News  of 1st April  2007

National | Shillong | International | Editorial | Regional | Sports 

  Arjun vows to get quota stay vacated

New Delhi/Ahmedabad: Buffeted by pressure from its allies and other pro-reservationists, the government on Saturday night said it would work for getting the stay on the OBC quota in elite educational institutions vacated and hold consultations with all parties on a fresh census demanded by the Supreme Court.

On a day when UPA allies sought to put pressure with a shut down in Tamil Nadu and Puducherry and Human Resource Development Minister Arjun Singh, who was booed by anti- reservationists, said the government would act "straight away" in approaching the apex court for vacation of the stay.

His colleague, Law Minister H R Bhardwaj, said in Bangalore the government would defend the law enabling a 27 per cent quota for OBCs with "full force" in the court. "The power of judicial review is to be for the people and not against the people," Bhardwaj said.

Ruling out any confrontation and refusing to use any strong against the Supreme Court, Singh told PTI: "The Supreme Court has not rejected anything...We will take all Constitutional measures to get the stay vacated."

On the apex court's stand that the 1931 caste census could not be the basis for reservation now and on the constitution of a new commission, Singh said a decision would have to be taken on the basis of political consensus.

Singh will meet legal officers, including Additional Solicitor General Gopal Subramaniam, to discuss the issue.

Making clear the government's intention to provide equity in access to higher education, he said an all-party meeting will be convened by the prime minister after the SAARC summit to deliberate the issue. "Unless all parties are on board, nothing can be done," he said.

Meanwhile, the Indian Institute of Management here on Saturday indicated that admissions under the quota for OBCs may not be implemented in the coming academic year.

"We will not violate the law of the land if the Supreme Court does not vacate the stay (on the 27 per cent quota for OBCs)," said industrialist Vijaypath Singhania, who today took over as chairman of IIM-Ahmedabad.

Speaking to reporters after chairing a meeting of the IIM-A board, he said: "The view taken by the board was that if they give admission to the OBCs now, it may amount to contempt of court.

Left sources said the meeting of the Left-UPA Coordination Committee could be held on April five. This will be followed by an all-party meeting in the next few days.

"It is a very serious issue that the court has stayed a near unanimous legislation of Parliament. While it is the right of the legislature to make laws, it is a right of the judiciary to interpret them. We think this delicate balance has now come into question," CPM leader Sitaram Yechury said. (PTI)

Court asks Centre, Asom Govt to file affidavits on ULFA cadres

Guwahati: The Gauhati High Court has directed the Central and Asom governments to file affidavits with the list of ULFA cadres handed over by Bhutan to India following the Himalayan kingdom's military operation against the banned group in 2003.

A division bench comprising acting Chief Justice D Biswas and Justice B P Kataky has asked for the affidavits to be submitted by April 12.

The court issued the fresh orders as it was not satisfied with documents submitted by Additional Solicitor General H Rahman in response to its order on March 13 to furnish information about "missing" ULFA cadres.

The court had then directed the Central and Asom governments to produce the original and authentic list of ULFA cadres who were handed over by the Bhutan government after the crackdown on ULFA camps in the Himalayan kingdom.

The wives of six ULFA militants began a fast-unto-death on March 21 to demand information about their "missing" husbands. They were arrested on Friday on the charge of attempting to commit suicide and violating prohibitory orders. (PTI)

Centre hints at law to overcome SC order

New Delhi: Under strong pressure from its allies like the DMK, PMK and Left parties, the Centre on Friday hinted at a fresh law to circumvent the Supreme Court's stay on the quota for OBCs in elite educational institutions.

"Taking note of the recent developments, we reiterate the UPA government's resolve to ensure that there is no compromise with (the) commitment towards social justice," the Human Resources Development ministry said in a statement after a meeting of the Congress core group headed by party President Sonia Gandhi disussed the issue.

"The UPA government is committed to make appropriate laws in this regard," the statement said.

It noted that the 93rd amendment of the Constitution, "adopted with near unanimity by Parliament, provides for equity in access to higher education for the weaker sections -- the Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled Tribes and the Other Backward Classes".

"The government is weighing all legal options available. The UPA allies, the Left parties and other political parties will also be consulted on the issue at the earliest," it said.

The statement came a day after the apex court stayed the 27 per cent quota for OBCs in Central educational institutions like the IIMs and IITs, sparking protests by the Left and allies of the UPA.

Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi wrote to the prime minister and presiding officers of both Houses of Parliament to convene a session immediately to discuss the situation. The DMK-led ruling coalition in Tamil Nadu has called a bandh on Saturday in the state.

Referring to the government's commitment to enact "appropriate laws" to ensure equity in access to higher education, the ministry's statement said: "The boundaries of such laws are laid down in the Constitutional provision of Article 15(5)."

The Central Educational Institutions (Reservation in Admission) Act of Parliament was enacted as part of the UPA government's commitment towards social justice.

The UPA Coordination Committee and Left parties had resolved on May 23, 2006 that the "93rd Amendment to the Constitution, providing for reservations in educational institutions, will be implemented by the Central government in letter and spirit", the statement noted.

Meanwhile, a group of government law college students took out a 'funeral procession,' of the Supreme Court stay on the 27 per cent reservation for OBCs in higher educational institutes, in the city. About 50 students carried a 'pall,' symbolising taking of funeral of the Apex Court stay and marched from Gandhipuram bus stand to the District Collectorate. (PTI)

No troop reduction: Azad

Jammu: Ruling out troop reduction in Jammu and Kashmir, Chief Minister Ghulam Nabi Azad on Friday said the slaying of five Hindus by militants in Rajouri district in the wee hours should serve as an eye-opener to those demanding demilitarisation.

"Militancy in the state still exists. This has been proved by the Rajouri incident which should serve as a lesson to those advocating demilitarisation," he told reporters here.

"Militancy is playing hide and seek and people should not be deceived by its rise and fall," Azad said after visiting the injured at the military hospital here.

"No political party should, therefore, interfere in security aspects. In this environment of killings of minority community members, how can we think of troop withdrawal," he said.

"I have always emphasised that troop reduction will take place when militancy will totally end in the state," Azad said.

No political interference would not be allowed even in routine relocation of troops, the Chief Minister asserted. Praising security forces, he said they were playing a useful role in protecting lives and property of the people, particularly in remote and far-flung areas in the state.

"They will continue to do so in future as well," Azad said.

In a pre-dawn attack, militants shot dead five Hindus and wounded four in Rajouri district, defence officials said.

Condemning the Rajouri incident, the BJP demanded dismissal of the Ghulam Nabi Azad government saying it had failed to protect lives of minorities in the state.

Slamming the state government for failing to turn down the demilitarisation demand effectively, state BJP chief Ashok Khajuria alleged the killings took place due to "slow troop withdrawal" in Rajouri district recently.

People in far-flung areas were living at the mercy of militants, he said demanding sacking of the Azad government.

The state BJP chief said a party delegation had met the Governor and demanded dismissal of the state government. (PTI)

Prosecution to challenge acquittal of two in 1984 riots case

New Delhi: The prosecution is likely to challenge the acquittal of two persons including a woman accused in a 1984-anti Sikh riots case in which three others were sentenced to life imprisonment by a Delhi court on Thursday.

Y P S Ahaluwalia, chief public prosecutor of Karkardooma courts, who demitted his office on Friday, has advised Delhi Police to challenge the acquittal of Suraj Giri and Kamlesh, lone woman accused, saying the charges against them were similar in nature to that of the three convicts.

Ahaluwalia said since the conviction of the three was based on eye-witness account of complainant Harminder Kaur, acquittal of two others could be challenged in the High Court as she, in her testimony, had identified all the five as part of the rioting mob. (PTI)

Cops hurt in jail riot
Probe ordered

Meerut: At least seven policemen were on Friday injured during a clash with inmates of the Central Jail here when they were carrying out a raid for unauthorised items in its barracks, one of which was allegedly left unlocked.

The Uttar Pradesh government has ordered a spot probe into the incident by Additional District Magistrate (city) Manvendra Singh and the jail handed over to the police and the PAC who were carrying out intensive searches of the premises. Five jail employees had been suspended and the Election Commission's permission sought for shifting prisoners involved to another jail, given that the model code was in force, District Magistrate Mukesh Meshram said.

The raid carried out at around 6:30 am by a police team led Deputy Inspector-General (prisons) M L Prakash came after a report by the Superintendent of Police (city) of a mobile phone being seized from a barrack on Wednesday.

Probe ordered in Meerut jail clash

Meanwhile, five officials of the Meerut jail were suspended after a seven-member inspecting team of the Agra Police were assaulted by jail staff and inmates Friday and an enquiry was ordered into the incident.

"We have started our probe into the matter and five jail officials have been suspended," District Magistrate Mukesh Meshram said.

Additional District Magistrate (Meerut) Manvander Singh has been asked to file an immediate report by Saturday and a detailed report of the incident in the next 15 days. Earlier in the day, Meerut Jail officials and inmates attacked the Agra Police personnel who came on a surprise inspection following intelligence reports of mobile phone use on the jail premises. (Agencies)

MCD seals 26 establishments

New Delhi: The sealing drive in the capital continued on a low-key note for the third consecutive day today, with the Municipal Corporation of Delhi taking action against 26 unauthorised commercial establishments only.

The civic body targeted 12 shops on Pradhan Road in Nirankari area of Civil Lines while 11 units on Geetanjali Road in South Zone was sealed on Friday, an MCD spokesman said. Three shops were also sealed in Krishna Nagar area of the South Zone.

Sealing was resumed in the capital on March 28 after the Supreme Court passed strictures against the MCD and asked it to restart the drive immediately. A total number of 127 properties have been sealed since Wednesday.

Meanwhile, traders filed a petition in the Supreme Court seeking immediate stay of the sealing drive in areas. (PTI)

Cong, BJP, BSP are communal parties: Mulayam

Jhansi: Branding the Congress, BJP and BSP as "communal parties", Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Mulayam Singh Yadav on Friday harked back to the Gujarat riots after the Godhra incident of 2002 and said the Samajwadi Party would always oppose "such designs".

Addressing an election meeting Mau Ranipur in this district, he accused the Congress, BJP and BSP of "inciting communal passions" and referred to the Gujarat riots of 2002 in this context.

Yadav said the SP would put a stop to "their influence and will always oppose such designs". (PTI)

India, B’desh to renew agreement on passenger train

From Our Correspondent

New Delhi: On the eve of the SAARC summit India and Bangladesh have agreed to renew an existing agreement for passenger train service between the two countries, which if materialized will see revival of the communication link after nearly four decades.

The Council of Advisers which is the virtual cabinet in Bangladesh now has approved in principle the proposal to introduce Sealdah (India)

Joydevpur (Bangladesh) passenger train service. Passenger train services between the two countries remained suspended since 1965 when India and then East Pakistan following a war.

A three-year agreement regarding the Joydevpur-Sealdah passenger train service was first signed on July 12, 2001 and it was extended again in 2004. The agreement expires in July this year and India wants to further extend the agreement up to 2010 on a regular basis.

One passenger train was operated in the last seven years on an experimental basis, but it has been out of operation since then due to lack of adequate infrastructure. Goods train service with India is in operation although not regularly.

Both India and Bangladesh are eager to introduce the passenger and goods train service and officials of both the countries will meet soon to review the condition of the train line, how to remove the infrastructure problem and other technical aspects. The passenger train services can start within three months but there are certain technical problems like tariff and immigration, which need to be settled.

Incidentally, "connectivity" will be the main theme of the 14th SAARC summit. The summit is highly important as a new member (Afghanistan) will be formally included in the grouping and five observers- US, EU, China, Japan and South Korea will be present at the event.

Chief Adviser, Dr Fakhruddin Ahmed of Bangaldesh will have bilateral talks with Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh on the first day of his four-day visit. Dr Ahmed is arriving on Monday and would hand over the chair to Dr Singh since India is the next Chairman of the summit.

Trinamool warns Tata Motors of ‘serious consequences’

Kolkata: Taking exception to Tata Motors’ managing director Ravi Kants’ remark that the firm was not answerable to anyone for selecting Singur for its small car plant, the Trinamool Congress on Friday threatened the company and its officials of "serious consequences" for such "provocative" comments.

"This is a highly provocative comment which should be immediately withdrawn, otherwise it will have serious consequences," Trinamool general secretary Partha Chatterjee said here.

Chatterjee, also the Leader of Opposition in the assembly, said the statement was "uncalled for" and "insulting" to the people of Singur. If it was not withdrawn, "both Tata Motors and the officer (Kant) will realise its consequences", he said. "How can he comment on a matter which is before the Calcutta High Court?" Chatter-jee asked. "We strongly condemn the statement made by the officer who is singing to the tune of the CPI-M and more particularly Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacher-jee." He also warned of an "appropriate movement" against Tata Motors in West Bengal.

During an interactive session in the city yesterday, Kant had said his company had decided to set up its small car plant in Singur at the invitation of the West Bengal government and nobody had the right to question the move.

The Trinamool Congress has been leading protests aginst the location of the plant on farm land and demanding it be shifted to some other site in the state. It has also sought the return of the land acquired for the plant. The Trinamool-led Krishi Jami Raksha Committee also came out strongly against Kant’s statement. (PTI)

‘Christians have highest unemployment rate’

New Delhi: Christians have the lowest illiteracy levels in the country but the highest unemployment rate, according to a government survey released on Friday.

"In rural areas, the unemployment rates were higher among the Christians (4.4 per cent) as compared to those among the Hindus (1.5 per cent) or Muslims (2.3 per cent). In the urban areas also same pattern was observed," an NSSO survey said.

According to the survey on employment and unemployment situation among major religious groups in India for 2004-05, Christians also had the lowest illiteracy rate for both rural (20 per cent for men and 31 per cent women) and urban areas (6 per cent for men and 11 per cent for women).

The survey covered 7,999 villages and 1,24,680 sample households. Except for rural women, the proportion of literates among the Hindus was higher as compared to Muslims.

The worker population ratio (WPR) among men in rural area was highest among Christians (56 per cent), followed by Hindus (55 per cent) and Muslims (50 per cent). For women, the ratio was 36 per cent for Christians, 34 per cent for Hindus and 18 per cent for Muslims. The WPR among men in urban areas was highest for Hindus at 56 per cent followed by Muslims (53 per cent) and Christians (51 per cent). In case of women, the WPR was highest for Christians at 24 per cent, followed by Hindus (17 per cent) and Muslims (12 per cent). The survey said nearly 49 per cent of Muslim households in urban areas were self-employed as against 36 per cent Hindu households and 27 per cent Christians. (PTI)


 

  Byrnihat industries responsible for power shortage: Tewari

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Blame it on the policy makers' shortsightedness for the acute power shortage in Meghalaya, which was once a power surplus State and had been supplying power to the neighbouring states.

The State's source of revenue suffered a major setback after the power supply to neighbouring states especially Asom, had to be stopped due to over consumption by the mushrooming industries in Byrnihat, a fact highlighted by the outgoing Chief Secretary SK Tewari way back in 2000. Another major factor was, of course, less rainfall since the last couple of years.

Mr Tewari had warned the State Government in 2000 that there would be acute shortage of power, if more industries come up in Byrnihat. "I had circulated a note in 2000 in the Cabinet that the State would run short of power in the future," Mr Tewari told reporters on Saturday. "At that time, Meghalaya was a power surplus State and we were even selling power to Asom," he recalled.

He lamented that nobody bothered to restrict the number of industries coming up in Byrnihat considering the availability of power. "Now, the end result is that the industries set up in Byrnihat are getting power for only six hours," he said. He said the people who issued the licences to set up more industries should be blamed, as at present the government is not in a position to provide power even to the existing industries.

300 children died of malaria: Mr Tewrai also expressed oncern over the deaths of children due to malaria. The authorities have confirmed 167 malaria deaths in the last year in the State.

However, according to Mr Tewari's "personal sources" in Jaintia Hills, at least 300 children died of malaria in a particular village. "This may be unconfirmed, but the case of children dying of malaria has exposed the Health department as it could not provide the basic health facilities to the people of rural areas," Mr Tewari said.

New CS to continue ‘good schemes’
By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: New Chief Secretary Ranjan Chatterjee, who assumed office on Saturday, said that good schemes followed by his predecessor SK Tewari would be continued.

Mr Tewari had made efforts to give fillip to State's horticulture production and had also raised the matter in various forums including the Centre.

Speaking to reporters, Mr Chatterjee said that continuity of good schemes is needed for overall development.

"To make the government more effective, the officers should perform well," he said adding, "the task ahead is to be accountable for betterment of the administration," he said. He also stressed the need for having a "degree of convergence" on the part of NGOs in their approach towards various issues.

Oilcat to make your car go 50 kmpl
By Our Spl Correspondent

Shillong: Did you ever wish your car had a mileage similar to that of a 100cc motorcycle? If you did, your wish has just come true, thanks to a US-based scientist with a Shillong connection.

The mandate for Denzel Mayum Kharmujai, a 31-year-old researcher at Stanford University in Palo Alto, California, was to develop cellulosic ethanol, a much-discussed biofuel projected to cut the US "dependency on foreign oil" by 35 billion gallons by 2017.

Instead, he developed the ultimate fuel booster that he has patented as Oilcat, or oil catalyst. The "biochemical" product enhances the thermo-energy of hydrocarbons without losing its property. "It’s like this: adding Oilcat to diesel or gasoline (petrol) will make your vehicle run three-six times more for the same quantity of oil," said Kharmujai via e-mail.

Test-runs have revealed that a petrol car with an average mileage of 15 kmpl gave a little over 50 kmpl after Oilcat—compacted to the size of a golf ball—was implanted in the specially designed engine. A diesel SUV with an on-road mileage of 10 kmpl, on the other hand, ran a tad over 30 kmpl. Oilcat is good news for the aviation industry too: a mid-sized Boeing flew four-and-a-half times more with fuel that would normally have exhausted in one flight.

No wonder, Oilcat—commercial production is scheduled to commence by this year-end—has had the US going gaga over Kharmujai, given the fact that America’s wars in West Asia have been pushing the global price of oil up. "This must be one of the greatest discoveries of this millennium," said Chris Somerville, professor of biological sciences at Stanford University and Kharmujai’s guide.

Somerville, though, was quick to add that he was relying on "wonder boy" Kharmujai to make cellulosic ethanol, the "fuel of the future" that is being derived from Miscanthus, a perennial grass native to subtropical and tropical regions of Africa and southern Asia.

Kharmujai, the older of two children of Shillong-born Helen Kharmujai and the half-Manipuri, half-Bengali Rabindra Mayum, has already received $2.5 million from investors to set up his Oilcat factory in the US. But he wants the "land of my ancestors" to benefit from his discovery.

"I want India to be the base for my Asia, Oceania and European operations," he said, hoping Meghalaya would be the first to offer him land and other incentives to help produce Oilcat.

JHADC session can solve the tangle: Nongtdu
By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: The State Congress is waiting for a session of JHADC to solve the present crisis in the Council. "We hope that session will be held soon to elect the new Chairman in JHADC," MPCC president OL Nongtdu said on Saturday. In a sudden move, the Chairman of JHADC resigned last week creating further delay in solving the leadership crisis in the Council. "We hope that by next week there will be a solution to the crisis," Mr Nongtdu said. With Edmund Lyngdoh and Moonlight Pariat claiming for leadership, the Cabinet even met recently to discuss the crisis. Mr Nongtdu said that the present JHADC CEM Mr Pariat is now and Independent member in the Council after his expulsion from the Congress.

Students held
By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Two school students, roaming "in a suspicious manner" in Umsning in Ri-Bhoi district, were handed over to police by a local person on Saturday. The brother duo, who were in school uniform, have been identified as Lumlang Myrthong (11) and Shanborlang Myrthong (8).

Jongksha Dorbar secretary defends Biloris
By Our Reporter

Shillong: The Secretary of Jongksha Durbar has expressed disapproval with the allegations made against Meghalaya State Women's Commission (MSWC) chairperson Dr Biloris Lyndem on the Rinehskhem Kharsohnoh murder case.

In a statement issued here, the Secretary of the Durbar said that on March 17 he called up Dr Lyndem at 9.15 a.m. to be present at Nongthymmai Police Beat House to record the statement of Mrs Shimti Kharsohnoh who is the mother of the murdered lady.

"Whatever that Mrs Kharsohnoh said was recorded in my presence" the Secretary of the Durbar said.

He also informed that a public meeting held recently in the village had also termed the accusations against Dr Lyndem as baseless.

During the the meeting, the MSWC chairperson also said that she had taken several steps for protection of women from domestic violence and crimes.

NCP meet

By Our Reporter

Shillong: The meeting of the NCP Nongskhen Block Circle was held recently at Pynursla in the presence of the State President WR Kharlukhi, EK Sangma, MLA, W Syiemiong and others.

Meanwhile, another public meeting of the party will be held at Dangar on Monday at 11 am, a statement issued here said.

Consumer awareness

By Our Reporter

Shillong: A consumer awareness programme attended by the Sordars, students and NGOs to sensitise the public on the rights of the consumers was organised by the Office of the Sub-divisional Officer (Supply), Mairang recently. Mr MR Mawlong, retired IAS, who was the chief guest on the occasion, delivered speeches on the Consumer Protection Act (COPRA).

Upgradation of civil hospital mooted

By Our Reporter

Shillong: Several suggestions had been made for improvement of health care system in Shillong Civil Hospital during the recent meeting of the Hospital Management Society of Shillong Civil Hospital held here recently which was attended by Commissioner and Secretary of Health Mr P Naik who is also chairman of the Society.

According to sources, the meeting took note of the requirement of equipments in the Orthopaedic department and Accident Trauma Centre and that a proposal would be sent to the State government through the Director of Health Services (DHS).

The meting also decided to procure one ECG machine in view of immediate need and that the machine would be procured from the fund of the Society.

It was also decided to create a Central Sterilization Store Department (CSSD) with the required manpower.

In view of the current load shedding by the MeSEB, the meeting decided to procure three emergency lights for the corridor of the emergency room for use during power shutdown.

The meeting also decided to purchase the urgently needed OT medicines from the fund of the Society.

It also decided to sent a proposal to the State government for procurement of Laparascope. Another proposal would be made for procurement of Surgical Eye Microscope for the Eye department.


Welter of confusion

West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya stands accused for the wrong reasons. He is not personally responsible for the atrocities, by the police or CPI(M) cadre disguised as policemen. The opposition headed by Mamata Banerjee is baying for his blood and demanding his resignation. Will the removal of the Chief Minister put an end to violence? The CPI(M) will continue to rule and the old order will not change. It is strange that Mamata Banerjee and her cohort do not vociferously demand the dismissal of the Left Front government as a whole. On the other hand, it has become clear that if Bhattacharya has to be condemned, it is because of his naivete , as Jyoti Basu said , and the lack of coordination in his cabinet, the bureaucracy and his party cadre. He said that no land would be acquired at Nandigram and the next day he had to admit that a notice had been issued which he wanted torn into ribbons. That is not all. He declared that land acquisition had been put on hold in West Bengal and yet a notice had been issued at Deganga by a bumbling official. He met the Governor who had condemned violence at Nandigram and is reported to have said that if he was in the Governor’s shoes, he would have done the same thing. He does not want to find scapegoats ( he should have come down heavily on the culprits ) and has accepted moral responsibility for all that happened. Has he also accepted moral responsibility for the two rapes allegedly perpetrated by two CPI(M) goons? This was not a response to a challenge but the acts of human beasts. What is more, if Bhattacharya accepts moral responsibility , it should follow that he should himself offer to resign . Lal Bahadur Shastri as railway minister created history by taking such a decision years ago. That would have heightened his image. It would not have been under pressure from the opportunistic alliance of non-parties in West Bengal . His party and the people would have decided if his resignation was to accepted . If it was not , he could have carried out a perestroika of his party and administration with a firmer hand . His apology now is being dismissed as a damage-control measure .

Until the continuing mess is cleared , the main issue of industrialisation remains clouded . At the outset , all parties in West Bengal wanted industrialisation and huge investment including FDI. Industrialisation means growth and employment . Agriculture cannot meet the entire need . Landless labour and share croppers get so little out of their hard work that displacement should not make a great difference to them . Their employment is seasonal. That explains the urban movement of the rural poor . So there should be no confusion about the need for growth of industry in rural areas . The solution lies in an arithmetical balance . How much industrial development would be necessary and how much agricultural land would be needed for the purpose? Coming to compensation , to what extent can the poor tax payers bear the burden (agriculture is outside the tax net ) ? Finally, industrial growth is not synonymous with SEZs. The Left parties have long been advocating amendments to the Act of 2005 . Buddhadeb Bhattacharya should shelve the issue. How can the Left Front government in West Bengal make SEZ projections when the CPI(M) high command is still marking time?




Kashmir: A third world paradigm

By Indu Prakash Singh

The US State Department in a study paper released recently says Kashmir occupies centrestage in any discourse on Indian politics and regional relations in south Asia. Most discussions on Kashmir focus on either the constitutional position of the state, the legality or illegality of the instrument of accession or the externally-sponsored terrorism affected by foreign mercenaries. Some also look at it from the point of view of human rights of distinct nationalities and recommend self-determination for the people of Kashmir. Rarely is the Kashmir issue seen as part of a bigger problem faced by most Third World states to integrate their multi-racial and pluralistic societies in their attempt at nation and state building. If viewed in the larger context, Kashmir, far from being an exception or a specific South Asian problem, conforms to a pattern.

Almost all states in the Third World have one or more minority groups within their national territories, and minorities frequently live on different sides of state borders. Consequently, the treatment of minorities presents a moral and political dilemma with both domestic and international ramifications. In this sense, Kashmir is a paradigm and the lessons learnt here have implications for all Third World nation states grappling with the problems thrown up by heterogeneity and the demands of a pluralistic society. Therefore, to view the Kashmir problem in isolation and to offer prescriptions specific to this territory without addressing the larger questions of Third World nation building would be intellectually presumptuous and practically unacceptable.

The modern nation state, undoubtedly one of the world's most enduring institutions, is facing major challenges: It is going thought period of stress and strain that may not only alter the political maps of the world but also transform the very notions of sovereignty and nationhood. States are being pressed in different unpredictable and politically violent ways by ethnic, religious forces or by demands for reunification with homelands across borders. The results are visible not just the turmoil in most Third World states, in the collapse of the Soviet Union and its satellite states, Yugoslavia and others, but in all the seemingly more stable and established nations. Canada is an interesting example, but the results of the recent referendum may come as a sobering influence on many of the minority groups who try to break away from the established states, as well as on those who advocate referendum as a solution to such problems. In appreciating the difficulties encountered by the Third World states, it should not be forgotten that the process of state-making in Europe, home of the modern nation state, followed a gradualist pattern. It took, decades and several bouts of unprecedented violence to stabilise these sates.

Even the USA went through a tumultuous period culminating in the historic Civil War. Even so, imperfections remain. A case in point is Britain with its unruly mixture of Scots, Welsh and the English, and its war zone in Northern Ireland. Sub-surface ethnic tensions persist in the United State as well due to the complexities of race relations and the continued (and often illegal) inflow of new migrant races. For the newly independent countries it is not time alone that constrains their journeys to nationhood. They have to tackle the political, social and economic dimensions of the de-colonialisation process simultaneously, rather than through a process broken into phases as was the case with the Western developed states.

The Western nation states were fortunate in having the chance to solve some of the intricate problems of nation-building well before they had to face the ordeal of mass politics. This makes the problem of a nation state a more difficult and complicated task in the Third World.

The unfortunate part is that Western leaders and intellectuals often try to foist their values and ideas which have centuries to evolve to nascent Third World states for their own interests and in the process sometime de-stabilise the process of nation building. Given this theoretical framework, Kashmir is no exception, and in fact shares the experiences of other pluralistic societies nearer home, particularly in Southeast Asia. All the countries of Southeast Asia with the single exception of Singapore have problems of some national groups trying either to assert their autonomy or to secede from the state. While armed communist movements constituted the most serious threat to regime survival in post-colonial Southeast Asia, armed separatist movements involving indigenous ethnic minorities are challenging the very basis of statehood and national identity in the region. Southeast Asia is home to at least 32 ethno-linguistic groups and all the world's major independent rebel groups have organised armed campaigns against the state structure within the ASEAN countries.

In the case of Myanmar (Burma), for instance, about 10 sub-ethnic groups are demanding sovereignty ever since the country became independent. Burma since ancient times has been dominated by the majority Burman ethnic group. The countries independence was expected to correct earlier deprivation of many of the minority groups and offer them equal rights and a place under the sun, but it never happened.

In Thailand too the problem of ethnicity affects the stability of the State and of national integration. The country is predominantly Buddhist, only 4 per cent of the entire population follows other faiths. About 3.82 per cent of the population is Muslim, the rest being Christian. It is this minuscule Muslim minority that has most vociferously opposed the national integration plans in matters of administration and other governmental activities.

The Philippines is also not free from such ethnic separatist movements. Ever since the country's independence, the central government at Manila has tried to assimilate the Moros, who are Muslims living in a predominantly Christian country and who have always looked to the Malay world and to the Middle East for cultural and religious sustenance. But under former President Marcos, who ruled from 1996 to 1986, the movement for a 'Bangsa Moro' began to gain momentum.

An interesting aspect of the movement for independence in Kashmir is that it is directed not only at the Indian state in terms of secession but also at the established ruling groups within Kashmir. Its social origins are neo-bourgeois and its philosophy a combination of "Kashmiriyat" and Islam. Depending upon the weightage given to each of these two elements respectively, we have half-a-dozen militant groups. The current crisis is the culmination of many years of perverse democratic politics within the state, compounded by rampant corruption and sluggish socioeconomic development. All this fanned political disenchantment especially among the growing numbers of educated unemployed Kashmiri youth. Also, the sense of alienation from the Indian state among the Kashmiri emergent middle class is due in part to a feeling of discrimination by New Delhi. Rightly or wrongly, this feeling is deeply embedded in the Kashmiri psyche. The winds of fundamentalism and the stories of 'heroic terrorism' across the world provided the inspiration for many Kashmiris to adopt militancy. These feelings within Kashmir constitute a great opportunity for Pakistan to exploit.

Given the past history of the subcontinent, a further division or granting of independence to any of the constituent units of India will not solve any religious, linguistic or other ethnic disputes. The same is true for Pakistan. The case of Bangladesh was very different because the two former wings of Pakistan were not only physically separated by another country, but they also had nothing in common except religion.

Long years of neglect, indifference, and bad policies, although not deliberate, have led to the alienation of a large number of Kashmiris. It is proving difficult to bring Kashmiris back into the mainstream. If the Southeast Asian experience holds any lessons for Kashmir, it is first that it will be difficult to reach a solution as long as the armed Kashmiri movement continues to receive support from an external source, which in this case is Pakistan and a few other Islamic countries. Second, the Kashmir movement cannot be solved by force alone. The case of Thailand and to an extent the Philippines shows that a more considerate policy towards minority groups succeeds in diminishing alienation and with it the problem of armed insurgency and terrorism.

In short, a compromise needs to be worked out. The Kashmiris clearly need more devolution of powers and autonomy. At the same time, they need to be reminded that secession is unacceptable. The solution to a dispute like that in Kashmir cannot be the fragmentation of the Indian state, but decentralisation and devolution of power to the constituent units; better communication between the state and its sectarian and ethnic minorities; and cultural tolerance and fairness in the from of constitutional safeguards for the disadvantaged. A careful scrutiny of the roots of unrest in South Asia reveals that many of the urgent issues confronting the region centre around the tension caused by either a central government or a particular dominant ethnic, linguistic, or religious group arrogating too much power to itself. INAV

Right judgement

Sir,

The Supreme Court on Thursday stayed until August the 27 per cent reservation of seats in elite central educational institutions for backward class students.

It is a nice move by the court and have given relief to thousands of talented students who were going to miss the opportunities due to this reservation system. The politicians were trying to impose the law for their benefit. They never thought about the future of the students who are putting a lot of efforts in their studies. Now the decision taken by the court is absolutely correct and should be appreciated.

There is no wrong in making the effort to raise the living standard of backward classes and give them more opportunities in educational institutions but reservation is not the solution. It is going to create tensions and nothing. So it would be better if the government comes forward with some other plan which can solve the issue permanently and give equal opportunity to all classes of students.

Yours etc.,
Shailesh Kumar,
Via e-mail

Men in ‘faded’ blue?

Sir,

Now when the dust is settled and the aspirations/expectations are washed away in waters of incompetency displayed by the very hyped 'Men in blue', it's time we give priority to other disciplines as well. The Godlike status, the endorsements tagged with big bucks and the like factors etc, have proved detrimental to them. The focus/support from firms/public should shift to the other contenders of various sport disciplines who equally deserves it. Let us not make cricket very much relevant to patriotism or attached our emotions to it. The show of esteem, hard work, success, style as being wrongly portrayed in ads, does no justice to the person hitting a boundary or a fielder taking a catch or for that matter quenching a thirst or gelling your hair. There are various brave hearts of Indian sports who have done and is still doing India proud in keeping the tri-colour fluttering. It is looking to the other side of the arena and we will know that there are 'many' who are making us smile every moment.

Yours etc.,
Adilbert Dkhar,
Shillong-3
Via e-mail

II

Sir,

The Indian cricket team is undoubtedly in a very pathetic condition. Cricket has become more of a religion in India, but none of the players realise this. I feel the problem with the Indian cricket team is not with their coach or the other technical staff, the problem is with the players. They (the players) lack the zeal and enthusiasm they once possessed when they first held the willow while playing in their streets. As of now they should be taking a long break and go for a sanyaas. I personally won't be watching cricket anymore, but am planning to shift my interest to another game...maybe kho kho. I think the Indian players don't know what really the World Cup is.

Yours etc.,
Phiralang Diengdoh
Via e-mail


Hmar outfit warns Congress MLA in Mizoram

Aizawl: Manipur-based Hmar National Assembly (HNA) on Saturday warned Congress MLA R Lalzirliana following his allegation that the ruling Mizo National Front (MNF) had given them AK-47 rifles.

An HNA statement here said, ''Lalzirliana has told the Mizoram Assembly an outright lie, which was contempt to the House as well as to the people of Hmar and unless he is able to provide witness, he will be responsible for any consequence.''

Lalzirliana had alleged that the Mizoram Government had handed over 12 AK-47 rifles to the banned-outfit at Zilthawchhuah, a Manipur village near Mizoram border, on January 13. The arms were transported in a Bolero car with registration number MZ-01B-3645.

The HNA will leave no stone unturned to reveal the truth to the people, the statement said, adding, ''The vehicle went to Parbung (Manipur) from Aizawl on January 13 which can proved by the Assam Rifles check-gate on the road.''

Meanwhile, Home Minister Tawnluia on Friday submitted a petition to the Assembly Speaker to constitute a 'house inquiry committee' to probe into the allegation.

''I was not aware of the 'giving of 12 AK-47 rifles to Hmar outfit' until Mr Lalzirliana mentioned it in the House. The police immediately investigated into the allegation but, an inquiry committee is necessary because the people of Mizoram should know the truth,'' he said.

Adding fuel to the issue, youth wings of the three Opposition parties - MPCC, MPC and ZNP - came out with a joint press release on Saturday, lashing out at the HNA statement.

The HNA leaders were summoned by the MNF Government through its CID personnel on the night of March 29 following which the statement was made, the joint press release said, adding the meeting included the outfit's president Thansung, the vehicle owner and driver.

The press release also said the MLA had more information, which he did not disclose in the House, such as the registration number of the police van through which the arms were passed on to the Sumo and the name of the police officer involved.

Expressing solidarity with the MLA, the release warned that if any negative consequence befalls him, because of revealing the truth, the HNA would be held responsible.

No Confidence motion moved

The entire Opposition in Mizoram moved a no confidence motion against the ruling Mizo National Front (MNF), forcing the Speaker to adjourn the House till Monday.

Zoram Nationalist Party (ZNP) legislator Lalduhawma moved the motion during the Zero Hour on Friday. It was supported by 12 legislators, including Congress and Mizoram Peoples Conference (MPC) besides ZNP. The MNF has 27 legislators in the 40-member Mizoram Assembly.

The Opposition alleged that the law and order situation in the State had been gradually deteriorating while a number of banned militant outfits of the northeast had made Mizoram a corridor for arm smuggling.

Finally, Speaker Lalchamliana adjourned the house till Monday and announced the schedule of discussion on the motion on that day. (UNI)

NC Hills bandh over delay in autonomous council polls

Guwahati: The BJP-ASDC on Saturday called a 72-hour North Cachar (NC) Hills district bandh from April 9 to protest the delay in holding elections to the NC Hills Autonomous Council (NCHAC), the term of which had expired in December.

Addressing a press meet here, BJP’s NC Hills District president Kulendra Daulagupu said, the elections to the NCHAC should have been held immediately after the term of the present council expired on December 20 last. But the State Government contrived to extend the term by six months, which was stopped only by a High Court ruling.

''We demand that the polls be announced without delay. The bandh has been called jointly by the BJP and Autonomous State Demand Committee (ASDC) to press for our demand,'' he added.

BJP legislator Mission Ranjan Das, also present at the press meet, said, ''The State Government can easily announce elections through an affidavit, which would automatically depose off the writ petitions pending in the court. But they don't have the will to do so.''

He said the Congress, which held power at Dispur as well as controlled the present NCHAC, was employing in delaying tactics as it feared losing power due to its "rampant corruption" in the NCHAC administration.

Mr Daulagupu further pointed out that the Government had pleaded for time for delimitation in the NC Hills, but it could have conveniently done it during its tenure of five years. The BJP would be contesting in eight of the total 23 seats in the NCHAC, leaving the rest for its alliance partner ASDC. (UNI)

ULFA cadres killed in skirmish, blast near CRPF camp

Sibsagar: Two ULFA militants were killed and an Army major was seriously wounded in a gun battle in Asom's Sibsagar district hours before the banned group triggered a blast near a CRPF camp in Golaghat. Authorities deployed the army at Oil India installations and areas of Sibsagar district dominated by Hindi-speaking people to prevent any retaliation by the ULFA.

Superintendent of Police Shyamal Saikia told PTI the army and police, acting on a tip-off, jointly raided a house at Nitaipukhuri Godabil where three ULFA militants were hiding. One of the militants fled, while the other two opened fire, seriously wounding Major S Parihar of the 174 Field Regiment.

In the exchange of fire, two ULFA rebels -- identified as "sergeant major" Nipon Borgohain and "corporal" Biplab Konwar -- were gunned down, Saikia said. An AK-47 rifle, a large quantity of RDX explosive, a 12-kg IED, and flexible wire were recovered from the two.

Army intelligence sources said the two slain rebels had been assigned by the ULFA leadership to strike in Guwahati and Tinsukia ahead of the group's raising day on April 7.

The wounded major was airlifted to Assam Medical College Hospital in Dibrugarh in a serious condition. (PTI)

Nagaland Budget hailed

Kohima: Nagaland Accountant General (AG) Ram Mohan Johri has appreciated the 2007-08 State Budget for improving the fiscal management as compared to last year, official sources said on Saturday.

Mr Johri said the State had limited resources and the deficit presented by Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio, who also holds the Finance portfolio, was a positive phenomenon.

Commenting on the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG), Mr Johri pulled up some State Government Departments including Health and Family Welfare, Power, Education and Transport and Communication for anomalies and lack of effective budgetary control.

He also revealed similar anomalies in all the nine departmentally managed government commercial and quasi-commercial undertakings.

On the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) mission in the State, Mr Johri pulled up for mismanagement, inefficiency and diversion of funds of the mission.

Citing a survey conducted in August 2003, he said three districts, that were test-checked, were found grossly deficient in infrastructure as 76 per cent of schools had no drinking water facilities, 94 per cent had no electricity, 55 per cent had no verandahs, 97 per cent had no toilets for girls and 92 per cent of schools had no urinal and above all 86 per cent of school buildings had dilapidated walls, roofs and floors.

He also said 43 per cent of the teachers were not adequately qualified and 65 per cent of teachers were not trained to perform their jobs adding that SSA funds of Rs 10.65 lakh were diverted for distribution of free text books in Kiphire under (then) Tuensang district though the state was providing funds for the purpose. (UNI)

Guwahati’s draft master plan released

Guwahati: The Draft Master Plan 2025 for development of the State capital was unveiled here on Saturday.

Announcing the Draft Master plan, Guwahati Development Department (GDD) Minister Himanta Biswa Sharma said, ''We have visualised a planned, clean and beautiful city by 2025. All individuals and groups are welcome to offer their suggestions for finalising the Master Plan.''

Developing three new townships at Changsari, Sualkuchi and Rani on the outskirts of the main city limits now is an important proposal in the plan. Two new bridges over the Brahmaputra on the eastern and western ends, besides better road communication and light rail transit system, are additional features of the plan.

A new Separate Economic Zone in south-west of the city and addition of 521 hectares of land for industrial purposes in the north-west part have also been proposed. (UNI)



National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |

 

                                               

Make This Your HomePage! | About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery

Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.