Nagaland K Sankaranarayanan has been asked to assume the additional charge of Arunachal Pradesh in addition to his own duties during the absence on leave of S K Singh, the communication said. (PTI)

Pranab visit

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Union External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukheerjee will visit the State on April 14 to address a seminar on "SAARC &BIMSTEC: Geography as an Opportunity" with special reference to the northeastern states at the NEHU campus. Mr Mukheerjee will also chair an interactive session on issues relating to the region.

Prohibition

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: East Khasi Hills District Magistrate on Thursday promulgated Section 144 CrPC prohibiting picketing, assembly of five or more persons, carrying of arms etc., in the district.

Does ‘Meghalaya’ need a change?

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Is there any need to change the nomenclature of the State from Meghalaya to a name that truly reflects the identity of its indigenous people? The legislators on Thursday aired mixed views on the matter in the Assembly on Thursday.

During the Question Hour, answering a question by PT Sawkmie (MDP), GAD Minister Prestone Tynsong said there was no plan to change the name of the State from Meghalaya to any other name.

However, the questioner said the name 'Meghalaya' does not suit the tribal character. Mr Sawkmie said as other states had changed their names, Meghalaya could also follow the suit.

To this, Mr Tynsong said that the suggestion to rename can be accepted and the matter would be examined by the GAD committee.

Manas Chaudhuri(Ind) expressed doubts whether the committee under GAD was competent authority to decide on the change of name. He said it needed constitutional amendment.

HS Lyngdoh (HSPDP) wanted to know the true meaning of Meghalaya.

After the Minister replied that the literal meaning of Meghalaya was abode of clouds, Mr Lyngdoh, contradicting this said that as per Greek dictionary, the meaning of Meghalaya was "the place of frogs." He suggested that it is better to change the name Meghalaya into Khasi-Jaintia State and Garo State.

To supplementary questions by Sengman R Marak (Ind), Tonsing Marak (Congress) and PM Syiem(Ind), Mr Tynsong said there was no demand from any quarter to change the name of the State.

Lottery dues

The State government is yet to receive Rs 33 crore for running both online and paper lotteries in the State for the last five years.

Answering a question by Manas Chaudhuri (Ind), Chief Minister DD Lapang informed the Assembly that while the State received Rs 19 crore for running online lottery, Rs 10.49 crore was received from the firms running paper lottery.

Mr Lapang said the due from the firm running online lottery is Rs 25.80 crore. He also said from the five distributors of paper lottery, the government has not received Rs 7.23 crore.

House for creation of employment avenues

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: The legislators who took part in the debate on the State Budget expressed concern over the tardy progress of the state over years.

Continuing with his discussion, Mr PT Sawkmie (MDP) said that Meghalaya should get the facilities under the backward area fund like all the other poor states in the country. He also urged the government to provide more employment to the youth in the State by taking up employment generation programmes.

"The government should also look into the aspect of providing employment opportunities to the physically challenged," he said.

Participating in the discussion, Mr PM Syiem (Ind) stated that the price hike of commodities needs to be controlled by the State government. He also added that the government should initiate measures to diagnose the inflation.

Stating the need to provide good governance, Mr Syiem said that money is pumped to different departments but what lacks is proper monitoring of the same.

Mr HS Lyngdoh (HSPDP) narrated the plight of the people in the border areas due to the border dispute. He also urged the government to implement important programmes and policies that will benefit the people.

Education

During the question hour, Higher and Technical Education Minister RG Lyngdoh informed that while the State has 2,595 elementary schools run by the government, the number of such private schools is 6015.

Replying to a question by Mr PT Sawkmie (MDP), the Education Minister said that the state has 33 higher and technical level government educational institutions.

Mr Lyngdoh also said that the private institutions are not taking opening permission since they are not under the aided category.

Shillong Banking Corporation

In replying to a question put forward by Mr Manas Chaudhuri(Ind), Deputy Chief Minister Dr Donkupar Roy said that the issue of liquidating the liabilities of the defunct Shillong Banking Corporation Ltd is pending with the Gauhati High Court.

City gang of thieves busted

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: In a major breakthrough, police of East Khasi Hills District busted a gang of thieves and recovered a number of solen items which includes three air conditioners, two CPU, keyboard and two batteries. A major part of the recovered goods were stolen on February 19 from the office of Radio Lala Positive Pvt. Ltd, part of M/S Positive Television Pvt. Ltd. (NETv).

The mastermind of the gang was Pradeep Purkayastha, proprietor of a computer shop located at Upper New Colony. His modus operandi was to entice workers of offices having electronic goods and with their assistance later rob the offices. He would later interchange parts of the goods and sell the different parts of the electronic goods to customers. This was done in order to deceive the police.

Along with Pradeep Purkayastha, the others arrested include Sujoy Roy of Barapathar, Arjun Barman of Mawpat, Emol Rajbongshi of Kokrajhar, Kunal Choudhury of Lum Mawrie and Rajdeep Purkayastha of Upper New Colony.

Police teamwork the mainstay of all success: Syiem

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: At an impressive ceremony held on Thursday at the 1st MLP Battalion Mawiong parade ground, altogether 84 recruits were inducted into the Meghalaya Police Force.

The Inspector General of Police (TAP) Mr MS Syiem, IPS took the salute of the passing out parade of the 32nd batch of Recruit Constables. The new Recruit constables comprised of 31 AB constables and 53 driver constables. They joined the 1st MLP Bn Training Centre on July 29,2006 and underwent 32 weeks of a thorough training programme prescribed for a full-fledged policeman, before qualifying to join as fulltime police force.

Mr Syiem lauded the new recruits for their impressive passing out parade and affirmed that from henceforth they are no more recruit constables but regular inducted police personnel of the Meghalaya Police. He called upon the new recruits to utilise their training to the best of their ability to serve the State, the country and the community around them by winning the goodwill of the people.

Mr Syiem encouraged the recruiting constables to don their khaki uniform with honour and execute their duty with integrity and pride. He stressed on the importance of teamwork to get success in endeavours.

The Commandant Ms C Lyngwa, MPS, while thanking the Inspector General of Police MS Syiem, IPS, for gracing the function, commended his interest and helpfulness in the training facilities. On the occasion trophies were awarded to the outstanding recruits.

Delimitation panel proposal opposed

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Langkyrdem Block Youth Congress Committee has opposed the the proposal of Delimitation Commission to delete Langkyrdem Constituency.

Addressing a press conference here on Thursday, LBYCC president Bannangsan Tynsong said that if Langkrydem constituency is deleted after the implementation of the delimitation constituency then it will deeply hamper the overall development of Ri-War area adding that annually the area will loose nearly 1 crore of the MLA scheme.

"Around 63 small villages will be affected from the delimitation of the constituency which have around 22,000 voters" Mr Tynsong added.

Plea on power cut

SHILLONG: BJP legislator AL Hek has urged Deputy Chief Minister in-charge Power Dr Mukul Sangma to ask the MeSEB not to have any power cut on Friday. In a letter to Dr Sangma, Mr Hek stated that Good Friday being an auspicious day for the Christians, Dr Sangma shoud take necessary steps to withdraw load shedding in the State on Friday to allow the chruch services to be carried out smoothly.

GIWO plea to curb liquor dens

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: The Greater Iewduh Welfare Organisation (GIWO) has urged the Syiem of Mylliem to close down all liquor "dens" including restaurants selling alcohol in Iewduh.

In a statement, the GIWO said that porters working in Iewduh should be issued identity cards after verifying their antecedents in order to check the flow of non-tribal porters in the market.

The GIWO also wanted an "efficient and energetic person" to head the Mylliem Syiemship Police Station at Iewduh in order to deal with crimes and other illegal activities in the market.

The organization has appealed to the other NGOs to avoid unnecessary agitations as it "causes severe loss to shopkeepers especially those selling perishable items."

Furore over expulsion of headmaster

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Students of RB Anoopchand Secondary School, Police Bazar on Thursday staged a demonstration to oppose the decision of the school’s Managing Committee to removed the school principal Mr KK Bhattacharjee.

Meanwhile, the Secretary of the Managing Committee maintained that the expulsion of the Headmaster is justified as he was dishonest.

Earlier, the students of the school opposing the arbitrary decision of the Managing Committee against the Headmaster has staged a demonstration demanding his reinstatement and claimed that the decision is vindictive and threatened to go for a hartal. They claimed that the allegations are false.

It may be mentioned that the Order for suspension was passed on Wednesday and was hanged in the School Notice Board much to the humiliation of the head master and the students of the School.

Meanwhile, B.P.Bajoria, the President, and K.K.Jhunjhunwala the Secretary of the Managing Committee and O.P.Agarwal who claims to be a member of the same speaking to media maintained that the headmaster has misappropriated a huge amount of money from school fund even as the Order of Suspension has stated a sum of Rs 62,586 and a due enquiry will be constituted even as they have not filed an FIR.

The suspension order stated that the Headmaster will not be allowed to enter the school premises, office or classroom and will be getting a subsistence allowance.

Paul’s recipe for development

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Minister of Urban Affairs Paul Lyngdoh said that most towns in the north eastern region need more investments for infrastructural projects.

Delivering his valedictory address at the Regional Workshop on Pool Finance Development Funds Schemes here on Thursay, Mr Lyngdoh said that the towns in the region also requires consultants and experts from cities in the mainland to prepare us better. He however said that the reason of the lack of facilities is the topography of the region .

The Urban Minister also hopes the outcome from this workshop will go a long way in addressing the needs of the Municipalities in the North East.

Villagers respond to self-employment

From Our Correspondent

TURA: The West Garo Hills district administration has been enthused by the spontaneous response of the villagers to the ongoing MREGS programmes as was evident from the mammoth gathering for its two day workshop at Tura district auditorium which began on Tuesday.

As many as 2400 village elders, nokmas, along with the secretaries and chairmans of the Village and Area Employment Councils (VECs/AECs) from eight different blocks participated in the programme.

One of the main objectives of the two day programme was to get the villagers to have a plan perspective for their own villages.

Educating the people about Army

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: The GOC of 101 Area Major General Vinod Nayanar said that ‘Know Your Army’, which will be held on Saturday next, is an annual event to familiarise the general public with the strength and capabilities of the Indian army.

Addressing a press conference here on Thursday, Major General Nayanar said that another objective of this exhibition will be to promote better understanding of army personnel amongst the local populace and to educate the youth on the career prospects in the army.

"In this event multiple facets of the army will be shown or displayed in the forms of stalls, display of weapons and equipments, live display and also humanitarian activity like free medical and blood donation camp" GOC of 101 Area said.

He said that all school children will be provided with free transport for conveyance from school to Polo Ground to ensure massive attendance in the event. The Major General further informed that the amount spent for the event is about 5 to 6 lakhs.

The main attraction of the event is the first time ever live display of Hot Air Balloning team of 3 EMER Centre Bhopal who will display the skills of Hot Air Balooning. The other live display in the event includes heliborne operation, skills of military canines, para motor gliding, acrobatic display, sky diving and many others.

There are total of six exhibition stalls showcasing glorious history of Indian Army by Field Composite Signal Regiment (FCSR), training and operations of Indian Army by 58 Gorkha Training Centre, adventure activities of Indian Army by (FCSR), humanitarian activities by Shillong Military Hospital, career counselling to join the army by Zonal Recruiting Office, Shillong and stalls by young cadets.

The weapons that will be displayed in the event includes Bofors Gun, Radil Relay Vehicle, Composite Entity Vehicle, Inmarsat Sattelite phone among others.

Correction

With reference to the news item under caption ‘Achieve-ment’(Dt April 5), the name should be read as Dr Regalia May Tangper . She completed her research under the supervision of Dr SM Sungoh.


SAARC summit

The 14th SAARC summit was held amidst turbulence in the region and question marks over his relevance. Has it made any progress since it was formed in 1985? The answer is no. This was because of the inherent contradictions among Saarc members. The most important reason was the lack of trust. India's smaller neighbours looked at it as a hegemonic power. Bilateral issues also became a barrier for a regional cooperation. The security concerns of these members are also divergent. Above all, there was no political will to make Saarc a success. New Delhi managed to host a smooth summit is in itself a feat. Added to that is SAARC's expansion, with the admission of Afghanistan as the eighth member. Another notable feature of the summit was the presence of five observers: the US, China, European Union, South Korea and Japan. The inclusion of Iran also as an observer has given an added dimension to the summit. Iran had taken a keen interest in seeking this association for the past two years in line with its Look-East policy. It may seem contradictory. On the one hand, the record of SAARC is dismal. But, on the other, global powers like China, US, Japan, European Union and South Korea want to be associated with this organization. Why do these big powers show interest in Saarc? Is it because of the growing economic clout of India and other countries in the region? Almost all the South Asian countries have shown impressive growth rate, and they are in a position to give business to the big powers. Obviously, they do not want to be left behind when South Asia grows. The second reason could be the strategic interests in the region. Interestingly, the Chinese and Japanese foreign ministers came up with a number of schemes for the Saarc countries, particularly the youth.

Now that the summit has ended, the question is: Will the Saarc take off? Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, as the new chairman of SAARC, expressed the hope, in his concluding speech, that "we can make the Saarc work". However, on the ground, the story was quite different. The Heads of states as usual reaffirmed their commitment to terrorism, food security, poverty alleviation and energy security. While the summit produced only two agreements- one on South Asian University and second on setting up a Saarc food bank -- there was no substantial progress on terrorism and trade. Despite Singh's announcement of free access to Indian markets for the poorer Saarc countries, trade continued to remain a contentious issue. SAFTA is yet to be implemented in letter and spirit. Rhetoric apart, if the SAARC countries decide to sort out the economic problems, there could be some success in future. Good economics is never bad politics. Connectivity was one of the themes of this summit. There is a ray of hope that with the expansion of SAARC, things may work out better. New Delhi summit was smooth but the same spirit should animate next year's summit to be held in Maldives. Otherwise, it will be just a talk festival.




The truth does hurt

By Patricia Mukhim

In a society that is at best soporific and at worst engages in drawing room saber-rattling it is indeed encouraging to have a response to one's article. Dr H Srikanth's riposte to my critique on NEHU merits another treatise on the arguments advanced to defend his academic colleagues and their intellectual commitment. The tone and tenor of his article is reminiscent of a trapeze artist walking the tightrope. Srikanth is torn between being politically correct and blurting out the truth. As a result he has come up with a pretty diluted response which reveals yet again that NEHU scholars lack fire in their belly. No wonder they are unable to ignite minds.

Friedrich Nietzsche said liberal institutions straightaway cease from being liberal the moment they are soundly established. Could this be true of NEHU too? Now that the institution is touted as the university with potential for excellence (meaning that several more crores will come its way) the feeling one gets is that NEHU has also become a sacred sanctuary beyond the purview of public criticism. In other words NEHU is resting on its laurels and the argument is that it should be allowed to do so. About the much-touted 'university with potential for excellence', status, I dare say, NEHU earned it only because it is comparatively better than other universities in this region. In the land of the blind the one-eyed is undisputedly the king. The funds flowing to NEHU are part of the policy of appeasement of the Central Government through the UGC. It comes from having the right connections in the right quarters in Delhi. Frankly speaking, the 'potential for excellence' label is merely a phrase to justify the grant of additional funds to NEHU which is a central university.

Ideas have consequences and Srikanth has thrown up ideas relating to ethnocentrism of civil societies in Meghalaya. This is a very clever articulation on the discordant concept of civil society. Civil society is itself an emerging entity and it requires that the University give us a clear picture of what it should ideally be, so we could strive towards the ideal. When and where is civil society entirely free from all bind? The civil societies that Srikanth has in mind, and I know this from having previously engaged in this discourse with his department, in fact fall in the category of 'uncivil societies'. The mafia for instance is an uncivil society. Hence it becomes imperative that the civil elements defeat the uncivil. Agreed that there are insular organizations but that is just one small fraction of the larger human population of Meghalaya which is certainly not blinkered. The problem with this unattached mass is that they are groping for want of a direction.

Not only in the North East but even within the country, it is difficult to find a civil society that is unattached to an ethnic ideology, religious affiliation, community, caste, et al. Ethnocentrism is merely replaced by other sorts of fetters. What happened in Gujarat (2002) is a classic example of the collapse of civil society. That such a thing should happen in a more socially evolved and economically vibrant part of the country only goes to show that civil society which is liberal and absolutely free from petty encumbrances and seeks the greater good of the human race is still an amorphous idea, although, it is an urgent need. I recall that this issue was discussed by a couple of NEHU scholars outside the campus. Hence it is curious that my article was discussed in the precincts of the university. Does it not call for a larger public debate?

That NEHU is an insular monolith is borne out by the fact that when the right to information exercise had got underway, the fees charged for application for information was Rs 500. Subsequent photocopies were priced at Rs 50 a piece. Is this not an attempt to shirk public accountability and to discourage the public from asking questions? Only after several engagements, followed by complaints, were the fees reduced to an affordable amount. Why would a public institution be uncomfortable about giving out information on various subjects?

One argument advanced by the learned scholar and one that baffles, is that teaching is a specialized profession, not a social service activity. My own perception is that if teaching is a specialized activity then all that universities will produce are brilliant, cut-throat, whip-lashing monsters unfit for society. The west today places a premium on liberal education as opposed to 'specialized education' because they have seen the dangers of specialization. Specialization slots a person in one profession throughout life. Liberal education on the other hand produces rounded individuals and makes students real human beings who can feel the pangs of life as it is lived outside the ivory towers. Education is useless if you take away from it the component of social service. In fact, the end of all good education is service to humanity.

The argument that research should be judged from their utility in advancement of human knowledge and that it should not be assessed from a narrow angle of whether it serves the interests of immediate communities, seems to me to be a typical Brahmanical attitude to education. Without being parochial or bigoted, my understanding of the reasons why NEHU was started is essentially to enable the people of the region to find their feet. Hence research that does not meet their needs but serves only the larger national interest is totally out of sync. Perhaps there is a need to revisit the goals for which NEHU was established. Let us not lecture on communalism and its ignoble virtues because we see too much of that in all universities including those in our neighbourhoods. In fact, NEHU today looks more like a gurukul (without the essence of the gurukul system) where hegemony by one group of scholars is sought to be staunchly established. What is constantly practiced by NEHU scholars is to guard their respective turf. Any encroachment on that protected space leads to regular turf wars.

In the world of information technology Srikanth should not be moaning about NEHU being peripherally located. On the contrary it is strategically poised to be the catalytic agent churning out ideas on the Look East Policy, a slogan which is beginning to look more and more like a red herring. As for scholars lacking journalistic skills, one feels that a journalist writes for the common man, in common parlance, minus the jargons and convoluted language. The best language is simple and easy to read not heavy academic hocus-pocus. Scholars like Sunanda Dutta Ray, Bhanu Pratap Mehta, Ramchandra Guha write such easy prose. Do they lose their privileged positions for addressing the common man? Far from it, rather, such scholars help bring academia within reach of the least common denominator of society.

Srikanth's caption, "University and Civil Society", seems to suggest that NEHU is apart from and incapable of being a civil society. Rather, he seems to think that the two occupy separate spaces and the twain between university and civil society can never meet. This is a rather disdainful, presumptuous thinking unworthy of a scholar. Are scholars not affected by the confusion and tumult that rages in society? Are they not part of society? Or would it be more correct to say that a good many scholars treat NEHU as a temporary milking cow for as long as the cow is able to deliver milk. Apart from that, they form their own civic space, interface with their own kind and thereby create a polarized zone.

I am also intrigued by this phrase 'by and large the students are decent and academic friendly'. Does decency include a non-dissenting, apathetic, unchallenging, subservient attitude? The kind of scholars that NEHU turns out, have neither the stamina nor the interest to engage with the many problems that confront them outside the ivory tower. In fact, after so many years in the University they do not even have the tools of engagement. What a pity that NEHU is only churning out little robots who can only mimic their gurus. No wonder the best and the brightest take the first flight out of Guwahati to pursue a more outstanding scholarly pursuit. Why, even NEHU scholars themselves send their children outside the region and out of the country. This is enough to certify NEHU's credentials.

 

School teachers: Future tense

Sir,

This refers to the statement made by the Education Minister regarding the non-payment of DA to the teachers for the last two years (ST, March 23), where the Minister cited shortage of fund as the reason behind non-payment. I would like to ask the Minister why there is always a paucity of fund whenever the matter is related to the teachers especially the primary teachers? Why this ill-fated primary teachers are always at the receiving end? I wonder, if the government has ever cancelled the foreign tour programmes of the MLAs and the Ministers because of the paucity of fund! The govt is unable to pay the DA to the teachers but able enough to distribute sophisticated laptops among its MLAs. Fair enough! Probably with these sophisticated devices MLAs will be in a better position to calculate their TAs, DAs, pensions etc. and will learn the games of politics now in a more sophisticated way.

It is worth mentioning here that the primary teachers of Meghalaya are deprived of any retirement benefit scheme such as CPF, gratuity or pension whereas their counterparts in the states like Delhi, Bihar, Jharkhand, Orissa etc. are in far better position in terms of salaries, medical facilities, retirement benefits etc. But in Meghalaya the teachers do not even get their salaries regularly. Could our Education Minister be kind enough to say if an MLA can earn the right of pension by merely serving for 3 or 5 years than why not a teacher is eligible for the same even after a constructive contribution of 30 years? When all other employees of the government are drawing their salaries in the new pay structure after the due merger of 50% of D.A. with the basic, the primary teachers are still uncertain whether they are going to receive the same. Moreover, it is disheartening to see that the primary teachers are drawing their salaries @ 71 % of D.A. at present whereas the present rate of D.A. is much higher. Is the government listening?

It is learnt that the government is eager to improve the quality of education. Chief Minister DD Lapang recently said, "we want every teacher to have the best qualification" (ST, March 23). Being a teacher I welcome this whole heartedly, but at the same time I want Mr Lapang to look into the problems faced by the primary teachers. The Chief Minister should understand that a teacher can deliver quality education only when the quality of his life is improved. I feel if the government is really serious about improving the quality of education then it must change its step-motherly attitude towards the primary teachers else the dream of quality education will remain as a mere dream.

Yours etc.,
Anirudhha Datta
Shillong-4

II

Sir,

Apropos the letter 'Teachers' Grievances' (ST - March 28) by the General Secretary, Khasi Jaintia Deficit School Teachers' Association, I, as teacher have the, following observations :-

1. Why did the Association keep the teachers in dark for about seven months after meeting the Education Minister on August, 7, 2006 and the subsequent meeting with the Commissioner (Mrs. R. V. Suchiang)? After all, the office bearers of this Association are the representatives of the Secondary Deficit School Teachers and they owe it to teachers.

2. When the Commissioner informed the office bearers of the Association that the sub-committee constituted for extending pensionary and retirement benefit is exclusively for college teachers only and the appointment sought with the Education Minister was not granted, how could they it pending for so many months? Was it not an insult to the entire teaching community?

3. A delegation of six teachers met the present Education Minister Mr RG Lyngdoh on March, 20, 2007. What did this Association do since the day it met the previous Education Minister, Dr. Donkupar Roy till it met Mr Lyngdoh? Was it expecting some windfall gain for teachers?

4. When the teachers are in distress, how this Association allowed the government to complete the Annual Examinations, SSLC Examination and evaluations unhindered and uninterrupted? Remember "Hit the iron when it is hot".

5. If nothing concrete comes out including pensionary benefit after the dead line of April, 30, what this Association intends to do? If agitation, which is the right way, should it not keep the teachers in readiness for the bigger struggle? Time is running out.

6. This Association should chalk out a programme for spreading the agitation in the entire State taking into confidence the Garo Hills Deficit School Teachers' Association so that the teachers movement may gain bite' and sting and education comes to a grinding halt, whereupon the government is compelled to bow before its legitimate demands.

7. Why not the Association resorted to agitation when the State Assembly is on? It would have been food for the opposition MLAs to grind the Govt.

Yours etc.,
TS Nongrum
Shillong-4


AASU takes on Centre on border fencing issue

From Our Correspondent

Guwahati: The All Assam Students' Union on Thursday accused the Central government of putting country security and integrity at stake by keeping the India-Bangladesh border in Assam unfenced.

The Adviser of the AASU, Dr Samujjal Kumar Bhattacharrya said, "The porous India-Bangladesh border sector in Assam is being used by the Islamic fundamentalists organizations and Pakistani ISI to sneak in their agents to foment trouble in the region."

The AASU leader expressed surprise that even the decisions taken in the Prime Minister level tripartite talks to seal the India-Bangladesh border by 31st December 2006 failed to ensure completion of the project.

The AASU on Thursday warned immediate steps to complete border fencing work in Assam by the Central government failing which it would launch a vigorous mass agitation soon.



National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |

 

                                               

Make This Your HomePage! | About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery

Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.