News of 24th March 2007
National | Shillong | International | Editorial | Regional | Sports

All accused guilty in Manjunath murder case
Lakhimpur-Kheri (UP):
Pronouncing the verdict in a packed court room, District Judge S M A Abidi said that he has reached the conclusion that all the eight were guilty in the murder of the IIM-Lucknow graduate on November 19, 2005.They were convicted under sections 302 (murder), 120 B (criminal conspiracy) and 201 (destruction of evidence) of the Indian Penal Code and provisions of the Arms Act.
On the plea of the defence counsel that time was needed to prepare their submission, Abidi fixed Monday for hearing of arguments on the quantum of punishment.
Manjunath was shot dead at a petrol pump in Gola area in this district after he threatened to cancel the licence of petrol pump owner Pawan Mittal for selling adulterated fuel.
Besides Mittal, the others convicted were Devesh Agnihotri, Sanjay Awasthi, Rakesh Anand, Shivkesh Giri, Rajesh Verma, Harish Mishra and Vivek Sharma. They were present in the court room when the verdict was pronounced.
While Harish Mishra had earlier been enlarged on bail, the rest were in the jail.
The killing of Munjunath had evoked sharp reaction from the industry, IIM students and alumni and several social organisations, which had demanded stern punishment to the guilty.
Earlier, media personnel had to face the ire of the defence lawyers and several of them were forcibly pushed out of the court room as soon as the judge came in to deliver the verdict. Even after the judgement was pronounced, the convicts and a section of the lawyers raised slogans against the large contingent of print and electronic media persons.
Some of the convicts even tried to break the police cordon and move towards the media people while being escorted back to the waiting police van for being transported to the jail but were thwarted by the security personnel.
A day after the murder, Manjunath's body was recovered from a car in Maholi area in the neighbouring Sitapur district. Rakesh Anand and Vivek Sharma, who had gone to Sitapur to dispose of the body, were caught there.
The police filed the chargesheet in the case on February 15, last year and the trial began on March nine. Charges under the IPC and the Arms Act were framed on May 19 and the examination of the witnesses began from June five. As many as 23 witnesses were examined during the trial of whom three turned hostile after having giving their statements to the police.
The court had on March nine last reserved its judgement after the counsel for the prosecution and defence submitted rulings of the Supreme Court and High Courts to buttress their contention.
Father of murdered Indian Oil Corporation (IOC) official S Manjunath, Shanmugham, today expressed ''100 per cent satisfaction'' at the conviction of all the eight accused in the case and said he expected all of them to be hanged to death.
Speaking to UNI here, he lauded the efforts of the judiciary, media and Manjuanth Trust for supporting the case and the subsequent conviction. He also thanked former Union Petroleum Minister Mani Shankar Aiyar who had morally supported the cause.
Manjunath's mother, Pramila, also welcomed the conviction.
Earlier in the day, a Lakhimpur Kheri court convicted all the eight accused in the case and said the quantum of sentence would be announced on March 26.
Manjunath, an IIT-Kanpur graduate and an alumni of IIM (Lucknow), was killed inside the Mittal Automobile Petrol Pump at Gola Gokarn in Lakhimpur Kheri district on November 19, 2005. The whistle blower had reportedly threatened to seal Mittal Automobiles for selling adulterated fuel. (Agencies)
Indian Army to get BrahMos missile this year: Pillai
Moscow:
With the successful completion of tests of the BrahMos, the Indian Army will start inducting the supersonic cruise missile this year, a top official of the Indo-Russian venture that makes the weapon system has said."We will start delivering the BrahMos cruise missiles to the Indian Army in 2007," BrahMos Aerospace CEO Sivathanu Pillai said in an interview to weekly Nezavisimoye Voyennoe Obozrenie (Independent Military Review).
The army will get the missiles mounted on mobile platforms in "large numbers". A total of 13 tests were conducted with the missile jointly developed by India and Russia and the Indian Army was satisfied with its "precision hits", he said.
India and Russia are the only countries possessing a supersonic cruise missile, which will end the era of the much-hyped US Tomahawk cruise missiles, Pillai said.
The Indian Navy has inducted the anti-ship version of the BrahMos. An air-to-surface version is in advanced stages of development and the only task remaining is its integration with the on-board avionics of the platform that will deliver it, he said.
"With a...range of 299 km, the BrahMos cruise missile flies at the speed of 2.8 Mach (almost three times the speed of sound), while the Tomahawk is a subsonic cruise missile with the speed of 0.8 Mach," he said.
The US had effectively used Tomahawks during the Gulf war, but active work has been underway across the world since then to counter the missile. However, there are no means to counter the BrahMos, which is much faster than the Tomahawk.
"India and Russia today have a monopoly in the field and BrahMos will end the era of Tomahawks," Pillai said in his interview published under the title "Moskva river becomes tributary of Brahmaputra to drown the much-hyped Tomahawk".
The name for the missile, a combination of Russia's quiet Moskva river and India's furious Brahmaputra, was suggested by President A P J Abdul Kalam, who initiated the BrahMos project as chief of the Defence Research and Development Organisation. (PTI)
BESU teachers extend support
to victims
nandigram killings
Kolkata:
Condemning the Nandigram police firing, the teachers' of Bengal Engineering and Science University (BESU) on Friday submitted a letter to Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, urging him to withdraw police forces from there.Expressing solidarity with the distressed people of Nandigram, the teachers urged the chief minister to supply relief materials and medical aid to the strife torn area . They also demanded that free access to the affected areas by the press, electronic media and other civil organisations be ensured.
Terming the incident a "state sponsored genocide," BESU members said "we are stunned to learn about the horrendous activities like molestation and rape of womenfolk of the region and killing of innocent people by the goons in connivance with the police force." While the teachers protested against the massacre in Nandigram, West Bengal Gandhi Peace Foundation and West Bengal Sarvodaya Mondal would continue with their peace march in and around Nandigram.
They would also organise a Satyagraha programme on Saturday near the Hospital. Further, the Congress on Friday continued its attack of the Left Front government in West Bengal for the killings in Nandigram.
AICC General Secretary Digvijay Singh, who headed the party's fact-finding team to the troubled spot, had said on Thursday that the incident was "totally local", contrary to the CPI-M's claims that some Maoists were involved.
Singh had said the handling of the situation in Nandigram was due to "insensitive" handling by Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya and the incident took place due to "lack of communication with the local people or arrogance". Singh wanted a judicial inquiry into the incident along with the CBI probe already ordered to unravel the truth.
He said "the magisterial inquiry instituted would not do as there is hardly any difference between government and the CPI-M cadre". (Agencies)
Opp in Bihar seeks Governor's intervention
Patna:
The RJD-led opposition in Bihar, which has been boycotting proceedings of the Assembly for the past 12 days, on Friday sought the governor's intervention to direct the state government to withdraw a censure against it to break the impasseMLAs led by Leader of Opposition Rabri Devi marched to the Raj Bhavan and submitted a memorandum to Governor R S Gavai, seeking a direction from him to the government to withdraw the censure motion passed by the House against the opposition on March 12.
Later, Rabri Devi reiterated the opposition's decision not to attend the assembly till the censure was withdrawn unconditionally.
RJD spokesman Shyam Rajak said the governor had assured an opposition delegation that he would send for the records of the March 12 proceedings of the House and, after perusing them, convene a meeting of opposition MLAs with Speaker Uday Narayan Chaudhary, Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, Deputy Chief Minister Sushil Kumar Modi and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Ramashray Prasad Singh to find a way out of the deadlock. (PTI)
Left split wide open over Nandigram
New Delhi
: The rumblings in the Left Front in West Bengal over the Nandigram police firing refuse to die down as the CPI has now blamed big brother CPI(M) and Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhatta-charjee of keeping the partners in the dark on the issue.In a hard hitting article in CPI organ "New Age", party General Secretary A B Bardhan said the "organised and brutal police assault" on villagers was unprecedented, unbelievable, shocking and traumatic, forcing many to think that time had come to break up the Left Front. "The initial feeling of anguish and disbelief gave way to deep indignation."
Tata’s ‘people’s car’ to dent top-end bikes
NEW DELHI:
The much-touted "people's car" from the stable of Tata Motors could create a major dent in the top-end motorcycle market with its lucrative price tag, which has become a global case study, global consultancy firm JD Power has said.If Tata's are able to get quality and customer satisfaction parameters right, the 'People's Car' could shift buyers from top-end two-wheelers on account of its safety and convenience factors, it said.
"The two-wheeler market in India could see a dent at the top-end because of the Re one-lakh car, but how far reaching will it be, will depend on the product's performance, after sales service and overall customer satisfaction," JD Power Director India Mohit Arora said.
The progress of the car is being monitored by automobile industries across the world for possible replication in different markets.
"The Re one-lakh car is a case study which the whole world is watching. If successful, the car can spark demand in a new segment. Brazil and China are looking for similar products," J D Power Asia Pacific Managing Director Gerrit Kuyntjes said.
The firm, however, cautioned that Tata's would need to get its product right at the first shot as the dynamics of Indian automobile market have changed over the years.
"Unlike the Indica, in which Tata Motor's got a second chance, it is doubtful if it would get a similar one with the Re one-lakh car as consumers have become more discerning and demanding," Arora added.
Even rural customers, one of the main targets of the car are becoming demanding and less forgiving, he said.
Commenting on the Indian passenger car market, Arora said: "The car market would see exciting times ahead with sales volume expected to cross the 1.8 million units mark by 2010." He said the industry would need to focus on cars as a high-value product and needs to retain customers with significant amount of re-purchases coming in.
JD Power, which plans to start its syndicate services in the Indian two-wheeler market, predicted a phase of consolidation of market share as home-grown companies slug it out with foreign competitors.
Predicting a good future for the two-wheeler industry, Arora said, the market would continue to grow as its reach expands into the rural areas.
"Even for the two-wheelers, quality would be paramount as they report three times more problems compared to a four-wheeler." (PTI)
Donkupar presents tax-free Budget
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Deputy Chief Minister Dr Donkupar Roy on Friday presented a tax-free deficit budget of Rs 25.35 crore in the State Assembly for 2007-2008 but promised to slap taxes based on recommendations of Resource Mobilise Committee to mobilise additional resources.
The government hopes to tide over the deficit by borrowings and also by additional resource mobilisation. The total budget stands at Rs 2,732 crore and power sector has been accorded highest priority.
Presenting the budget, Dr Roy said that the total receipt including that of public accounts is Rs 15,219.82 crore against a corresponding expenditure of Rs 15,204.99 crore. Taking into account the opening deficit of Rs 40.18 crore, there will be a closing deficit of Rs 25.35 crore.
Dr Roy said that in the context of increasing revenue expenditure and the need to support plan expenditure through mobilisation of additional resources, a Resource Mobilisation Committee was constituted in December 2006 to examine the ways and means of generating additional resources through taxes and cesses, widening of tax base, imposition of cess for maintenance of roads and plugging loopholes leading to evasion of taxes.
Dr Roy said the committee is expected to submit the report within three month, adding that the recommendations of the committee will help raise more resources for development. On the important areas, Dr Roy said that the topmost priority is given to power sector with a plan outlay of Rs 303 crore.
In the context of power shortage, there needs to be a paradigm shift in the policy frame work in the power sector. He said the power policy of the State is in the advanced stage, adding that the proposed policy will help explore more power projects by MeSEB, Central Undertakings and suitable private partners.
According to Dr Roy, the increasing cost of power purchase, coupled with the uneconomic sale, price of power is threatening the financial health of the Board.
"The average cost of power sold to MeSEB is Rs 4.64 per unit whereas the average sale price is Rs 2.66 per unit resulting in a per unit loss of Rs 1.98," Dr Roy said.
Dr Roy said the improvement of roads is another area of priority and the plan allocation for the sector is Rs 180 crore. He said the Centre has entrusted the work for four-laning of NH 40 from Jorabat to Umiam to the National Highway Authority of India.
Regarding police department, Dr Roy said that a tentative outlay of Rs 4.5 crore is proposed to be earmarked for the State Police. There is a proposal to set up new police stations and upgrade strategic outposts and beat houses in a phased manner.
On education, Dr said that core monitoring teams have been set up at the state and district levels to ensure improvement in the quality of elementary education. The outlay for education is Rs 129 crore.
Highlighting the need to improve health sector, Dr Roy said that construction and upgradation of new sub centre, PHCs and CHCs will be planned as per norms to increase the coverage of health delivery system. The outlay for the health sector is Rs 75 crore.
Other areas of importance are social welfare, agriculture and horticulture, veterinary and animal husbandry and others. Dr Roy further said that the year 2007-08 would be the first year of the Eleventh Five-Year Plan and third year of the Award of the Twelfth Finance Commission.
An outlay of RS 8,695 crore has been projected to the Planning Commission for the Eleventh Plan. The annual plan size fixed by the Planning Commission stands at Rs 1,120 crore. The non-plan estimate is fixed at Rs 1,549 crore.
The Finance Minister said the State's annual average growth rate has been targetted at 7.3 per cent.
Vote on account
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
The State Assembly on Friday passed vote on account for three months amounting to Rs 8.71 crore.Highlights
l
7.3 percent growth rate targetNCP deplores Budget
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG
: The Opposition NCP on Friday said the State Budget has nothing special to offer to the common people saying that it was just a routine exercise. "There is no plan for the future of the State in the budget," NCP legislator Edmund Sangma said.He added that the government's clear cut action plan should have been reflected the budget.
However, he admitted that there is a "small increase" in the budget allocation.
"But the increase will not be sufficient to meet the requirements," Mr Sangma said.
CCIB asks NBCC to stop fencing work
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Irked by continued border fencing carried out by the National Building Construction Corporation (NBCC), five NGOs under the banner of Coordination Committee on International Border (CCIB) have asked the NBCC to stop the fencing work before March 26.A CCIB meeting between top leaders of KSU, FKJGP, SSSS, HNYF and Federal Council of Ri-War Mihngi and War Jaintia (FCRWMWJ) here on Friday decided to issue "quit notice" to the NBCC and the concerned contractors fencing work is not stopped within the "deadline".
"We will ask the NBCC to leave the State if they fail to meet our demand," CCIB spokesman GH Kharshanlor said.
The NBCC has been continuing activities including earthwork and laying of foundation for erection of border fence in Huroi near Umkiang, Jaintia Hills, he alleged.
The CCIB spokesman also accused the Corporation of openly violating the direction of the State government to keep the fencing work in abeyance till the issue was resolved.
However, he informed that the CCIB is awaiting the response of the State Government on the date for the second visit to Nongjri and Pyrdiwah to assess the problem faced by land owners due to the proposed fencing work.
Contractors lament Govt inaction
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
The All Meghalaya Contractors' and Suppliers' Association (AMCSA) has said that there was no indication of any action by the State Government to release the pending bills of contractors."The State Government till now has done nothing with regards to our demand for release of pending bills," AMCSA president Dino DG Dympep said here on Friday adding that due to inaction by authorities to settle the issue, most contractors are frustrated and have doubt of getting any payment by March 31.
Stating that the AMCSA would decide its "drastic course of action" at its meeting on March 26 at PWD Barik Compound, Mr Dympep said that the delay of the officials of both Planning and Finance departments to clear the payment had exposed the insincerity of the State government despite its assurances to solve the tangle.
Meanwhile, most of the contractors have threatened to resort to destruction of works executed by them in both PWD and PHE departments in case the authorities fail to clear their bills within this financial year ending on March 31. They have also said that they could no longer wait as their livelihood had been affected.
Molestation verdicts
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Two persons were sentenced to imprisonment by a fast track court here in connection with two separate molestation cases, a delayed report said.In the first case, Alloyius Rynjah alias Makoh of Mawlai Nongpdeng was sentenced to two years of simple imprisonment for molesting two minors on May 23, 2004, at Mawlai Nongpdeng.
The fast track court sentenced another person involved in the rape of a 12-years-old girl at Nongsyrngan village near Pynursla on May 30, 2004, to seven-year imprisonment and imposed a fine of Rs 2000.
More charm to Statehood Day
urged
In
Assembly
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
The need for more imaginative Meghalaya Day on every January 21 in a befitting manner was brought to the notice of the House on Friday by Independent legislator Manas Chaudhuri.Moving a cut motion, Mr Chaudhuri said that since the statehood day on January 21 is a red letter day for the State, there should be some special and innovative programmes on the day.
Highlighting the purpose of Meghalaya Day celebration, Mr Chaudhuri said that the Day is an occasion to remember how the hill state came into being and the people's commitment to the State.
The fruits of sacrifice and unity of the people shown in 1972 should be highlighted in every Meghalaya Day celebrations, he said adding that there is a feeling of fragmentation and suspicion in the minds of the people.
"I also don't find any enthusiasm among the people during the celebrations," Mr Chaudhuri deplored.
According to him, January 21 is also an occasion to re-dedicate ourselves to work for the progress of State.
Mr Chaudhuri also wanted the government to involve more youth in the State during the Meghalaya Day celebrations so that they can showcase their talents. He stressed the need for associating Meghalayan NRIs and those outside the State.
In his reply, Chief Minister DD Lapang agreed with the contentions and said the celebrations of Meghalaya Day should be organized in a more befitting way.
GSU calls off night road blockade
From Our Correspondent
TURA:
The Garo Students' Union (GSU) has called off its night road blockade from Friday following invitation by Chief Minister DD Lapang for talks to be held on Monday in his office chamber in Shillong. This was informed by the Union's president, Mr Andreas T Sangma over phone.According to him, the Union's agitation is being called off temporarily in response to the Chief Minister's invitation for talks.
Constable held on murder charge
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
One constable was arrested on Friday for his alleged involvement in the murder of one Banteilang Kharsohnoh and seriously injuring one Raymond Umdor on Wednesday night at Iew Mawlong.Earlier, the constable, Hordor Kharkylliang, attempted suicide by stabbing himself for the fear of being caught, police said.
Police seized his service revolver, suspected to be used in the crime, and three empty cases of .38 ammunition recovered from his house. A case is also registered by the police against the constable.
Opp grills Govt on FIR delay
Housing scam
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Opposition on Friday questioned the government for the delay in filing FIR on the Housing scam in Garo Hills. It transpired during question hour that High Court directive was only complied with after four months.Replying to a question by Manas Chaudhuri (Ind), C&RD Minister Charles Pyngrope said that the High Court on November 14 directed the State Government to file case against those involved.
He said that the FIR was filed on March 6 and the final report was awaited. He said that the government had already initiated action against three Block Development Officers - Dr A Roy, MD Sangma and J Lakiang and one NGO, Gambil.
Mr Pyngrope said that the delay in the filing of FIR was because the State had directed for a magisterial inquiry by the Deputy Commissioner and an inquiry by the Anti Corruption Branch of the State Government, which is awaited.
According to Mr Pyngrope, the government is taking necessary steps to ensure that there should not be any further delay in action.
"It is not true that there is laxity in taking action against those involved," Mr Pyngrope said. With regard to taking action against other lower rank officers like project director and engineers involved in the scam, Mr Pyngrope said that necessary action would be taken once the report is completed.
‘Meghalaya security scenario bad’
From Our Spl Correspondent
NEW DELHI: The Centre on Friday reiterated that the internal security situation in once peaceful Meghalaya has deteriorated in the year gone by even while the overall situation in the region has improved.
The Union Home Ministry in its annual report for 2006 revealed that the number of violent incidents in Meghalaya has increased so also the civilians' death toll. On the other hand the number of extremist killed has come down to 20 in 2006 compared to 23 in 2005.
During the last Parliament session, the Union Home Minister, Mr Shivraj Patil had announced the same thing on the floor of the House. The overall security scenario in the entire North East has improved, the Home Ministry report said.
"The Government is well aware of the sliding situation in some parts of the country including the NE region and has adopted a multi-pronged strategy to tone up internal security in the country," the report said.
Explaining the Centre's policy to deal with internal security, the report said additional battalions of para-military forces were being raised to enhance the strength of law enforcing agencies. Intelligence agencies were being strengthened at the national and state levels.
The Government was keen on removing economic disparities and improving infrastructure. Several steps have been taken for overall improvement of the economic situation in the isolated NE, the report said.
In the insurgency hit NE region the government has also initiated peace process with some of the outfits, which came for talks, the report said. ANVC is one such outfit with which the Government has entered into a ceasefire.
Several steps have been taken for overall improvement of the economic situation in the isolated NE, the report said.
Health Dept all out to tackle malaria
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
In a bid to combat the threat of malaria before the onset of summer, Health Minister Deborah C Marak on Friday had a meeting with District Health and Medical Officers (DHMO) and District Malaria Officers (DMO) to work out strategies to deal with the disease.According to Mrs Marak, the meeting focused on malaria prone areas in Garo Hills, Ri-Bhoi and border areas of West Khasi Hills which witnessed maximum number of malaria deaths in the past. The meeting also took stock of the problems faced by doctors and paramedics in dealing with the disease.
"The meeting discussed the steps to prevent malaria in time before it could take a toll on precious lives this summer. We have worked out strategies and steps for better coordination between all health personnel and doctors in rural areas to combat the disease," Mrs Marak said.
The Health Minister also said that administering of anti-malarial drugs, regular spraying of DDT and training of health workers would be taken up in all malaria-prone areas of the State. She also said that district health officials would cover all the Blocks and submit weekly reports to the Health department on action taken by them to deal with the disease.
"I will review the reports block-wise every two months," Mrs Marak said adding that publicity on malaria prevention besides campaign to educate people in rural areas about the disease would be carried out in all the districts so as to remove superstition and discourage people's confidence on quacks.
Stating that problems were being faced by doctors and health workers posted in rural areas due to mobility problem, topography and shortage of manpower in several Primary Health Centres (PHC) and Community Health Centres (CHC).
Mrs Marak, however, maintained that there is "adequate" stock of anti-malaria medicines.
It may be mentioned that hundreds of people in Garo Hills and border areas of West Khasi Hills died of malaria in 2006.
According to official reports, 157 people died during the year due to the disease, which is the highest compared to 41 deaths in 2005.
State awaits dropout pattern
in
assembly
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Higher and Technical Education Minister Mr RG Lyngdoh said that the State govt is awaiting the report of the survey conducted by NEHU to assess the drop out pattern and its causes in the State.
Replying to a question raised by Mr E K Sangma, (NCP), Mr R G Lyngdoh said that the report would provide information on how the state can prepare a comprehensive plan to improve the learning environment.
This can be done by training untrained teachers, organising orientation programme for teachers, granting of opening permission to schools in rural areas, grant in aid to adhoc schools for qualified science teachers, provision for science equipments, appointment of teachers with B Ed, computer education, bridging infrastructure gap and others, the Minister said.
He also pointed out that Midday meals and free text books are being disbursed to schools students.
The Minister said that there has been a marked improvement in the enrollment of students - lower primary, upper primary, secondary, higher secondary - while comparing the records of enrolment with that of the previous years.
Replying to another supplementary question , Mr Lyngdoh said that monitoring of schools' activities are being done by the Inspector and Deputy Inspector of Schools
Delhi officers
Chief Minister DD Lapang said that though there were no officers on contract basis appointed in Delhi, one Mr Sharif Laskar was appointed as Public Relations Secretary to the Chief Minister located in Delhi to assist the Chief Minister. The salary is Rs 4,000 per month.
Replying to questions by Mr PT Sawkmie(MDP), and Mr PM Syiem ( Ind), Mr Lapang said he government will look into the creation of a separate cell in Delhi to have better liaison.
Govt to speed up power projects
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Deputy Chief Minister (also in-charge of Power) Dr Mukul Sangma said that the State has adopted a strategy to achieve the target of many pending power projects by the 11th Five Year Plan. Replying to a question by EK Sangma (NCP), Dr Sangma said that the government had projected many power schemes to tide over power crisis.Answering supplementary questions by Manas Chaudhuri (Ind), PT Sawkmie (MDP), TN Marak (Congress) and PM Syiem (Ind), Dr Sangma said that the Nagalbibra thermal power project and the Ganol hydel project would be taken up on a priority basis.
While the Ganol hydel power project is expected to start by the next financial year, the Nangalbibra thermal power project is at the conceptualisation stage as the government is "keeping its options open", Dr Sangma said.
He said that for tapping power, the government was undecided on whether to follow a joint venture or a Public Private Partnership or Independent Power Producers.
Dr Sangma said that with finalisation of the draft power policy and corporatisation of MeSEB, the power scenario could be improved. Giving projected figures worth crores for various upcoming power projects, Dr Sangma said that with the commissioning of the projects, the department could provide adequate power.
To another supplementary, Dr Sangma said that there was no major power project in Garo Hills for the last few years. Dr Sangma reiterated that the government had not messed up the State Power department but admitted that there are constraints. He assured that the government would not waste time for implementation of power projects.
The Power Minister assured the House that steps would be taken to exploit all the potentialities for generating power. Till then, the State will be in a position to draw power from the Grid and Central bodies, he added.
ADM’s action condemned
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: The Dorbar Shnong Diengiong near Mawdiangdiang has condemned the recent action of Additional District Magistrate T Lyngwa who "forcefully" raided the house and plot of land owned by local resident Mrs Thwintina Mawrie adjacent to NEIGRIHMS hospital. The Durbar Shong has also sought clarification from the authorities on the action of the ADM and his refusal to cooperate with the Durbar Shnong on the matter.
15 cave passages discovered
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Fifteen new cave passages were explored by the international cave explorers recently in Jaintia Hills during the 2007 International Caving Expedition organised by the Meghalaya Adventures Association last month.
The team comprised of 1 Austrian, Welsh, Scottish, Swiss, American and Canadian, 4 Germans 15 English and 4 Irish, besides members of the Association.
The exploration focussed on the caving areas of the Shnongrim/Nongkhlieh Ridge near to Shnongrim village, Sutnga Elaka, the Lukha Valley and Semasi Areas to the North East.
Mukhim assures strict PDS monitoring
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Civil Supplies Minister Mr Martle Mukhim on Friday assured the state assembly that strict monitoring measures will be initiated to plug the loopholes in PDS.
Continuing with his reply to a cut motion moved by Mr Manas Chaudhuri (Ind), Mr Mukhim said that the Department has proposed to introduce an efficient method of monitoring the Public Distribution System in the State.
To extend its services to the citizens effectively, a state-of-art solution called TETRAPDS. (Targetted Efficient Transparent Rationing and Allocation Public Distribution System) developed by NIC team,Kerala was developed for the Department of Food and Civil Supplies. He said there are efforts to create awareness amongst the public consumers on the implementation PDS in the state in collaboration with the National Service Scheme and North Eastern Hill University.
The Directorate of Audio Visual Publicity, Government of India, Regional Office Guwahati has also been asked to arrange publicity campaign for PDS in all the Blocks.
Regarding the proper implementation of PDS, Mr Mukhim said that he would take corrective action to ensure that PDS commodities reach the target group for whom they are meant.
He also assured that names of the monitoring committees will be made available to the legislators. He said revision of ration cards and fresh enumeration of BLP families will also be undertaken by the department. After this assurance, Mr Chaudhuri withdrew the cut motion.
Govt policy to regulate pvt educational institutions soon
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Higher and technical Education Minister Mr R G Lyngdoh informed the State Assembly on Friday that the state government has approached the West Bengal, Asom and other Northeastern States for tips from their education policy on how to regulate private educational institutions.
Replying to a question by Mr P T Sawmie (MDP), Mr Lyngdoh said that the state government would soon frame an education policy in the lines of West Bengal, Asom and other Northeastern States, soon to regulate the mushrooming of private schools and colleges.
The Education Minister said that having a policy would, besides regulation, take into account the need to have proper service rules of teachers, teachers emolument and infrastructure development.
Replying to a supplementary question by Mr P M Syiem (Ind) on government's intervention on the school fees hike in private institutions, Mr Lyngdoh said that the government is controlling only schools that are availing aid from it.
On the the possibilities of investment in Education sector, Mr Lyngdoh said that investments are welcome but the policy will not deter investment.
Replying to a question raised by Mr Manas Chaudhuri (Ind), the Education Minister said that opening permission for schools by the government is not mandatory.
On private schools that had asked for funds from DONER or NEC, Mr Lyngdoh said the government is just routing the appeal of the private institutions through the state planning department.
RANK and BOLT awards presented
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Air India and The Shillong Times RANK and BOLT Awards for 2006 were presented here on Friday at an impressive function held at State Central Library.
Bryan Wahlang, Anthony Bansuklang Khongsit and Mandakini Hazarika were conferred with top honours in recognition of excellence in the field of personal excellence and practicing professionalism.
It may be mentioned that altogether 12 awards were conferred to the students and teachers at the National, State and District level. The RANK award is given to the student achievers while the BOLT is awarded to teachers.
Addressing the gathering on the occasion, Governor MM Jacob lauded the Air India and The Shillong Times for taking the initiative in recognising excellence in the field of academics.
However, he said that students of this region are better than those in other parts of the country as they are more professional in their attitude and possess excellent communication skill.
Urban Affairs Minister Paul Lyngdoh who was the Guest of Honour, called upon the students to open their mind to achieve higher goals.
" It is the students who can transform Meghalaya to one of the major power houses of the country which will allow the State to march ahead in all spheres."
On the occasion, Mr Jacob and Mr Lyngdoh also distributed prizes to the various winners. Others who spoke on the occasion included The Shillong Times editor Mr Manas Chaudhuri, General Manager of Air India Mr SK Kolekar and Commercial Manager Mr AK Tirkey.
Roy remebers Mahatma Gandhi in city Khadi show
By Our Reporter
Shillong:
A ten-day State Level Exhibition on Rural Employment Generation Units and Khadi Mela, jointly organized by the Meghalaya Khadi Village and Industries Board and Khadi Village and Industries Commission was inaugurated by the Meghalaya Deputy Chief Minister Dr. Donkupar Roy on Friday at State Central Library. Also present at the function was the Chairman, MKVIB, Mr. Draishon Kharshiing.Speaking on the occasion Dr. Donkupar Roy stated that by holding this programme, a respectful tribute is being paid to Mahatma Gandhi who is regarded as the chief inspiration and motive force of the modern day Khadi.
He further said that Gandhi had the welfare of the humble rural folk at the centre of his concern and sought to relief the economic misery of the Indian countryside by advocating the use of the improved charkha and other rudimentary but effective technologies to boost traditional skills and crafts, thereby generating additional employment and income for the villages in a sustainable, eco-friendly manner.

Plan targets
The Finance Minister may disagree and pin his hope for a 10 per cent economic growth during the 11th Five-Year Plan, beginning April 1, 2007, but the Planning Commission has already started to sing a different tune. In fact, the deputy chairman, Montek Singh Ahluwalia's latest admission that "there are signs of overheating in the economy and the nine per cent economic growth rate is putting pressure on inflation" carries a sense of concern, if not disappointment, with the way the government is managing the inflation and how it may impact the real growth rate. Inflation seems to have changed the future growth scenario of the economy. In fact, too much is being made of the 11th Plan growth targets despite the fact that all these talks of targets and growth rate will bear little meaning after two years if the Congress-led UPA government fails to return to power in 2009 when the next Lok Sabha elections are due. Depending upon the results of some of the state elections to be held in the interim period and the attitude of the UPA allies and their outside supporters such as the Left group towards the Congress leadership, the national elections may even be preponed. Any change in the political face of the next government may make the current 11th Plan document meaningless. It has happened in the past. A changed government rarely pursues the economic agenda of its predecessor.
As things stand now, the Plan targets and a forecast of the average nine per cent economic growth rate in the next five-year period sounds a bit over-optimistic. The current double digit inflation in terms of the consumer price index is certainly a matter of concern. Ahluwalia blames the "signs of overheating in the economy" on inflation, which, he says, "has been brought under control" through a slew of fiscal and monetary measures. At the same time, he admits that measures to curb inflation may put pressure on high growth "initially." What he means is obvious. The economic growth target may not be achievable in the next two years as a result of certain anti-inflationary measures such as higher cost of borrowing from banks and the sucking up of excess liquidity in the market by manipulating the cash reserves ratio (CRR) and statutory liquidity ratio (SLR). These steps may lead to a melt down of the economic growth. Thus, the responsibility of covering any interim short fall in the economic growth rate rests on the next national government. And, that is clever. The government seems to have forgotten that the basic goal of the economic reform is to efficiently manage the supply side in order to bring maximum happiness to its people, especially the common man. The current inflation is the result of the government's obsession with the revenue growth and demand control.
Sachar report highly flawed
By Dr. Nitish Sengupta, IAS (Retd)
The Sachar Committee Report, a 404 page document, I must confess, has been extremely disappointing, both in its method of analysis and in the way it has collected and presented some dubious statistics. A fundamental fact that has been ignored is that almost 95 per cent of the elite community among the Muslims in India, who largely depended on jobs, went wholesale over to Pakistan following partition in search of better job prospects. Those who stayed back in India were, by and large, the rural community, the self-employed and the service providers. The great majority of them, under the influence of powerful section of Mullahs, kept away from modern education and, in consequence, modern jobs and professions. Thus, the figures for Muslim percentage in government jobs etc. practically started from a zero base. This point should have been mentioned somewhere in the Committee's overall analysis. Its total omission is a serious statistical error.
Then again, the Committee has conveniently ignored the fact that the social and economic position of a community does not necessarily depend on the jobs that its members hold in the Government or in the organized sector. If that had been the case, I am afraid, the position of the Parsees, to take one example, would be extremely backward. What the Sachar Committee's report has ignored completely is the fact that there is a much larger number of self-employed people, tradesmen, service providers among the Muslims who do not necessarily seek government jobs. The fact that those who were left behind after partition, by and large, did not go to the portals of higher education and professional education, nor applied in adequate numbers for government jobs, is a very important factor in making an analysis of the subject that was assigned to the Sachar Committee.
Where it has gone completely wrong is in creating an impression as if the whole educational and economic system in this country had gone out of its way to exclude the Muslims. In actual fact, we have all gone out of our way vis a vis qualified Muslims and have also gone out of our way to give placement to them wherever they would merit selection. There are indeed, some very serious errors on the statistical front. In a seminar held at India International Centre recently on this subject by the Society for Applied Research in Humanities, Prof. A.R. Hashim pointed out that, in looking at the position of the Hindus in general, the Sachar Committee first excluded the Scheduled Castes and the Dalits from the general Hindu community and then compared them with the Muslim community. Now the same Committee has pointed out that the position of the Scheduled Castes and Dalits etc. is little or no different from that of the Muslim community. To exclude such a big chunk from the Hindu community and thereafter compare the residual Hindu community with the Muslims is a serious oversight, if not mischievous.
In the same seminar, another Muslim scholar, Prof. Imtiaz Hussain, also trashed the report on the ground that it has ignored the status of the Muslims in terms of jobs held in all the South Indian States and also in a few other States like Gujarat and West Bengal. He forcefully pointed out that in all the Southern States the Muslims are much better off than what the Sachar Report has made them to be. He questioned the dubious statistics presented by the Sachar Committee in preference to the Census data which definitely shows that the Muslims are better off in many of the States of India than what has been pointed out.
Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, Chief Minister of West Bengal has also pointed out that the report ignores the position of the Muslim peasantry, who benefited from the State's land reforms programme. Insofar as the organized private sector is concerned, one point which has escaped the Committee's attention is that many of our business organizations are still dominated by the caste system. Consequently, a company dominated by banias generally looks out for banias. In that process also, the Muslim and minorities tend to suffer as much as the people belonging to the other Hindu castes. This need not necessarily be viewed as anti-Muslim bias.
Clearly, Justice Sachar simply chose to ignore the entire available evidence to show that the Muslim community is not doing much better than the other communities, which the Committee has made out to be. He should have taken into account the examples like Azim Premji, Chairman WIPRO, the richest corporate Indian, Habil Khorakiwala of Wockhardt, the CIPRA group or, for that matter, so many industries run very prosperously by the Muslims, the cases of people like Habib Rahman, Chairman ITC Hotels, Israt Hussain a top associate of Ratan Tata and many other such examples. He should also have objectively made a community-wise analysis of the employees of such successful enterprises as Azim Premji's WIPRO. Is merit their main criterion for recruitment? Does this amount to discrimination and anti-Muslim bias a la Sachar Report? Or do successful Muslim industrialists reserve jobs for fellow Muslims irrespective of their merit.
I need not speak of so many leading Muslims who have held high posts in the Government, people like Dr. A.R. Kidwai, Musa Raza, Abid Hussain and many others. Similarly, I wish the Sachar Committee had taken into account all the brass manufacturers and traders of Moradabad, the glass workers of Ferozabad, the textiles operators of Bhiwandi, the carpet makers of Kashmir, the Zari workers of Varanasi and other places. Such examples are galore. Sadly, however, these examples do not find any mention in the Sachar Report which chose to concentrate only on certain levels of Government jobs and worked out the position of the Muslims only on that account.
That is not all. The Committee has not taken into account the overwhelming eminent position occupied by the Muslims in Mumbai's film industry, including the fact that the top actors and actresses are almost 50 per cent Muslims, if not more. Does that smack of discrimination? Even Shiv Sena supremo Bal Thackeray has never spoken about this fact or complained about it.
It remains a mystery as to why the Government did not think it appropriate to assign this work to the National Minorities Commission or even to its own Department of Minority Affairs and, instead, chose to appoint a separate committee. Equally mysterious is the fact that without choosing to discuss this matter in the country's sovereign Parliament or allowing for informed debate, the Government has announced that it has accepted all the recommendations of the Sachar Committee. At this stage, an Action Taken Report cannot also be far off.
Neither the Government of India nor the largely Indian nation deserves the accusation by the Sachar Committee that they have been anti-Muslims all these years. The Report has to be held flawed and dismissed as a highly subjective document on this account.
Taken all together, one has to come to the sad conclusion that the Committee has erred both in its analysis and its conclusions. Mr. Justice Rajinder Sachar has been a very respected friend for many many years. But, I am afraid, in this report he has side stepped from the position of a judge and taken on the role of a lawyer who has been assigned a certain brief and has only collected whatever evidence suited that brief!---INFA (The author is a former member Lok Sabha and formerly member-secretary Planning Commission)
Poetry as Investment
By Adil Jussawalla
This piece will make sense mainly to those to whom poetry makes sense. Ranjit Hoskote tells me that the number of such people is growing. How nice. I can assure you that there are a number of people familiar with the names of the poets I’m about to mention than there were, say, five years ago.
But let's talk, once again, not about who reads poets but who publishes them. Between 1952 and 1982, Nissim Ezekiel brought out seven books of poems.
How many people know that he paid for five of them to be published? Agha Shahid Ali paid for his first two books to be published.
So did Suniti Namjoshi and Meena Alexander. Gopal Honnalgere was not alone in having to pay for practically all his nine books.
My point in mentioning a few names from a long list — it includes me — is not to single them out as pathetic examples of what the public calls "vanity publishing", but to show that such a form of publishing has been vital to the survival and growth of many of our best-known poets.
After all, the marketing possibilities of Indian fiction in English changed after Midnight's Children, but not those, perceptibly, of poetry.
The publishing scene here would be inconceivable and greatly impoverished if poets didn't have to publish themselves. So would the history of Indian poetry in post-Independence India.
It's quite likely, for instance, that Arun Kolatkar's Jejuri, now a New York Review of Books classic, would have remained an uncollected poem-sequence, like The Boatride, available only in anthologies, had not a group of poets formed Clearing House in the mid-seventies.
If my claim sounds bizarre, consider this: Those who gain from this state of affairs, apart from poets, are those who believe that poetry doesn't sell for our big publishers.
The anthologies they publish are filled with work that first saw the light of day in books they rejected as bad investments, but which, when used selectively in anthologies, brought them steady profits.
Isn't it time publishers changed their line from 'Poetry doesn't sell' to 'Poetry doesn't sell but somehow the poetry we publish in our anthologies sells very well indeed?' (By arrangement with The Times of India)
Why this delay!
Sir,
Referring to a number of news reports regarding delay in placing of the judicial inquiry reports on the twin massacre at Tura and Williamnagar in Garo Hills in Assembly, the same government was in power almost 18 months ago when the incidents took place. The same government constituted two separate judicial commissions, on public demand, to investigate them. Now the same government is delaying the tabling of those reports in the Assembly against the demand for it coming from various quarters, and against wishes of the people of Garo Hills who have the right to know everything about how and what happened on that fateful day - September 30, 2005. The government has neither come out with any reason for the delay nor given any date for tabling the twin reports. It is again acting as irresponsibly as it did at the time of killings.
The investigation on the most recent killings at Nandigram in West Bengal that took place on March 14, 2007 was handed over to the CBI. The CBI has already submitted its preliminary report to the High Court.
Yours etc.,
M M Sangma,
Via e-mail
Excess billing
Sir,
This is with reference to the "shortcut to KBC contest" conducted by Airtel for its subscribers. In the light of the directive issued by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) ref no. F.No.305-8/2004-QOS ,Dated 3rd May, 2005 ,wherein it has been clearly mentioned and I quote "the Authority in exercise of its power conferred upon it under Section 13 read with Section 11 (1) (b) (i) and (v) of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 and clause 9 and 11 of the Telecommunication Tariff order 1999 ,all the Cellular Mobile Service Providers and Unified Access Service Providers are to publish in all communications/ advertisements relating to premium rate services, the pulse rate/ tariff for the service" , it is apparent Airtel has violated this directive as they have failed to mention the premium rate for this particular contest when sending the details of the contest to subscribers mobile phones. As a result the subscribers come to know about this only at the time of final billing causing much distress. I myself am a victim of this. My bill was excess of Rs 3000 because of the premium charge of Rs 6 being charged for the SMS. In all of Airtel's advertisements, all KBC related SMS/calls are said to be charged at Rs 2.40 and not Rs 6. Even when I called Airtel's customer care to enquire about the rates I was told all KBC related SMS/calls are charged at Rs 2.40.
Yours etc.,
Rosamma Mathew,
Via e-mail

From Our Correspondent
Guwahati:
The proscribed ULFA on Friday refuted a media repots about the insurgent group hatching a sinister design to carry out serial blasts in the state in coordination with Pakistani ISI.Refuting the allegation leveled by the India Army official, the ULFA stated that the militant group which had already lost over 10,000 of its dedicated cadres in the armed struggle for ‘restoration of sovereignty of Assam’ would not require help of the ISI to continue its struggle against ‘Indian occupational forces’.
The ULFA military spokesman termed the Indian Army allegation ‘fictitious and not based on facts’ and a part of conspiracy by the Army to carry out subversion in the stare and blame the same on the ULFA. The insurgent group warned the people of Assam to remain alert against such design. The ULFA stated that it was still enough to carry on with its struggle on its own and that it was an imaginary idea that it would take help of the ISI. The police suspect that many ISI operatives are in the State threatening peace.
Manipur bandh
Imphal
: A 12-hour Manipur bandh called by some hill-based organisations to protest alleged arrest of some villagers by Myanmar Army evoked mixed response on Friday, official reports said. (PTI)
National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |
Make This Your
HomePage! |
About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery
Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.