News  of 8th March 2008

National | Shillong | Interntional | Editorial | Regional | Sports 

Left sets deadline to Govt on N-deal
Priority to survival of Govt: Pranab

NEW DELHI: Scotching speculation about early polls, External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee has made it clear that the survival of the government was more important than the Indo-US nuclear deal and Left parties will have to be taken on board.

He ruled out the possibility of a minority government signing the nuclear agreement, saying the US was not ready for it.

Left parties on Thursday set a deadline asking the government to make it clear by March 15 whether it intended to proceed with the controversial Indo-US nuclear deal or drop it.

The key outside supporters of the government, whose backing is crucial for its survival, has asked the government to convene a meeting of the UPA-Left Committee by March 15 to discuss the draft of the India-specific Safeguards Agreement reportedly reached with the IAEA.

Mukherjee also said that India had not conducted negotiations on the agreement with a "fixed timeline", in an apparent response to the US which has set the deadline of May.

"We are trying to evolve a consensus and first the consensus will be with the supporting parties because that is primary importance for which the (UPA-Left) mechanism was created. Then we shall try to evolve a larger consensus," he said in an interview to a news magazine.

He said the government will have to discuss the India-IAEA safeguards agreement with the Left but declined to elaborate.

When pointed out that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Congress president Sonia Gandhi had said in October last that survival of the government is more important than the deal, he said "that position is still there." He added "what the Congress president says is the final word of the party and what the Prime Minister says is the final word of the government." (PTI)

Polio review

New Delhi: With fresh polio cases being reported from various parts of the country, the Government feels that the national programme for its eradication has not been upto the mark and has decided to review the entire initiative. The programme being run in collaboration with international organisations like WHO and UNICEF involves door-to-door administration of polio vaccine and surveillance of the polio cases through the National Polio Surveillance Project. (PTI)

Home loan rates

New Delhi: Making a strong case for a cut in interest rates on home loans of up to Rs 20 lakh, Finance Minister P Chidambaram on Thursday said he would continue to talk to bankers as these accounts, which form a lion's share of total borrowing for housing, carry less risk weightage. (PTI)

FM pitches for lower rate for home loans up to Rs 20 lakh

New Delhi: Making a strong case for a cut in interest rates on home loans of up to Rs 20 lakh, Finance Minister P Chidambaram on Thursday said he would continue to talk to bankers as these accounts, which form a lion’s share of total borrowing for housing, carry less risk weightage.

The Finance Minister, however, in the same breath added that the ball is in the court of banks and Reserve Bank.

"I made a number of efforts to impress upon bankers in this regard... it is a constant effort that I will have to make... bankers will have to take a call, RBI will have to take a call," Chidambaram said in his post-budget interaction with industry chamber Assocham here.

Following the Reserve Bank's tight monetary policy initiatives, interest rates on housing loans have shot up to the range 10-12 per cent, bringing the demand sharply down.

If the rate of inflation is high, RBI tightens monetary policy, leading to higher interest rates. But at its last monetary review in January, RBI kept all key rates intact.

But even then many banks, including market leader SBI, cut interest rates after RBI said their net interest margin is still high. The Finance Minister said he agreed that housing loan borrowers of less than Rs 20 lakh should be incentivised by lowering interest rates.

As much as 80 per cent of all housing loans fall in the category of below Rs 20 lakh, he said, adding that these loans have less risk weight than those above Rs 20 lakh. Therefore, bankers have incentives to lend to these borrowers at lower interest rates.

"I shall certainly bear in mind that there is public demand that interest rates for borrowers, who borrow (housing loans) up to Rs 20 lakh, must be lowered," Chidambaram said.

At the same time he also defended the RBI stance. The RBI governor's position to strike a balance between low inflation and high growth is unenviable, he said.

"He (RBI governor) can never please everyone. It is his judgement call what should be the interest rates in order to contain inflation and promote growth," the Finance Minister said.

Chidambaram said he recognised that from the government's point of view it is important to promote growth without stoking inflation. (PTI)

Kashmir Singh’s pardon challenged

Islamabad: A lawyer has challenged the pardon granted by President Pervez Musharraf to Indian national Kashmir Singh, who was freed after spending 35 years on death row in a Pakistani jail, even as the move was criticised by religious leaders and organisations. (PTI)

Soren acquitted in 1975 massacre case

Jamtara (Jharkhand): Nearly one and half years after he was absolved by a Delhi court in the murder of is private secrertary, a Jharkhand court on Thursday acquitted JMM supremo Sibu Soren in a 33-year-old massacre case citing lack of evidence.

Soren, still in legal tangles in another double murder case, was given the benefit od doubt along with 13 others by Jamtara Additional District and Sessions Judge Arun Kumar for want of evidence.

The court, however, held seven persons guilty in the case relating to the massacre of 11 persons at Chirrudih village under Narayanpur police station on January 23, 1975. The quantum of their punishment would be announced later.

"Justice has triumphed," was the immediate reaction of the tribal leader, who had appeared in person in the court, as he was forced to quit the union cabinet in 2004 following issuance of a non-bailable warrant of arrest against him.

Twentyone out of the 22 accused appeared in the court on Thursday. (PTI)

Hindu temple in London wins Pride of Place award

London: Shree Swaminarayan temple at Naesden in London has been named the landmark of which its residents are most proud, in a national poll.

More than 2,300 residents voted for the north London temple to win the inaugural Pride of Place award. It is the biggest and first Hindu temple to be built in Europe.

The Britain-wide campaign saw 36,800 people voting online. Nine London councils participated in the poll, in which 10 landmarks were nominated from the city. (UNI)

Left sets deadline on nuke deal

New Delhi: Upping the ante, Left parties on Thursday set a deadline asking the government to make it clear by March 15 whether it intended to proceed with the controversial Indo-US nuclear deal or drop it.

The key outside supporters of the government, whose backing is crucial for its survival, has asked the government to convene a meeting of the UPA-Left Committee by March 15 to discuss the draft of the India-specific Safeguards Agreement reportedly reached with the IAEA.

Apparently worried over a rash of statements from the government expressing virtually its determination to go ahead with the deal, the parties have asked the government to make a clean breast of its intention -- whether it wants to go ahead with the deal despite their opposition.

CPI(M) General Secretary Prakash Karat has shot off a letter to External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee, government's key interlocutor with the allies on the deal, asking for convening of the meeting by March 15.

The party also issued an ominous warning that the future of the government depends on the decision it will take on Washington’s "pressure" to conclude the agreement.

CPI leader D Raja and Forward Bloc General Secretary Debabrata Biswas, members of the Committee, met Karat this morning and discussed the strategy on getting from the government its position on whether it wants to go ahead with the deal despite Left's opposition to it. (PTI)

SC to examine if Pak national can own property in India

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has decided to examine an important issue whether a Pakistani national can have right to property in India.

The important issue has been raised by a petitioner Bhai Lal Shukla, challenging the Allahabad High Court order which had allowed a Pakistani national, Suhel Siddiqui, to take possession of the land belonging to his uncle who was a bachelor.

The High Court had also dismissed the testamentary case, filed by Administrator General of Uttar Pradesh who contended that the Pakistani national cannot own property in India and hence it should be declared evacuated and the possession be handed over to the state Government. (UNI)

Gentle Prime Minister turns combative

New Delhi: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, otherwise soft and gentle even in his attacks against his political rivals, was a different man Wednesday. By hitting out at Leader of Opposition L.K. Advani, in an uncharacteristically sarcastic way, Manmohan Singh took on the role of a sharp politician.

It made the ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA) as well as its Left allies happy.

"It was Manmohan Singh's maiden political speech," said Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) MP P. Rajendran.

"He has torn Advani into pieces," said another communist MP N.N. Krishnadas.

A senior colleague of Manmohan Singh put it like this: "When a quiet man becomes angry he becomes furious." Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) Mp Ramkripal Yadav went to Manmohan Singh immediately after he finished his more-than-hour-long speech, shook hands with him and said: "You have done wonders. You have made him speechless". A blushing prime minister was seen thanking everyone for their compliments.

The speech left even his own party men surprised. "It was not even a written speech. He added many things extempore," said a Congress MP.

The MP pointed out that the speech was absolutely different from the prime minister's usual speeches. "When he was attacking Advani on internal security issue, he said at least three times that he did not want to score a point. But what he did was a tit for tat to Advani."

In his speech Manmohan Singh said: "Advaniji has made some critical references about our govern-ment's performance in dealing with terrorism and terrorist groups of different kinds. I have no intention to score points against the opposition on this issue. "National security is too serious a matter for any kind of political one-upmanship. I would like to assure the house that our commitment in the fight against terrorism is absolute...

"I do not need to remind this house about a dark day in 2001 when, but for the fact that fate intervened and our vigilant Watch and Ward Staff, our Parliament would have been the scene of a great deal of bloodshed. I am not scoring points here against the failure of the NDA government."

Ruling out Advani's suggestion that a stricter legal regime to deal with terrorists was the need of the hour, Manmohan Singh said: "This lie must be nailed once and for all. Legal regimes do not prevent terror. "If that had been the case, there would have been no attack on Akshardham or on the Raghunath Mandir. Draconian laws could not prevent the IC-814 hijack. We had the shameful sight of the then external affairs minister (Jaswant Singh) escorting dreaded terrorists to their freedom. (IANS)


               

Another hung Assembly in Meghalaya

Our Bureau

SHILLONG/TURA: The elections to the 8th Meghalaya Legislative Assembly have produced a fractured verdict yet again with no party getting a simple majority, fuelling speculation that Congress, which has emerged the single largest political force, will head another coalition government with support from its former MDA allies or second-placed NCP if the situation demands so.

There are indications that Congress, which garnered 25 seats despite losing four Cabinet ministers and 12 sitting legislators, will hold on to its former MDA partners UDP, KHNAM and HSPDP and stake claim to form the new government led by DD Lapang as the Chief Minister.

UDP, KHNAM and HSPDP secured a total of 14 seats, while NCP won 14 seats like it did in the 2003 elections.

Anything, however, can happen in a fluid political situation like Meghalaya's with Congress and NCP reportedly holding parleys with various regional parties on formation of the next government which is due in a few days from now.

Apart from Chief Minister DD Lapang, both the deputy chief ministers in the MDA Government - Dr Donkupar Roy (UDP) and Dr Mukul Sangma (Congress) - were re-elected to the Assembly. While Mr Lapang won the poll from Nongpoh, Dr Roy and Dr Sangma reclaimed Shella and Ampatigiri seats respectively.

Besides Mr Lapang and Dr Sangma, only three other Congress ministers - Prestone Tynsong (Lyngkyrdem), Charles Pyngrope (Sohryngkham) and Nehlang Lyngdoh (Rymbai) - crossed the electoral barrier. Assembly Speaker Martin M Danggo also reclaimed his seat.

The Congress Cabinet ministers, who bit the dust in the polls, are Deborah C Marak (Rongrenggiri), Manirul Islam Sarkar (Phulbari), Brening Sangma (Kherapara) and Zenith Sangma (Rangsakona). Deputy Speaker Phingwell Muktieh (Mawhati) also lost the election.

The 12 sitting Congress MLAs who lost the elections are Khan Khong Dkhar (Nongshken), Irin Lyngdoh (Pariong), Tony Curtis Lyngdoh (Malki-Nongthymmai), Elstone D Marak (Kharkutta), Draison Kharshiing (Nartiang), Boldness L Nongum (Mairang), Tonsing N Marak (Songsak), Clement Marak (Selsella), Monindro Rava (Tikrikilla), Beckstar Sangma (Rongchugiri) and Sengman R Marak (Rongram).

Both KHNAM and BJP, which had two legislators each in the 7th State Assembly, managed to get only one seat each this time. While KHNAM president Paul Lyngdoh won the Jaiaw seat with a big margin of 6,695 votes he polled against his nearest rival and former Finance Minister AH Scott Lyngdoh (Congress), the lone BJP winner and sitting legislator from Pynthorumkhrah AL Hek reclaimed 

his seat by defeating his closest rival James Marvin Pariat (NCP) by a huge margin of 8,559.

MDP drew a blank as none of its candidates, including party president Martle N Mukhim, won the election. Mr Mukhim, who contested from Dienglieng constituency, suffered defeat at the hands of UDP's Remington Pyngrope (UDP) by a thin margin of 66 votes.

NCP bagged 12 out of the 24 seats in Garo Hills, while Congress could manage to win only seven in the region. Congress, however, won 18 seats in Khasi and Jaintia Hills, including regional party stronghold Mawlai where Congress had never won any election since creation of the State in 1972.

Congress candidate Founder S Cajee defeated sitting legislator Process T Sawkmie (UDP) by a margin of 3,079 votes. Union Tribal Affairs Minister PR Kyndiah's son Waibha K Kyndiah, who was in the news for HS Shylla being deprived of Congress ticket, pathetically lost the race from Nongkrem constituency and was placed a poor fifth.

The seat was won by former FKJGP president Ardent M Basaiawmoit (UDP) who beat sitting MLA Lambor Malngiang (KHNAM) by a margin of 717 votes.UDP has been routed in Jaintia Hills, where six of the seven seats went to Congress and the other to NCP. In Ri-Bhoi district too, Congress could bag only one out of the four seats - Nongpoh. The rest went to UDP. NCP, which fielded 26 candidates in Khasi and Jaintia Hills, could win only two seats - Laban and Nartiang. After resigning from Congress on the eve of the elections, UDP candidate and former Chief Minister JD Rymbai was elected to Assembly for the fifth consecutive time from Jirang constituency. Garo Hills strongman Purno Agitok Sangma once again proved the political pundits wrong by winning the election from the prestigious Tura seat but was left shaken as the final results for the entire State showed Congress ahead of NCP and UDP. Mr Sangma defeated his nearest rival and sitting MLA Billykid A Sangma (Ind) with a litle over 2000 votes. Congress stalwarts, including former Chief Minister Salseng C Marak and Health Minister Debora C Marak, were defeated at the hustlings as NCP literally swept the East Garo Hills region, bagging six out of the seven seats in the entire district. There was some respite for the party as Congress candidate Frankenstein W Momin won from Mendipather, defeating sitting UDP MLA Beningstad G Momin. Out of the twenty-three seats in Garo Hills which went to the polls, NCP bagged 12 seats, Congress 7 UDP 1, while 3 seats went to Independents. The two sons of Mr Sangma -- James K Sangma and Conrad K Sangma -- came on top winning from Rongchugiri and Selsella constituencies. James defeated Congress heavyweight Beckstar K Sangma, while Conrad beat Congress MLA Clement Marak. Former Chief Minister and Congress candidate from Resubelpara constituency, Salseng C Marak has failed to make it to the Assembly for the second time in a row. Sitting NCP MLA Timonthy D Shira retained his seat. Debora C Marak also lost her Rongrenggiri seat as NCP's Marcus Marak won. In the last elections Mr Marak was narrowly defeated by Debora Marak with a margin of less than a hundred votes. PWD Minister Zenith Sangma lost to NCP's Adolf Lu hitler Marak in Rangsakona. Interestingly, raising the issues of corruption and non-performance, many observers and analysts had predicted a debacle for Congress, which increased its tally to 25 from 22 in the last elections, the voters appeared to have rejected "failed" sitting MLAs rather than any party.

Congress set to form coalition Govt
CLP to meet today

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Meghalaya is all set to have a coalition government once again with Congress winning the largest number of seats as results of all the 59 seats of State Assembly elections were declared on Friday. The party has won 25 seats while NCP, which was expected to make a surprise under PA Sangma's leadership, had to be content with only 14 seats followed by UDP with 11 of its legislators being elected.

Though Congress will not be able to form the government on its own, the party has put up a better show than the last election and is all set to come back to power. In 2003, Congress won 22 seats, which is three less than the present tally.

According to MPCC president OL Nongtdu, the party has "no difficulty" in continuing with the relationship with its MDA partners "if they are keen to have an alliance with us".

However, he said, opinions of the newly-elected party legislators would be sought before taking any decision on formation of such an alliance.

"We have no reservation to work with those parties we worked together in the past," Mr Nongtdu said adding "the final decision on formation of the alliance with any party would be taken at the meeting of all elected Congress legislators on Saturday." Congress Legislature Party (CLP) leader will be elected in the meeting.

However, final approval on formation of alliance with any party will have to come from the party high command and all the legislators would also abide the high command's decision, Mr Nongtdu said.

Four Independent legislators from Garo Hills have reportedly expressed their readiness to support the Congress in government formation.

There is also possibility of Congress following the party's tie-up with NCP at the national level. Besides being allies at the UPA Government at the Centre, Congress and NCP are also sharing power in Maharashtra and Goa.

However, NCP's decision in this regard would largely depend on whether party strongman Purno A Sangma would agree on the idea of sharing power with the Congress in the State.

Meanwhile, Mr Lapang tendered his resignation along with his Council of Minister to the Governor Dr SS Sidhu on Friday.

The UDP, which had earlier stated that it would wait for the results before taking any decision 

on post-poll alliance, is yet to make its stand clear on sharing power with the Congress.

The party will meet on Saturday to discuss the issue.

UDP president Dr Donkupar Roy said the decision to support any party would be taken unanimously by all the 11 newly-elected legislators in the meeting. The meeting to be attended by former Chief Ministers EK Mawlong and JD Rymbai will also elect the UDP Legislature Party leader.

A more of less clear picture, as to which party or parties are going to hold the reins of power in the next government, will be available after Saturday's meetings of UDP and Congress.

If both the parties agree to retain the MDA, the Congress, being the single largest party, is likely to stake claim to form the government on the same day before the term of the present Assembly ends on March 10.

Prominent winners

DD Lapang (Cong)

JD Rymbai (UDP)

EK Mawlong (UDP)

Dr Mukul Sangma (Cong)

P A Sangma (NCP)

P Tynsong (Cong)

Martin M Danggo (Cong)

Nehlang Lyngdoh (Cong)

Charles Pyngrope (Cong)

AM Basaiawmoit (UDP).

HS Lyngdoh (HSPDP)

Donkupar Roy (UDP)

Paul Lyngdoh (KHNAM)

Manas Chaudhuri (Ind)

Roytre C Laloo (Cong)

Rowell Lyngdoh (Cong),

Frankenstein Momin,

Abu Taher Mondal (Ind)

Adolf Lu Hitler Marak (NCP),

Nimarson Momin (UDP)

Prominent losers

Salseng C Marak (Cong)

FA Khonglam (HSPDP)

Deborah C Marak (Con)

Admiral K Sangma (NCP)

KK Dkhar (Cong)

M N Mukhim (MDP)

Irin Lyngdoh (Cong)

PM Syiem (NCP)

P T Sawkmie (UDP)

MI Sarkar (Cong)

D P Iangjuh (UDP)

Riang L Tariang (UDP)

Mihsalan Suchiang (UDP)

Sing Mulieh (UDP)

Draison Kharshiing (Cong)

Monindra Rava (Cong)

Elstone D Marak (Cong)

E K Sangma (NCP)

Chamberline Marak (Cong)

BG Momin (UDP).

VERDICT 2008: Snippets

MDP, LJP draw a blank

MDP and Lok Janashakti Party (LJP) drew a blank in the Assembly polls. MDP and LJP contested the elections unsuccessfully from 19 and 18 constituencies respectively. MDP president and Forest Minister Martle N Mukhim himself lost the electoral battle to his UDP rival Remington Lyngdoh by a margin of only 66 votes.

8 businessmen among winners

Eight businessmen have been elected to the 8th Meghalaya Legislative Assembly. The include Nehlang Lyngdoh (Cong), Sniawb-halang Dhar (Cong), Metbah Lyngdoh (UDP), Remington Lyngdoh (UDP), Donkupar Massar (Ind), Charles Pyngrope (Cong), James Pangsang Kongkal Sangma (NCP) and Conrad Kongkal Sangma (NCP).

Lowest victory margin

The lowest victory margin was recorded at Dienglieng constituency where UDP candidate Remington Lyngdoh defeated veteran MDP leader Martle N Mukhim by only 66 votes. BJP candidate AL Hek bagged the highest number of 13086 votes in the elections.

3 former CMs

re-elected

Three former chief ministers were re-elected from their respective constituencies.

They are DD Lapang (Congress), JD Rymbai (UDP and EK Mawlong (UDP).

Five-digit votes

Eleven candidates got votes of five-digit figures. They are DD Lapang (Cong) - 10,974, Nehlang Lyngdoh (Cong) - 12,893, EK Mawlong (UDP) - 10,226, Metbah Lyngdoh (UDP) - 10,642, Comingone Ymbon (Cong) - 12,631, AL Hek (BJP) - 13,086, FS Cajee (Cong) - 12,490, HS Lyngdoh (HSPDP) - 10,537, Marcuise N Marak (NCP) - 11,942, PA Sangma (NCP) - 10,881 and Mukul Sangma (Cong) - 10,626.

5 Independents win

Five Independents have won the 2008 Assembly elections. They include Manas Chaudhuri (Mawprem), Donkupar Massar (Nongshken), Limison Sangma (Tikrikilla), Abu Taher Mondal (Phulbari) and Ismail R Marak (Rongram).

Lone woman MLA

Only one out of the 19 woman candidates, who were in the fray, emerged winner.

UDP candidate for Laitumkhrah constituency Ampareen Lyngdoh is the lone female candidate to be elected to the 8th Meghalaya Legislative Assembly. Prominent among the woman candidates who lost the election were Health Minister Deborah C Marak and Pariong legislator Irin Lyngdoh.

Cry for change brings in 25 new faces

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: All the 25 new faces, who made it to the eight State Legislative Assembly, are of the view that people are fed up with the stagnant development process and wanted a change in leadership for the sake of uplift of their respective constituencies. They have attributed their success to the voters saying it was the people's love which made their victory possible.

Congress' winner from Mylliem, Ronnie V Lyngdoh, who caused a major upset by defeating seasoned campaigner and NCP candidate Pynshai Manik Syiem, said people of the constituency had sought a new leader to bring development "from which the constituency was deprived of for the last 15 years."

In the name of development all along the years, there was only distribution of goods under some schemes, he said. Mr Lyngdoh has promised to bring sustainable development among the majority farming community in the constituency. He also lamented the fact that though there are 16 high schools in the constituency, the constituency still does not have a full-fledged college. Congress' Founder S Cajee, who, in his third attempt, gave a body blow to UDP's Process T Sawkmie in Mawlai, said his top priority is to improve the standard of living of the large number of downtrodden families in the constituency. Mr Cajee said his ultimate aim is to make Mawlai the most shinning constituency of the State. Victorious UDP candidate Ampareen Lyngdoh gave an assurance to the people of Laitumkhrah constituency that she would try to follow the vision document of the party in the coming five years for development of the constituency. "If I can bring a change to the life of the 300 underprivileged families in the constituency, I would believe my job is done," Mrs Lyngdoh said. She said her father and former MP, PG Marbaniang, still plays a big role in her life and that this victory would not have been possible without his blessings. UDP's Nongkrem winner Ardent M Basaiawmoit, who came as a surprise surpassing two big players -- KHNAM's Lambor Malngiang and Independent HS Shylla --, said his keyword to success was his campaign against use of "money power" during the elections.

Besides promising to implement the various government schemes to benefit the common people, he said "as a responsible legislator," he would oppose any government decision made against the will of the people.

Pyngshngainlang Syiem of Congress, who shocked sitting UDP legislator DP Iangjuh in Mawsynram, said he would try to bring transparency and accountability in the implementation of the various schemes. After handing a shocking defeat to veteran regional leader and MDP chief Martle N Mukhim in Dienglieng, UDP's Remington Lyngdoh said the people wanted a change which ultimately led to his victory.

NEW FACES: Lakmen Rymbui (Congress) from War-Jaintia, Comingone Ymbon (Congress) from Raliang, EC Boniface Bamon (NCP) from Nartiang, Sniawbhalang Dhar (Congress) from Nongbah-Wahiajer, Donbok Khymdeit (UDP) from Mawhati, Metbah Lyngdoh (UDP) from Mairang, Ronnie V Lyngdoh (Congress) from Mylliem, Ampareen Lyngdoh (UDP) from Laitumkhrah, Sanbor Shullai (NCP) from Laban, Founder S Cajee (Congress) from Mawlai, Remington Pyngrope (UDP) from Dienglieng, Ardent M Basaiawmoit (UDP) from Nongkrem, Donkupar Massar (Ind) from Nongskhen, Dr Phlour W Khongjee (Congress) from Sohra, Pynshngainlang Syiem (Congress) from Mawsynram, Dr Adviser Pariong (HSPDP) from Pariong, Marcuis M Marak (NCP) from Rongrenggiri, Omillo K Sangma (NCP) from Kharkutta, Nihim D Shira (NCP) from Songsak, Limison Sangma (Ind) from Tikrikilla, James Pangseng K Sangma (NCP) from Rongchugiri, Conrad K Sangma (NCP) from Selsella, Ismail R Marak (Ind) from Rongram, Phillipole Marak (NCP) from Kherapara and Salseng Sangma (Congress) from Dalamgiri.

32 sitting MLAs bite the dust

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: As many as 32 sitting legislators bit the dust in the elections. The are Riang Lennon Tariang (UDP), Mihsalan Suchiang (UDP), Draison Kharshiing (Congress), Sing Mulieh (UDP), Phingwell Muktieh (Congress), Stanley Wiss Rymbai (Congress), Boldness L Nongum (Congress), Pynshai Manik Syiem (NCP), Tony Curtis Lyngdoh (Congress), Process T Sawkmie (UDP), Martle N Mukhim (MDP), Lambor Malngiang (KHNAM), Khan Khong Dkhar (Congress), Flinder A Khonglam (HSPDP), D Plaslanding Iangjuh (UDP), Bires Nongsiej (UDP), Irin Lyngdoh (Congress), Deborah C Marak (Congress), Elstone D Marak (Congress), Beninstand G Momin (UDP), Tonsing N Marak (Congress), Monindro Rava (Congress), Edmund K Sangma (NCP), Beckstar Sangma (Congress), Manirul Islam Sarkar (Congress), Clement Marak (Congress), Sengman R Marak (Congress), Billy Kid A Sangma (Ind), Brening A Sangma (Congress), Admiral K Sangma (NCP), Zenith M Sangma (Congress) and Nidhu Ram Hajong (Ind).

Fractured mandate to affect devp: Purno

From Our Correspondent

TURA: Elated at his win in Tura but disappointed with the overall results of the March-3 elections, Garo Hills strongman Purno A Sangma is hoping against hope that a non-Congress coalition government will be formed in Meghalaya, saying a hung Assembly will further hamper development activities in the State.

"I can't say what happened for such a change. We will analyse the election results in the coming days. But, we accept the people's verdict," a dejected Mr Sangma said after NCP came a distant second behind Congress.

The newly-elected NCP MLAs will meet in Shillong on Saturday to try and cobble up a coalition minus Congress.

"All non-Congress parties are going to have a meeting with us in Shillong tomorrow at 6 am. We will decide our next step," Mr Sangma told The Shillong Times on Friday evening.

Expressing his unhappiness with the results, the chief ministerial candidate of NCP said the fractured verdict would only affect development of Meghalaya.

"We have seen what happened during the last five years when frequent change of government took place due to absence of any single party getting a clear majority in the previous elections," Mr Sangma said.

His limited victory margin (2825 votes) against sitting MLA Billykid a Sangma (Ind) in Tura appears to have forced the once formidable heavyweight into retrospect.

"There was a divide between tribal and non-tribal votes. I will ask my non-tribal friends what was wrong with my candidature," Mr Sangma said.

Keeping all options open- post election- Mr Sangma said NCP was not averse to sit in the opposition benches.

"If the situation requires we are ready to sit in the opposition," Mr Sangma added.

Halt to Mukhim’s 20-yr political journey

By Our Reporter

Shillong: MDP has suffered a major setback in this election with the party drawing a blank and even president Martle N Mukhim losing the electoral race.

Mr Mukhim, who has represented Dienglieng constituency for 20 years, surprisingly lost to Remington Pyngrope of UDP by a small margin of 66 votes.

On the party's poor show, a distressed Mr Mukhim said, "At present I can't make any comment."

However, he said, use of "money power" by other parties may be one of the causes that led to his "unexpected" downfall.

The veteran regional leader said he has respect for the verdict of the people and will not lose heart.

According to supporters, who were seen weeping after Mukhim declared lost, money power played a big role in the defeat of the MDP chief.

A "post-mortem meeting" would be called in the coming days to analyse the cause of the party's debacle and to decide the future strategy, he said.

Winners promise to carry on ‘good work’

By Our Reporter

Shillong: BJP's lone winner AL Hek on Friday assured the people of carrying on his "unfinished work" for development of Pynthorum- khrah constituency, while Independent candidate Manas Chaudhuri, after his victory, said he would continue to work hard for development of Mawprem constituency.

Talking to reporters after the poll results, Mr Hek said, "I'll try my level best to work for overall development of Pynthorum khrah constituency."

Congress legislator from Sohryngkham Charles Pyngrope claimed that development work done by him in the past five years earned him the victory. "I had worked for uplift of the rural poor," he said.

Thanking the people of Malki-Nongthymmai for electing him, veteran regional party leader Bindo M Lanong (UDP) stressed the need for equidistribution of funds sanctioned under MLA scheme.

Independent legislator Manas Chaudhuri, after his re-election to the Assembly from Mawprem seat, said his hard work to uplift the whole constituency had paid off . Mr Chaudhuri also said he would remain committed to development of his constituency.


Telangana issue and Congress

Four years after the Congress aligned with the newly-formed Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) in Andhra Pradesh, the two parties have parted ways. A paradigm shift has taken place in Andhra politics with the TRS’s 16 MLAs, six MLCs and four MPs resigning this week. It was a marriage of convenience effected in 2004 with the sole objective of ousting the Telugu Desam Party government headed by Chandrababu Naidu. Their efforts succeeded in the installation of the Rajasekhara Reddy-led Congress government. The TRS, which won four Lok Sabha seats, supported the UPA at the Centre. But much has happened since then, and the TRS is struggling to stay afloat. The breaking point came after the TRS failed to get a separate Telangana state. What better way to pressure the Congress than to resign from Lok Sabha and the State Assembly a few months before the elections? The Congress is not yet ready for a decision on the tricky Telangana issue.

The concerns for a separate Telangana were manifold. First of all, Congress has to find a consensus within the party at the local as well as at the central level. Congress leaders from the Telangana region also want a separate state while those from the other two regions - coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema - are opposed to it. Congressmen from these regions are afraid that their influence will decline with the creation of a Telangana state. It will be difficult to get a resolution for a separate Telangana passed in the State Assembly without which the process cannot begin. The Congress leadership is clear that statehood cannot be achieved in the absence of a consensus among political parties at the Centre. A consensus is possible only when the CPI (M), Samajwadi Party and the Telugu Desam retract from their opposition to a separate Telangana State. The AICC will not take any initiative before the next Lok Sabha polls even as pro-Telangana leaders have vetoed its move to constitute a second States Reorganisation Commission (SRC). The impact of the TRS leaving the UPA will be felt at the time of elections. In Andhra Pradesh, both the Congress and the TRS have to face an acid test. In the next elections, the Congress may be isolated as the left parties are looking to the newly formed UNPA which includes the TDP. The BJP and the NCP support the TRS. For a weakened TRS, it will be a tough task to prove its strength. If film star Chiranjeevi floats a new party, that would also pose a danger to the Congress.



Congress needs some serious populism

By Praful Bidwai

Now that India must go into the next general election within 12 to 14 months, if not earlier, the Congress has had no choice but to make some tentative moves to face the contest, if not quite to fight it spiritedly. But it’s doing so reluctantly, listlessly, without its heart in the exercise. Or else, it wouldn’t have adopted defensive, dodgy, unconvincing or plainly tactless postures, appeared clueless about its strategies of political mobilisation and alliance-building, and presented an unappealing visage to the public.

On the eve of the budget session, the Congress fell back on something that a self-confident party should never do: launch a training programme in corporate-style "media management" and "image makeover" for its key members. It invited self-styled desi management gurus like Ujjwal K Chowdhury to hold a two-day session for its state-level spokespersons, which was devoted to anger and stress management, "the right way" of shaking hands, dressing up for television and deciphering body language.

Party spokespersons also got "capsules" (puffs) on issues like the India-US nuclear deal, Ram Setu, the Maoist movement and the Sachar Committee from TV-oriented Congress leaders like Kapil Sibal and Salman Khursheed. A couple of journalists were thrown in too, to offer advice against "off-the-record" conversations and excessive drinking.

Amidst this inane image-polishing exercise, most participants seem to have forgotten that an image ultimately derives from its source, the object; it can never be separated from it. Putting a successful spin on or dressing up something well depends on the content of what’s being embellished.

If you don’t have a pro-poor and inclusive economic policy, you won’t be able to sell Special Economic Zones by citing their (non-existent or negligible) employment potential. If your decision-makers believe that the only strategic-political "game in town" is the American one, and there’s no alternative to tailing the United States on the nuclear deal, it’s foolish to sell it on the ground that it’s good for India’s energy security (which it is manifestly isn’t).

It won’t do to chant the Aam Aadmi slogan while handing out generous tax-breaks to the rich and demanding lower interest rates and reduced EMIs (equalised monthly instalments) on housing loans for the urban upper middle class, and saying nothing about the overwhelming majority of Indians who don’t have a pucca house with a toilet.

Again, it’s simply unconvincing for the Congress to advocate high principles and a pluralist notion of Indianness based on a multi-lingual, multicultural identity, and claim to defend the citizen’s fundamental right to live and travel anywhere in India while mollycoddling the ultra-chauvinist Shiv Sena and Mr Raj Thackeray.

Unfortunately, the Congress has failed to rise beyond the "SEZ-EMI" level of salesmanship. This might appeal to the privileged, but will do virtually nothing to win the votes of the majority. The Congress-led United Progressive Alliance has pursued GDP-obsessed policies which have greatly increased inequalities and jeopardised millions of vulnerable livelihoods—from the tribals in Orissa’s and Chhattisgarh’s mineral-rich tracts to small farmers working lands being acquired for posh urban housing and SEZs, and from Vidarbha’s suicide-prone cotton-growers to the vegetable-hawker and raddiwala/kabariwala in every city.

As organised retail grows at breakneck speed, stores catering to the middle class are fiercely competing with one another by underselling vegetables at Rs 5 or 6 a kilo, when their wholesale price is double that, and the local vendor retails them for Rs 12-15. Now, some big chains are even offering Rs 25 for a kg of old newspapers—directly hitting some of the hardest-working people in the economy, who perform a valuable ecological function by recycling waste.

The greatest irony is, the UPA is only half-committed to its own progressive schemes and legislations. These include the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act—extended from 200 districts in 2006 to 330 districts last year, now to all 600 districts of India—, the Right to Information Act, and the Forest Dwellers Act, which recognises the Scheduled Tribes’ rights to modest plots of highly degraded forest land.

The NREGA is meant to have a far-reaching impact by creating 100 days of employment at minimum wages for each rural poor household. Admittedly, its performance needs improvement. In 2006-07, only 56 per cent of the targeted below-poverty-line households got the promised employment—a fair increase over the previous year’s 41 per cent.

Yet, wherever the administration implemented the scheme transparently and followed the rules, it got good results. Even poor states like Rajasthan and Assam were able to record high achievements proportional to targets: 78 and 86 per cent respectively.

Elitist or ill-informed writers have run a nasty crusade against the NREGA, ridiculing it as an expensive way of spreading corruption without denting poverty. Some critics cite a provisional and very limited report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, which looks at 513 villages in 68 districts. A careful look at the document shows that corruption runs in the tens of lakhs and not crores, and can be greatly reduced through the transparency safeguards built into the Act and its guidelines.

Independent citizens’ groups, such as those led by eminent academic Jean Dreze and his students, and by RTI activist Aruna Roy, have conducted social audits of the NREGA in several states. They conclude that corruption can be substantially reduced, if not eliminated, and employment targets met, through popular involvement in the planning of schemes, and proper attention to their location, work application procedures, distribution of job cards, worksite management, record-keeping, etc.

However, the UPA is planning to raise the NREGA allocation by less than 40 percent while doubling its coverage. A scheme like this needs the widest possible publicity on rural television and radio, with a simple explanation of the right of the poor to work, and of procedures for applying for it. It also needs dedicated bureaucrats willing to work with civil society and landless labourers’ unions, as well as a strong push from above.

That push is lacking. The UPA government has been foolishly spending money on advertising the scheme in English on BBC World! It has not generated the necessary will and energy in the administration in favour of the Act. Nor has it recognised the powerful local obstacles to its implementation. After all, the rural rich, who increasingly seek to extract more work from the poor, have a stake in keeping wages at starvation level and killing any alternative employment opportunity. This opportunity is precisely what the Act provides. The government hasn’t drawn up a strategy to counter the influence of the privileged elite.

Similarly, non-UPA states like Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Orissa have done more to implement the Forest Rights Act than UPA states (barring Andhra). The UPA stands to lose electoral dividends from its own progressive measure—unless it corrects course. The RTI too has turned out a story of the left hand taking away part of what the right hand has given, with the executive (especially the bureaucracy) whittling down the Act’s scope, and hedging it in with all kinds of conditions that violate transparency.

If the UPA’s record on equity and empowering the poor is indifferent, it continues to drift Rightwards on foreign and security policy too. India’s "strategic partnership" with the US, and now Israel, is growing just when these two have contributed to making the world more insecure. Meanwhile, India is losing some of its stature in West Asia, Southeast and South Asia, and now increasingly, in Africa.

Having agreed with the Left not to carry further the process of negotiation of the US-India nuclear deal, the UPA is caving in to pressure from the US administration to abide by a tight deadline (early May) to complete the deal and send it to the US Congress for ratification. Merits apart, this risks loss of the Left’s support and a mid-term election for which the UPA isn’t well prepared. After the election, it may again need to tie up with the Left—unless it wants to become dependent on Ms Mayawati.

The truth is, the Congress/UPA lacks a political strategy. It looks over the shoulder all the time and is afraid of taking bold populist measures in the best sense of that term—putting the interests of the majority at the centre of policies and doing everything to mobilise mass energies.

Nor is the UPA remotely showing a sense of urgency in organisational matters. It has lost the Telengana Rashtra Samiti and the MDMK. Its constituents in Bihar and Tamil Nadu peaked electorally in 2004. Neither the Rashtriya Janata Dal-Lok Janashakti Party, nor the DMK-led alliance will repeat their scores. It has to find small, new allies—just as Ms Sonia Gandhi did four years ago with tireless efforts.

The UPA should know that its adversaries, especially the NDA, have many chinks in their armour—despite manufactured appearances. It can take them on only if it reaches out to the masses, like Indira Gandhi did. It would be a shame if it loses for want of trying. (IPA Service)

Sons Of Soil Issue
Turning into a hot potato

By Insaf
Round the States

The ‘sons of soil’ issue in Maharashtra refuses to die down. With the Shiv Sena Chief Bal Thackeray firing the latest salvo by targeting the Biharis asserting that they were an 'unwanted lot' in all parts of the country. "Not only Maharashtra, they are not wanted in southern India, Assam, Punjab and Chandigarh," he thundered. Challenging RJD Chief Lallu to perform Chhat Puja in Mumbai, the Sena leader added for good measure, "Those who have turned Bihar into hell should not try teach nationalism to Maharashtra." Predictably, Thackeray’s comments reverberated in both Houses of Parliament with Lalu’s RJD MPs giving a notice of breach of privilege against Thackeray, accusing him of "lowering the dignity of MPs as also Parliament" And the Lok Sabha Speaker Somnath Chatterjee stating that such references amounted to contempt of the House.

The Telangana Statehood issue is hotting up again with Parties gearing up for General elections next year, if not earlier. All four Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) MPs resigned from the Lok Sabha on Monday and 16 of its 26 MLAs and 3 MLCs followed suit the next day. The reason: Sonia Gandhi and UPA Government’s "betrayal of promises made to the people of the Telangana region.

In the 2004 Assembly elections the TRS President K Chandrasekhara Rao had formed an alliance with the Congress and joined the Government both in the State and at the Centre.

In fact, the issue is fast turning into a hot potato for both the State and Central Government. Notwithstanding, the Union Home Minister Shivraj Patil statement in the Lok Sabha on Monday that Mumbai is built by people of all regions and belongs to all. Making plain that the Centre would not allow any Party to target migrants anywhere in the country he added, "No one can be stopped or restricted from going to any place of work." Taking a cue from this, the Maharashtra police served a show cause notice to the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena Chief Raj Thackeray asking him to explain why the gag order enforced on him following his anti-North Indian agitation should not be extended. Clearly with the Shiv Sena supremo trying to recapture his Party’s 'Marathi sons' plank, hijacked by nephew Raj the last word has still to be said!

No arms to fight naxals in Chhattisgarh

Chhattisgarh’s best known secret has now got the official seal. No less that the Chief Minister Raman Singh confessed that "some 50-odd police stations located in the Dandkarenya forests running through its inter-state borders of Chhattisgarh, Orissa and Maharashtra have to fight the AK-47 and SLR-wielding Naxalite guerrillas with just batons." Adding that the police were denied arms and ammunition because of fear that they may be snatched or looted by the Naxals. Shockingly, the decision not to give arms to certain police stations in the "orange" and "green" zones was justified on two counts. One, it was to ensure fire power availability for the arms-strapped Central forces and the police to take on the Naxalites. Two, the risk of the innocent villager being caught in the crossfire between Naxals and the police was minimised. Never mind, that the State’s ‘no-arms’ policy has cost the State dearly with scores of policemen and innocent villagers being killed by the militants. Even as the State prepares for what could be its biggest counter-operation against Left-wing extremists.

Telangana issue hots up again

The Telangana Statehood issue is hotting up again with Parties gearing up for General elections next year, if not earlier. All four Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) MPs resigned from the Lok Sabha on Monday and 16 of its 26 MLAs and 3 MLCs followed suit the next day. The reason: Sonia Gandhi and UPA Government’s "betrayal of promises made to the people of the Telangana region. In the 2004 Assembly elections the TRS President K Chandrasekhara Rao had formed an alliance with the Congress and joined the Government both in the State and at the Centre. In 2006 it withdrew its support to the UPA on the grounds of being cheated and set 6 March as the deadline for the Centre to start the process of carving out a separate Telangana. Will the resignations help the cause? While their numbers may not rock the boat at the Centre and State, it could affect the vote banks in the coming polls. Moreover, it could help the TRS to carve out an alliance with the BJP, which is supporting their demand for Statehood.

Home coming for Pandits

Winds of change are blowing in the Kashmir Valley. After 18-long years, displaced Pandits are finally getting a roof over their heads they can call their own again. On Monday last, 26 non-migrant Kashmiri Pandit families moved into the Valley’s first exclusive "safe zone" Pandit’s colony in Sheikhpora, on the outskirts of Srinagar. About 200 families would shift into the colony, with 16-feet high walls and guarded, in the first phase of the rehabilitation package of the J&K Government. With terrorism taking roots in 1989 in the State, the minority Pandits were forced to flee their homes and live in wretched dwellings. Migrants in their own country, the Pandits may never get what they lost, but if their Kashmiri Muslim neighbours so desire, their return could be a major step forward towards normalcy.

Mob fury in Bihar

Mob fury is ever-increasing in Bihar. Two boys were beaten and shot dead by villagers as they tried to flee after killing a man in Teka Bigha, in Patna district and a man was lynched by villagers in Munger district after he shot dead a school boy in a drunken state on Monday last. Shockingly, the two boys were lynched just 4 km away from Chief Minister Nitish Kumar’s backyard Bakhtiarpur. Recall, in September last 10 suspected thieves were lynched by villagers in Vaishali, another person was lynched ten days later in Gopalganj and yet one more in October. Needless Police enforcements have been sent and patrolling has been intensified, says the Patna Police. The horrific incidents once again underscore that there is no rule of law in the State despite intensification of police patrolling and more forces.

"Dirty" Delhi

It’s bad news for Delhi. The country’s Capital has been tagged as one of the dirtiest cities in the world. The rating comes from none other than the Forbes magazine. In its report dated 22 February 2008, the renowned magazine rates Delhi as the "24th dirtiest city." Obviously, the "filthy waters of the Yamuna and its unhealthy surroundings" haven’t gone unnoticed by the magazine. The report consults Mercer’s Health and Sanitation rankings Quality of Life report, 2007 in which Delhi scores a sad 46.6 on health and sanitation index while the most polluted city Baku in Azerbaijan scored 27.6. With Delhi to play host to the Commonwealth Games 2010, its time the municipal authorities clean up their act. ---- INFA

Illegal settlers

Sir,

When one visits places like Garobadha, Rajabala, Mahendraganj is left astonished. The reason behind this is because though this place comes under the Garo Hills, Bangladeshis are dominant force in the area. This indicates that the district administration and the local NGOs have been mere spectator to these issues. Local politicians are benefited by these illegal Bangladeshis. They are used as vote bank. Garos are outnumbered by those refugees staying in those areas illegally and that is why there is no Garo representative from this area. The ANVC is supposes to protect the rights of the Garos but they are only interested in extorting money from the local hard-working people. Why do not they learn from NSCN? Hence, my opinion is to arouse the Garos to this fact!

Yours etc
Daniel Sangma,
Gurgaon
Via e-mail

Budget for farmers

Sir,

By waiving the massive Rs 60000 crore farmers' debts, Union Finance Minster P Chidambaram has performed an astounding feat in the present Budget. Thanks to the ensuing Parliamentary election 2009 and a series of shocking suicide cases. Yes, the worst plight of the poor has turned out to be the best opportunity for the Finance Minister to exercise his pseudo-benevolence. Now unarguably, it will earn the UPA massive vote-bank in the next year election.

Oh, let's learn to put all the political gimmicks aside and be practical and genuinely humane. Well, at least for the sake of the country that predominately has farmers who are parched in the heat of miseries, I request the leaders not to feel complacent. It is now high time that our leaders rather make a series of innovative explorations so far as improvement in the agriculture sector is concerned. Frankly speaking, the infrastructures that we have now and the technology that we have introduced in this sector are of embarrassingly poor quality. The modern knowledge, measures and mechanisms to turn the barren land into fertile field are not known to our raw peasants. I believe, a big revolutionary step is what we need to take if we genuinely want to see our farmers not starving any more but eating two times wholesome meals heartily.

Yours etc,
Salil Gewali,
Shillong-2
Via e-mail


 Left sweeps Tripura

From Our Correspondent

Agartala: In yet another landslide victory, the ruling Left Front is all set to form next Government in Tripura.

As expected, the ruling front won 49 Assembly constituencies of the total 60 seats while its arch rival - Congress-INPT bagged only 11 seats, according to the results of Assembly elections that held on February 23.

The Forward Bloc, an ally of the ruling front, which opted out the Left Front could not make any impact in the electoral battle.

The Left Front has consolidated its strength as it increased its tally from 41 to 49 seats and number of Congress-INPT legislators has reduced from 19 to 11. A total of five Congress MLAs including PCC president Samir Ranjan Barman lost to their arch rival, Left Front.

Likewise, CPI(M) also suffered set back as one Minister- Bijoy Laxmi Singha and Deputy Speaker Subal Rudra lost to Congress candidates.

Rita Kar, CPI(M) candidate won the Sabroom Assembly constituency with highest margin (8032) while INPT president Bijoy Kumar Hragkhawl retained its 'own' constituency- Kulai with a narrow margin of 115 votes.

Side by side, the winning margin of Chief Minister Manik Sarkar has reduced from 4500 votes in 2008 to 2900 votes in 2003 votes.

The much hyped anti-incumbency factor does not click in the Left ruled State this time too.

The ruling front made impressive show in South Tripura district by wining all the fourteen Assembly constituencies.

Chief Minister Manik Sarkar greeted the voters to ensure victory of Left Front to speed up development activities in the State.



National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |

 

                                               

Make This Your HomePage! | About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery

Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.