News  of 4th March 2008

National | Shillong | Interntional | Editorial | Regional | Sports 

Govt says evolving consensus on N-deal; Left issues fresh warning

New Delhi: As the US continues to press India to conclude the nuclear deal at the earliest, Government on Monday said efforts were on to evolve a broad political consensus here on the issue.

The Left parties, however, insisted that there was no consensus on the deal and warned the government of serious consequences if steps were taken to operationalise it.

Making a suo moto statement in the Lok Sabha, External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee defended the initiative, saying it was essential to ensure end to an "unfair technology denial" regime and sanctions faced by India for over three decades.

"We will continue to seek broad political consensus within the country to take forward our engagement on this issue with other countries," Mukherjee said.

He did not elaborate but was clearly referring to efforts to overcome the stiff opposition by the Left allies to operationalisation of the deal with the US. Seeking to allay the apprehensions of Left and other parties over the Hyde Act, Mukherjee said the legislation was an enabling provision between the Executive and Legislative organs of the US and India will have civil nuclear cooperation with the US under the 123 Agreement only. (PTI)

Kashmir Singh released

NEW DELHI: Kashmir Singh, the Indian who had been languishing in various jails in Pakistan for the past 35 years, was released on Monday from Lahore's Central jail.

He would cross into India and to his home in Punjab on Tuesday, said caretaker Federal Minister for Human Rights Ansar Burney. Kashmir Singh would be walking into India from the Wagah border at around 11 am on Tuesday. The Ansar Burney Trust has been entrusted with the Indian's custody. (PTI)

Delimitation Bill

New Delhi:Law Minister H R Bhardwaj on Monday introduced in the Lok Sabha the Delimitation (Amendment) Bill, 2008 which seeks to replace a related ordinance. The proposed law would defer the delimitation exercise in some North-Eastern states and Jharkhand. (UNI)

Opp, Left slam Govt  over farm loan waiver 
Advani smells early polls
Inflation still a threat: FM

New Delhi: Opp- osition and Left parties on Monday came down heavily on the government for not making any budgetary provisions for farm loan waiver, even as Leader of Opposition L K Advani said there were indications that general elections, scheduled next year, could be advanced.

"It seems elections are nearing. Even if they are held in 2009 as scheduled and not in 2008, this is the last Presidential Address of this government," Advani said while participating in the debate on the Presidential address to the Parliament. "Elections may take place earlier than scheduled.... The people will review the performance of the UPA government... whether it fulfils the promises it has made," he said.

Maintaining that he supported loan waivers for indebted farmers, the senior BJP leader wanted to know why budgetary provisions were not made for the purpose. He also took the government to task for its "failure" to table the Women's Reservation Bill and create a separate state of Telengana. "We are prepared to support the government on the women's reservation issue. Whether it wants to bring in the original bill or enact the suggestions made by the Election Commission (that political parties reserve one-third seats for women)," Advani said. Initiating the debate, Congress leader Ajit Jogi said the loan waiver by the UPA government amounting to Rs 60,000 crore would provide relief to the small and marginal farmers across the country.

Meanwhile, expres- sing concern over rising food prices, Finance Minister P Chidambaram defended his budget proposal of waiving farm loans and rejected the criticism that the budget has forgotten the corporate sector.

"One of the reasons why inflation is still a threat is food prices in India," Chidambaram said, adding that after a long gap India has become a marginal importer of foodgrain, which is a dangerous omen.

"Because we are dependent on import, we are subject to world prices... No country with as large a population as India can be dependent on imports (of foodgrain)," he said at the post-budget interactive session with industry chambers. Since April 2007, prices of wheat in the global market has risen by 88 per cent and that of rice by 15 per cent, he said.

"Taking all this into consideration, we came to the conclusion that farmers distress calls for unorthodox response... response was farm loan waiver," the Finance Minister said.

The wholesale price-based inflation rose to 4.89 per cent for the week ended February 16 from 4.35 per cent in the previous week.

Responding to the issues raised by the corporate sector, he said: "I have not forgotten the corporate sector. Despite the advice given by my Chief Economic Advisor and suggestion from Economic Survey, we accepted your (corporates) demand of retaining peak Customs Duty rate." (PTI)

TRS MPs resign from LS

New Delhi: All four TRS MPs, including its leader K Chandrasekhar Rao, on Monday resigned from the Lok Sabha protesting delay in creation of a separate Telengana state.

The TRS members -- Rao, Vinod Kumar, Ravindra Naik and T Madhusudan Reddy -- submitted their resignation to Lok Sabha Speaker Somnath Chatterjee as the House assembled in the morning.

Raising slogans of "Jai Telengana", the TRS members walked out of the House.

The move is being seen as TRS' attempt to put pressure on the UPA Government on the demand for a Telengana state.

Leader of Opposition L K Advani noted that it was the first occasion when members have given their resignation in the House itself.

"In many, many years, it is the first occasion in the House that members have submitted their resignation in the House itself. The issue of Telengana deserves a full-fledged discussion," Advani said and complaining that the President's Address to Parliament did not make any mention of the issue.

The development also saw members of the treasury and opposition trading charges.

All 16 MLAs and three MLCs belonging to the party will resign from the Andhra Pradesh Assembly tomorrow.

Announcing the decision to resign from Lok Sabha yesterday, Rao had accused the Congress, with which it had contested the previous Assembly elections, of betraying it after coming to power on the issue of a separate Telengana state. (PTI)

Cong ‘very happy’ over progress in IAEA talks

New Delhi: The Congress on Monday said it was "very happy" over the progress made in the IAEA talks in connection with the Indo-US nuclear deal and sought to bring the Left around for an understanding over the ticklish issue.

"We are happy that India has made significant and notable progress at the IAEA talks. We are particularly happy that a vast and diverse area of differences have been covered, have been ironed out in the fifth round of talks," AICC spokesman Abhishek Singhvi told reporters.

Singhvi made a suo-motu statement at the AICC briefing saying it was "equally optimistic, positive and hopeful" about the deliberations and consultations at the Joint Mechanism of the UPA and Left parties which shall follow after the IAEA talks.

"We are confident of a constructive approach by all concerned... totally confident and sure of a reasonable approach by all sections of the Joint Mechanism", he said.

The AICC spokesman's statement came on a day when External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee made a statement in Parliament on foreign policy issues including the nuclear issue.

Questioning certain statements from the US, Mukherjee made it clear that its rights and obligations on civil nuclear cooperation came only from the bilateral 123 Agreement and it was not bound by the controversial Hyde Act.

BJP rejects govt.'s argument on Hyde Act

Maintaining opposition to the Indo-US civil nuclear deal, the BJP on Monday rejected the government's argument that the Hyde Act would have no bearing on the agreement and asked it not to operationalise it.

Soon after External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee made a statement on the nuclear deal in the Lok Sabha, the opposition party said the government should not go ahead to operationalise the deal as there was no consensus on it.

Mukherjee's statement that the Hyde Act "is not binding on us is opposite to the statement by American official. Government should make the situation clear," BJP spokesperson Vijay Kumar Malhotra told reporters here.

Cautioning the government against going ahead with the deal without consensus, he said, "consensus should not be merely with the Left parties." (PTI)

Police may extend gag on Raj Thackeray

Mumbai: As the curb on MNS chief Raj Thackeray, who had indulged in anti-North Indian tirade, from addresing rallies and the media expires at midnight tonight, the city police will send him a showcause notice to explain why the restriction against him should not continue.

"The current order lapses at midnight tonight and we are contemplating extending the restrictions imposed on Raj," Mumbai Police Commissioner Hasan Gafoor told PTI here.

He said the Deputy Commissioner of Police (Operation) will be issuing a showcause notice to Raj Thackeray and based on his reply the further course of action, including extension of the gag order, will be decided.

If the gag order is extended, it may hamper the second anniversary celebration of MNS on March 9.

Under the order served as per the provisions in the criminal procedure code, Raj is allowed to move anywhere he wants but cannot make any statement which will be provocative in nature.

After violent clashes between MNS workers and Samajwadi Party on February 3, the party cadre had indulged in a violent anti-north Indian migrants campaign across Maharashtra following which the first gag order was served on February 11.

Raj was arrested on February 13 on charges of making inflammatory statements and inciting violence. He was released on bail the same day. (PTI)

SC notice to IPS officer for ‘attack-on-judge order’

New Delhi: An woman IPS officer's conduct has come under the Supreme Court scanner for allegedly ordering her bodyguards to assault a Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) judge during his official visit to Ranchi last month.

The apex court on Monday issued a notice to the IGP-rank IPS officer, Nirmala Amitabh Choudhary, the Centre and the Jharkhand government in connection with the attack on CAT member Justice V V Rao.

A Bench comprising Chief Justice KG Balakrishnan and Justice RV Raveendran treated a letter, received by the court in connection with the incident, as a writ petition and sought details from the Centre and the state through its Chief Secretary about the February 21 incident

The CAT judge had come to Ranchi from Bangalore on an official visit during which the IGP's bodyguards allegedly attacked the him on her instruction.

An FIR has already been lodged on Justice Rao's complaint against Choudhary. Eight security men who had accompanied her to the place of incident were subsequently suspended.

The IPS officer, posted in the vigilance wing of Jharkhand State Electricity Board, has been sent for psychiatric treatment to Ranchi Institute of Neuro-Psychiatry and Allied Sciences (RINPAS).

After the incident, a senior police official had reportedly said that the behaviour of Choudhury was not normal and she has been sent to RINPAS for check-up.

The IPS officer had allegedly claimed that she had been receiving threatening e-mails after she returned from Hyderabad in connection with a case of internet fraud.

SC for status quo on demolition of tsunami victims' houses

In another order, the Supreme Court on Monday directed the Tamil Nadu government to maintain status quo relating to demolition of "unsafe" houses built to rehabilitate Tsunami affected families in Nagapattinam district.

A bench of Chief Justice K G Balakrishnan and Justice R V Raveendran issued notices to the state government and the Collector, Nagapattinam District, on a petition by an NGO and an house allottee challenging a Madras High Court order in which it held the houses as unsafe and unfit for living.

The NGO, Salvation Army, which was entrusted with the construction of 44 houses, said it was ready to carry out the required repair work otherwise there would be a loss of around Rs 70 lakhs.

The High Court on January 10 had accepted the report of a Committee set up by the state government and had asked the authorities to demolish the houses on the ground they were unfit for living and were of inferior quality.

The apex court also perused the report and expressed its displeasure over the type houses alloted to the Tsunami victims.

"Bricks can be pulled out by hand. No plaster has been put on the walls," the Bench said referring to the report.

"What to talk about Tsunami it will not even stand the earthquake," the Bench observed adding that "roofs are leaking and the construction is so bad". (PTI)

The court was informed that each of the house cost the government Rs 1.5 lakhs.

SC seeks details on HC judges’ appointment

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday directed the Centre to place before it the memorandum of procedure for appointment of permanent judges in High Courts as in the last nine years 351 such appointments were made without the approval of the collegium of apex court judges.

A Bench headed by Justice Arijit Pasayat said a "serious question" was involved in the matter as not one but many such appointments had been made between January 1, 1999 to July 31, 2007.

The Bench, also comprising Justice P Sathasivam, was hearing a petition filed by former law minister Shanti Bhushan questioning the appointment of Justice Ashok Kumar as a permanent judge of the Madras High Court despite an adverse report of the apex court collegium.

Bhushan raised the issue of alleged lapses in confirmation of additional judges as permanent High Court judges without following the proper procedure.

In response to the petition filed last year, the Centre in an affidavit said during January 1, 1999 to July 31, 2007, the collegium of the apex court was not consulted before appointment of 351 judges in various High Courts. (PTI)

Perusing the affidavit, the Bench said it was not about a single case of Justice Kumar and it wanted to know "what would have happened if the apex court collegium had refused to approve any such appointment".

"We feel that the dispute is not only about Justice Kumar) as the affidavit shows that same practice has been followed in appointment of other judges also," the Bench said after noting that there has been no case where an additional judge had been made permanent in consultation with the apex court collegium.

5 injured as BUPC, CPI (M) activists clash

Nandigram: Five persons were injured on Monday as activists of the Bhumi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee (BUPC) and CPI(M) clashed here during a 24-hour bandh called by the BUPC to protest the attack on four of its members on Sunday. BUPC leader Sheikh Sufiyan told PTI that two of its members were injured in the clash at Chowringhee Bazar in Nandigram block I in the morning when they tried to enforce the bandh. Niranjan Sihi, CPI-M leader and East Midnapore Zilla Sabhadipati, said two members of his party were also injured. Another CPI(M) supporter was injured in separate clash at Satengabari, he said. The bandh was complete in both blocks of Nandigram with traffic off the roads. Several shops, which had opened in the morning, downed their shutters after the clashes. (PTI)

Markets, business establishments, schools and colleges remained closed.

Police and the CRPF, deployed in the area after the November violence, were on patrol in the villages.

Four supporters of Trinamool Congress-led BUPC were shot at allegedly by CPI(M) cadres at Keyakhali on Sunday, after three months of calm in the area. The incident happened two days ahead of the visit of West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadev Bhattacharjee to the area.

One of them, who was shot in the abdomen and chest, is being treated at the government-run SSKM Hospital in Kolkata.

‘Bring fine arts to front pages of newspapers’

Chennai: Ridiculing the importance accorded to page-three items in newspapers, a galaxy of celebrated musicians have appealed to the print medium to bring fine arts to the front page.

"Bring the news of fine arts and artistes to the front page and take unpleasant things to the subsequent pages. We don't want to read unpleasant things in the morning," remarked eminent carnatic singer M Balamurali Krishna at a joint press conference on Monday here, addressed by the who's who of the Indian music world.

The musicians, representing both Hindustani and carnatic music styles, have come together under the umbrella of the All India Musicians Group (AIMG) to preserve the art and support up-and-coming artistes and indigent musicians.

"I think the front page is reserved only for cricket," commented renowned tabla player Zakir Hussain.

Coming down heavily on the page-three culture, he said "nowadays people first look only at page three where they get to read about persons whom they don't know. But those persons were in the news just because they went to a party."

Stressing on the importance of media's role in taking any art form to the masses, the musicians appealed to the newspapers to give more space for arts.

The AIMG, formed two years ago, held its third meeting here to "take stock of the current scenario in the music world and to identify issues which are prejudicial to its moving in the right direction."

Eminent classical vocalists Ajoy Chakrabarty, Rajan Mishra, Sajan Mishra, santoor player Shivkumar Sharma, sitarist Arvind Parikh, carnatic singer Sudha Raghunathan and Mandolin artiste U Shrinivas were also present. The musicians noted that the wave of globalisation that was sweeping across the world had moved the Indian music to the masses -- away from the patronage of the elite.

Expressing concern over the "meagre" financial and related support extended by the Governments both at the Central and state levels to the cause of music, the musicians said Prasar Bharathi had increased the allocation for culture from Rs 33 crore to Rs 49 crore, consequent to their meeting with officials concerned.

Stating that there could be around 25,000 artistes, including those who were not graded, in the country, Parikh said slots had been obtained from All India Radio in cities like Mumbai, Chennai and Kolkata for up-and-coming artistes with the sponsorship of corporate houses.

"Our most important agenda will be to collect money from corporate houses and promote young talents," he said.

He said the AIMG had also held talks with insurance companies like Oriental and New India Insurance to evolve special policies for aged and indigent musicians at a subsidised premium.

The musicians also stressed the need for music education in schools and colleges in order to create a next generation of musicians as well as audience.

"In a nutshell, our appeal is to adopt an artiste and nurture her/his career. In this world of globalisation, let the roots of our culture remain strong and intact," Zakir said. (PTI)

Hindi, Chinese may dethrone Queen’s English

Mumbai: Hindi and Chinese, languages spoken in the emerging markets of the world, may dethrone Queen's English from the coveted status of "preferred lingua franca", believes an American expert.

US economist David Rosen said the official languages of the two emerging markets, India and China, will soon be the most preferred language in the workplace in coming times.

Rosen, who is a China expert, is adjunct professor in the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia University. He was in Mumbai to deliver a lecture to a group of industry captains on "China's Macro Re-directions and Implications for India".

"Current economic trends predict that the markets of English speaking nations are on the downslide and they are witnessing a hiatus in the growth sector," Rosen told IANS in an interview.

"In all likelihood, functional knowledge of the Hindi and Chinese language may dominate the world market scene, as the English language speaking market, it seems, is fast becoming obsolete," he said.

Hindi and Chinese are said to be 400 and 4,000 years old respectively.

In the same breath, Rosen, however, projected an optimistic future for English language, stating that it would be erroneous to jump the gun and "prognosticate the demise of the First World".

"They (First World) will not disappear. It will not be easy to bring down the existing economic giants. After all, when you look at the present economic trends, if China is the 'factory of the world' and 'India the office of the world', then USA is the knowledge book of the world," he said.

Refusing to get drawn into the controversial issue of economic recession in the US economy, Rosen said: "I am not an investment banker so I cannot talk about an actual scene but going by the trends, it seems that NPA (non-performing assets) of banks is going to worsen and deteriorate further in coming days as investments will go down further."

Rosen said Indian economic planners should focus on the modernisation of agrarian sector. "They should bring about changes in approach policies whereby they can wrench themselves free from the economic structure of the past," he said. (IANS)


               

High turnout of voters may upset calculations
75 to 80 pc polling recorded; Cong supporter beaten to death in Garo Hills

Our Bureau

SHILLONG/TURA/JOWAI: Fate of 331 candidates was sealed in the electronic voting machines with people turning out in huge numbers for polling for the eighth Meghalaya Legislative Assembly elections that passed off peacefully except killing of a Congress supporter in Garo Hills on Monday.

The voter turnout, 75 to 80 per cent, was easily the highest so far in the election history of this hill State. However, exact figure of turnout was not available as reports from remote constituencies of the State were pouring in, Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) P Naik said.

According to observers, the high turnout of voters might upset many a calculation. Probably quite a few surprises may occur in this election, they said.

People were seen in long queues since early morning as the voting started at 7 a.m. in 1,582 polling stations across the State.

Due to the huge turnout, voting hours had to be extended beyond the stipulated 4 p.m. in many polling stations in Shillong and other places of the State. Voters, mainly women, were seen waiting for their turn till 8 p.m. in many polling booths.

Though in some polling booths of Shillong, voting was slow in the morning hours, it gathered momentum as the day progressed. However, a smart shower of rain during the day put a dampener to the voting process in most parts of the city.

Voting had to be stopped for some time at Dulong polling station in Jowai constituency due to a fault in the EVM. Voting started after the EVM was replaced within a few minutes.

According to the CEO, the polling passed off peacefully without any untoward incident across the State. There was no incident of booth capturing in this election, he said.

"Introduction of Electoral Photo Identity Card (EPIC) has certainly helped checking cases of proxy voting," Mr Naik said.

As per initial reports, West Khasi Hills recorded an overall percentage of polling between 80 and 85 per cent while in Ri-Bhoi district the figure stands between 75 and 80 per cent. In East Khasi Hills, the turnout was between 80 and 85 per cent.

According to Jaintia Hills Returning Officer FR Kharkongor, overall percentage of turnout in the district was above 80. However there is possibility of the turnout exceeding 90 per cent, he said.

Congress supporter Dinang R Marak of Patranggre village, under Selsella constituency in Garo Hills, was beaten to death during the early hours of Monday morning. The Congress has accused the NCP of being involved in that incident and names of three persons suspected to be involved have been given to the police.

Poll related violence was received from Rangsakona area and Selsella on the eve of polls as group clashes between suspected supporters of both the NCP and the Congress were reported.

Meanwhile, a polling agent of UDP was beaten up by a group of Congress supporters at Wahiajer in Jaintia Hills.

On Sunday night, NCP candidate from Rymbai constituency Simon Siangshai was detained by the Dorbar Shnong of Deinchynrum for allegedly distributing money among the voters. He was later released after paying a fine of Rs 10,000 to the Dorbar Shnong.

Earlier on Saturday night, group clashes between NCP and Congress occurred in Matlagre, Churu Budugre and Kentapara, all in Rangsakona constituency. A wooden bridge connecting Okkapara to Dengnakpara was set on fire by unidentified persons but damage was partial.

Case against Cong workers

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Police have registered a case against some Congress workers, who were involved in the assault of UDP supporters at Umran Diary in Ri-Bhoi district on Sunday. SP of Ri-Bhoi, MK Dkhar, on Monday said action would be taken against the guilty Congress workers after the election.

The Congress workers allegedly assaulted 13 supporters of UDP who were returning from Umtasor village after distributing slips of electoral rolls among the villagers. The two vehicles used by the UDP supporters were also damaged in the incident.

Cong, NCP, UDP hopeful of ‘clear mandate’

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Though the fate of various political parties and candidates will be known only on March 7 when the votes locked in EVMs will be counted, guessing games over numbers of seats have already started among the political circles.

After Monday's polling, all the three major parties of the State - Congress, NCP and UDP - have expressed their hope to emerge as the single largest party on March 7.

While Congress claimed that it would have a clear mandate by winning at least 32 seats, the NCP quoted a modest figure of 26.

UDP, on the other hand, went on to claim at least 30 seats to get an "absolute majority".

Speaking to The Shillong Times on Monday, NCP general secretary PA Sangma said, 

"We hope to bag at least 26 seats out of which at least 18 will come from Garo Hills and eight from Khasi and Jaintia Hills."

Reiterating his claim of "clear majority", MPCC president OL Nongtdu said the party would emerge winner in at least 32 seats.

The party is expecting 12 seats from Garo Hills and 20 from Khasi and Jaintia Hills, he said.

Supporting his party's claim for 30 seats UDP vice president SD Khongwir said, "We will win 10 seats in East Khasi Hills, four in West Khasi Hills and six each in Jaintia and Garo Hills. Besides, our party will sweep Ri-Bhoi district by winning all the four seats."

Festive mood in polling stations

SHILLONG: A festive mood prevailed across Meghalaya as people thronged polling stations on Monday to decide the fate of 331 candidates aspiring to be representatives of the 60-member State Assembly.

In almost all the polling stations, voters were queuing up, while workers of rival political parties were making the last ditch to pacify electorate to vote for their respective candidates. Even though the Election Commission (EC) had imposed strict restrictions on canvassing by political parties after campaigning ended on March 1, the posters and banners reflected the spirit of the day.

Flags and banners of the major contenders -- ruling Congress and its allies and Opposition NCP and BJP -- were erected 200 metres away from polling stations to assist the voters find their names and the polling stations marked for them.

In all the polling stations, electronic voting machines (EVMs) had Braille-coded push buttons this time for the physically challenged. Special ramps were also erected for the disabled in all the polling booths.

In the early hours of voting, turnout was very low and those who turned up were mostly early risers and daily wage labourers. ''I cast my vote in the early hours as I have to rush to work,'' said Gurung of Pynthorumkhrah Assembly constituency.

Some candidates were also reported to have arranged vehicles to ferry old people to exercise their franchise.

At Shillong Law College and St Anthony's School, some voters expressed discontentment with the presiding officers for not allowing them to cast their ballot for failing to get a slip from polling agents of political parties outside the polling stations, despite possessing an Elector's Photo Identity Card.

However, Chief Electoral Officer P Naik later instructed all presiding officers to allow all genuine voters to exercise their franchise.

''It's not mandatory to get slips from polling agents of political parties to cast the ballot, if a voter possesses an EPIC,'' Mr Naik said.

However, from early morning, polling began in a relaxed atmosphere with voters and candidates interacting and congratulating each other for participating in it.

Mostly women voters were seen making serpentine queues in Laitumkhrah and Laban Assembly constituencies in the city. There are only 19 women candidates in the fray this time while of the 12,32,908 total voters, 6, 26,711 are females.

During noon, serpentine queues were witnessed outside the polling booths as voters were exercising their franchise.

In almost all the constituencies, the atmosphere was cheerful with supporters of rival political parties thronging the streets on motorcycles and other vehicles making efforts to ensure their candidate's victory. 

''It's our turn now to lead the state for overall progress and development,'' NCP worker Sengnam Marak said. However, a supporter of an Independent candidate said the low turnout indicated another fractured mandate in the State.

''No party will get an absolute majority and the party with highest number of seats will definitely need help of Independents to lead the State,'' said Ivan Lyngdoh. (UNI)

Congress-NCP post-poll alliance possible: Lapang

NONGPOH: Meghalaya Chief Minister D D Lapang has hinted at a possible Congress-NCP post-poll alliance in the state, saying his party was not averse to a tie-up with the Sharad Pawar-party and "anything is possible after the elections".

"In politics, there is no permanent friend or enemy. NCP is our partner at the Centre. So anything is possible," Mr Lapang told reporters after casting his vote at the Presbyterian School here.

When reminded of the pre-poll bitterness between the two parties, Mr Lapang said, "it is just political opposition. The Congress is not averse to a tie-up with the NCP. Alliance is a normal principle in contemporary politics."

Lapang's remarks have given credence to speculation about a possible Congress-NCP alliance government after the assembly elections as opinion polls had suggested that no party was likely to get a clear majority.

He, however, was quick to add that Congress was expecting 30-plus seats in the 60-member House and therefore no tie-up with any party was required.

On the possibility of a post-poll alliance with NCP, MPCC chief Mr OL Nongtdu said the question of any such poll pact does not arise at the moment as the party is hoping for an absolute majority.

NCP, led by former Lok Sabha Speaker Mr PA Sangma in the State, is fast emerging as a major player along with the Congress and UDP the House.

Mr Lapang is locked in a tough contest with Dr R B Lyngoh of UDP but oozed confidence saying he would sail through. (Agencies)


Budget 2008-09

No budget is considered entirely satisfactory—only once in a while you get a dream budget. This year’s budget is said to have been prepared to cater to the vote bank in view of the coming election. But most people may say sufficient unto the year the joy thereof. The budget was presented against the backdrop of a strong domestic economy facing adverse external forces. Finance Minister P.Chidambaram has shown evidence of excellent fiscal management. The ratios of the Central government’s revenues and fiscal deficits are relatively low. It is due to a remarkable growth in tax revenues exceeding targets. The result has been a boost to inclusive growth. Allocations for education have been increased by 20 pc. Health sector investment with the stress on the rural areas has gone up by 13 pc. Infrastructure outlay, especially for rural infrastructure has also shot up. Personal income tax has been lowered at all levels. The corporate tax, however, remains unchanged and so has peak customs duty. But the Cenvat has been reduced from 16 to 12 pc. Excise duty has also been cut in sectors like automobiles and pharmaceuticals. Some new services will have to pay service tax. It is welcome since the services sector contributes an increasing share of GDP. The corporate sector may complain that the budget should have provided more incentives to sustained growth. One criticism may be that public investment in infrastructure should have been greater. Capital gains tax will continue to be a damper for the bourses. But the Bank Transaction tax has been scrapped.

The major feature of this year’s budget is the stress on the farming sector, which has never had it so good. Farmers constitute 70 pc of the population and the bonanza for them certainly has the shadow of the hustings behind it. The decision to waive Rs. 60,000 crore worth of loan of small and marginal farmers will bring cheer to them. But in the long run, it will be counter-productive as banks will be reluctant to grant soft loans to them in future. Indirect taxes are not likely to trigger inflation. Commodities like cars, two-wheelers, refrigerators and washing machines will be cheaper. Cigarettes (non-filter) will go up a lot but that is for health reasons. What may invite criticism is the rise in the price of mobile handsets and packaged software, key elements of technical growth. Infotech, on the whole, has received only a mixed bag.

The allocation for the Northeast has been raised from Rs. 14,000 crore to Rs. 16,000 crore, with the stress on Arunachal Pradesh. The hike is not considerable and is skewed. But Asom and Meghalaya will welcome an outlay of Rs. 40 crore for tea meant for rejuvenation of tea bushes and crop replantation. It will help save sick tea gardens, which have been hitting the Northeastern economy.



A feel-good Budget

By Poonam I Kaushish

It was a perfect electoral cake. Rolled out by Finance Minister Chidambaram to the strains of ‘Vote Congress.’ Iced with luscious lip-smacking freebies galore for one and all. From the aam aadmi to the debt-ridden kisan to the top tax payer. A feel-good budget that has bitten the ballot. To cream the electorate at the hustings!

Indeed, his 2008-09 ‘please-one-and-all’ budget has much to crow about. It has injected a much-needed dose to the suicide-prone farmers wherein debts worth Rs 60,000 crore have been promised to be waived off, it offers substantial tax relief to the middle class, welfare lollipops for workers in the unorganized sector, increased subsidies for houses under the Indira Awaz Yojana, special measures for Scs/STs, new deal for senior citizens and women et al.

However, the budget has a dangerous sub-text which has been lost in the euphoria of the goodies. The slew of schemes for the minorities is a pointer that minorityism has replaced cronyism as the tour de force of the budget. Take a 360 degree turn anywhere and minority appeasement hits you in the face. All in the garb of improving their quality of life (sic) which translates into "please give me your vote." Never mind that it holds out dangerous portends for India’s unity and national security.

How else should one react to the Finance Minister’s latest bonanza for the minorities. Starting with the piece de resistance, a multi-sectoral development plan for 90 minority districts at a cost of Rs.3,780 crore, Rs 80-crore earmarked for a pre-matric scholarships and over Rs 45 crore for modernizing madrassa education. The corpus for the Maulana Azad Education Foundation has been hiked by Rs.60 crore and 544 new bank branches (256 this year and 288 next year) will be opened in the minority districts to facilitate bank credit for them and Rs.75 crore more for the National Minorities Development and Finance Corporation..

Statistically speaking none can deny that a large section of the Muslims need a better quality of life. Data collated by various commissions bring out the fact that socio-economic indicators for Muslims were below those for OBCs in many cases. About 59 per cent were illiterate, only 10 per cent went to school and a mere eight per cent opted for higher education. Worse, even as they were vastly under-represented in official jobs, they were grossly over-represented in India's prison population. None can also deny that the Government has a special responsibility to provide job opportunities, education and upliftment of the minorities and the backward classes.

No doubt, the Grand Dame of Indian politics perceives its Finance Minister’s lollipops as it’s cash card to regain its long-lost glory. But the crucial question is: Does poverty have any religion? What has religion got to do with the Government’s strategy for inclusive growth? Does ‘inclusiveness of Muslims’ mean at the cost of other groups? Is it in the interest of maintaining the social fabric of the nation? Will it help the cause of taking the Indian people together on the path of development?"

More. How does it better the lot of the mass of Muslims, if a few persons get jobs? When does minorityism supercede equality assured by our Constitution? Are quotas based on religion and community, the answer for maintaining India’s social fabric? And more important, it’s crucial harmony? Is the Muslim identity distinct from that of the Indian?

Given the level of dishonesty, populism and irresponsibility which increasingly governs our political system, these exclusive measures announced are an invitation to disaster. Clearly, the move is fraught with dangerous implications for the unity of the country. Tragically, so blinded are our politicians in their quest for power that none can see the Frankenstein they recklessly continue to create. By giving legitimacy to a communal quota, religious bigotry at its most ferocious could end up in carving once more a blood-stained path across our country. Clearly, this could sow the poisonous seeds for a new communal movement and separate electorates inspired by the two-nation theory that tragically led to India’s partition.

Importantly, if reservation based on castes is bad, budgeting on communal basis is horrendous. Ominous reasoning is being appendaged. It would bring the Muslims into the mainstream. Ensure harmony between the majority and the minority communities. It would prevent Muslims from being exploited any more as vote-banks by the so-called secular parties.

Recall, Nehru increasingly bent over-backwards to woo the Muslim vote, which constituted 12 to 15 per cent of the total Congress vote, the largest single block it received in the first few general elections. Thus, Muslim appeasement was no longer viewed as luxury but as a matter of life and death. To be manipulated and held hostage as was done by the British colonial masters to block freedom.

Once economically pampered, the next demand would be that the Muslims alone should decide who would represent them. Bluntly, leading to a most dangerous and blood-thirsty monster of separate Muslim electorate. Clearly, this could sow the seeds for a new communal movement inspired by the disastrous two-nation theory that led to India’s partition and the creation of Pakistan, thanks to the diabolical communal award by the British Raj which provided for the Hindus to vote for the Hindus and the Muslims for the Muslims.

So caught up are all in their blandishments for the increasing Muslim vote-bank (36.76 per cent growth during 1991-2001) to suit their petty parochial ends that they fail to see the Frankenstein they could mindlessly unleashed --- a Frankenstein that encourages the Muslim leadership to go communal and dictate its national agenda. Already a seven-Party Muslim Front has been formed to fight the electoral sweepstakes on its own.

Importantly, there is no place for double standards or the Orwellian concept of ‘more equal than others’ in a democracy. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander. The Fundamental Rights provide for equal opportunities for all irrespective of caste, creed or sex. Let’s not fudge or forget this. India of 2008 is not the India of pre-1947.

Clearly, the Government has to end this evil of separatism. Separate budget for minorities is no answer for fulfilling the peoples’ aspirations. It will not only further divide our people on creed-caste lines but is also short-sighted and antithetical to any hope of narrowing India's burgeoning divide between the haves and have-nots. The Government has no right to limit opportunities for the deserving or to shrink the public space for autonomy and free association.

In the ultimate, our petty power-at all-cost polity has to think beyond vote-bank politics and look at the perilous implications of these decisions. What exactly is the message the Government proposes to send across the country by its budgeting policy? Does it want to be the first to sow the seeds of another partition? It is willy-nilly encouraging the Muslim leadership to go communal and resurrect the Muslim League. Which could in turn result in reservation for Muslims in Parliament and State Assemblies and even separate electorate a la the British Raj?

If not stopped here and now, these actions could threaten a blood-stained path across our country. Let us not ignore the grim lessons of history. Or, we shall end up condemning ourselves and the country to repeating history. Where a nation can be plunged into communal anarchy once again. How long will we allow this vote-bank politics to continue recklessly and play havoc with India’s unity and integrity? The buck stops at the Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s door. ----INFA

Clearly, this could sow the seeds for a new communal movement inspired by the disastrous two-nation theory that led to India’s partition and the creation of Pakistan, thanks to the diabolical communal award by the British Raj which provided for the Hindus to vote for the Hindus and the Muslims for the Muslims. So caught up are all in their blandishments for the increasing Muslim vote-bank (36.76 per cent growth during 1991-2001) to suit their petty parochial ends that they fail to see the Frankenstein they could mindlessly unleashed --- a Frankenstein that encourages the Muslim leadership to go communal and dictate its national agenda. Already a seven-Party Muslim Front has been formed to fight the electoral sweepstakes on its own. Importantly, there is no place for double standards or the Orwellian concept of ‘more equal than others’ in a democracy. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

IPL: Cricket for whom?

Sir,

The Indian Premier League (IPL) Twenty20 tournament will revolutionise cricket in the same way World Series cricket did in 70s. This is going to be a landmark event in the history of cricket. The World Series cricket of 70s, the brainchild of television mogul Kerry Packer, introduced day-night one-day internationals, coloured clothing and white balls.

Cricket is not going to change, but the unfortunate side is that cricketers have become commodities ... just commodities. Open display of wealth does not augur well for the Indian cricket where players are being auctioned for money. How can you generate city loyalty in a sport so focused on national identity?

In the name of improving the cricket the BCCI is spoiling the game by paying so high amount to those players who are already rich. I think fans should not encourage this type of money game. Shahrukh Khan has said that in future they are going to improve other sports. But the question is why not now? Instead of paying so much money to all the 'rich' cricketers, they should start offering helping hand to other sports. We do not know how many crores will go in BCCI officials' pocket. I for one cannot watch players playing for clubs. How can you generate loyalty to the teams owned by the likes of Priety Zinta etc.

Yours etc.,
Mominul Haque
Shillong-4.
Via e-mail

Impractical proposal

Sir,

A proposal to bring out stamps of Sachin Tendulkar, Sania Mirza and Shahrukh Khan was mooted by Shakeel Ahmed, MoS for Telecommunications. The Minister seems to be totally unaware of the policy of the International Postal Union. I am afraid that it has become necessary for a nonentity like me to point out to him that pictures of living persons cannot be on postal stamps.

Needless to say that it took several years after the death of a saintly woman like Mother Theresa (known to the world as a walking saint) to be ordained a saint. When an Indian dacoit can become a sadhu in one's lifetime, so can a youth icon achieve notoriety in no time. That being the case, the question simply does not arise of bringing out stamps of youths who have yet to achieve a lot in life and who might fall from grace anytime as has happened with many an icon. I have no desire to question the motive of Minister, but I strongly oppose the weird proposal that he made without any application of mind.

Yours etc.,
Omar Luther King
Delhi-34
Via e-mail


 Night curfew in Dimapur, Mon
CEC declares all booths sensitive in Nagaland

Kohima: Nagaland Chief Electoral Officer CJ Ponraj on Monday said all the 1,780 polling stations of the State have been identified as sensitive and 740 as hyper sensitive.

Addressing mediapersons on evening, Mr Ponraj said the concept of 'sensitive and hypersensitive' does not work in Nagaland like other parts of the country, and hence additional forces are being brought to assist the authorities in conducting a free and fair elections on March 5.

Answering to a query, Ponraj informed that Ghaspani-I has the highest number of 58,780 voters, while Mokokchung town Assembly constituency has the least number with 6,144 electorate.

Kingpao Polling station under Noklak Assembly constituency in Tuensang district has only nine voters, while Singrijan Polling Station under Dimapur-III Assembly constituency in Dimapur district has the highest number of voters with 2,142.

There are 142 polling stations in the State, which has less than 200 electorate.

He said according to latest figures, the total number of voters was 13,00,507, with 6,64,604 males and 6,35,903 female voters.

The CEO said 17 Assembly Constituencies will witness direct fights and the highest number of candidates are in Thonoknyu Assemby Constituency under Tuensang district with nine candidates, followed by Bhandari and Tyui Assembly constituencies with eight candidates each.

More than 2000 Electronic Voting Machines will be used during the March five elections and 1,780 EVMs will be used in 1,780 polling stations and rest will be kept as reserved to replace any defect machine, he added.

Meanwhile, prohibitory orders under Section 144 CrPC have been promulgated in some parts of Dimapur and Mon towns to maintain peace and tranquility following poll-related violence in those areas since Sunday evening.

Campaigning ends

The month-long campaign for the sixty-member Nagaland Assembly, which goes to polls on March five, ended at 4 pm on Monday.

A total of 12,99,888 electorate--6,64,984 males and 6,35,904 females, will decide the fate of 218 candidates, including four women. In the arena are twelve political parties and Independents.

Among prominent candidates are Mr Neiphiu Rio(NPF) from Northern Angami-II in Kohima district. He headed the Democratic Alliance of Nagaland government before President's rule was imposed in the state on January three.

Others are former Chief Minister KL Chishi from Dimapur-I, sitting Rajya Sabha Member from Nagaland TR Zeliang (NPF) from Peren, former DAN minister Dr TM Lotha (BJP), former Rajya Sabha Member Apok C Jamir (Cong), who is the son of Goa Governor and former Chief Minister SC Jamir. Former Speaker Kiyanilie Peseyie (NPF) is contesting from Western Angami constituency and former deputy Speaker EE Pangteang is contesting on an NPF ticket from Moka.

Campaigning in this hilly tribal Northeastern state was different from elsewhere in the country as the voting is decided by the clan, tribe or area-wise, for which electioneering by top leaders from outside the State has little impact on the voters. (UNI)

Misdistribution of postal ballots alleged

Agartala: The Opposition Congress in Tripura has accused the State poll panel of misdistributing postal ballots in the just concluded Assembly elections and demanded an inquiry into the entire procedure.

Tripura Pradesh Congress Committee (TPCC) president and former Chief Minister Samir Ranjan Barman alleged that the authorities had issued postal ballots for the employees who were not involved in the election process and other sections of civil society.

''A large number of such cases were reported from different constituencies in West Tripura and Dhalai districts where the prospects of the Left Front candidates are bleak,'' Mr Barman claimed, adding that a section of election officials had been used by the ruling party to ensure their victory in the polls.

He also expressed dissatisfaction over the announcement of the Election Commission of India (ECI) that the postal ballots would be accepted till the commencement of counting on March 7.

Meanwhile, Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) Dr GSG Ayyangar said the ECI had received complaints from the Opposition parties on the alleged bungling in distribution and receipt of postal ballots in various parts of the State and assured that the Commission would look into all aspects related to the Assembly elections, adding that Observers had been camping in the state to oversee the whole election process. (UNI)

Assam Budget session starts on stormy note

Guwahati: The Budget session of the Assam Assembly began on Monday on a stormy note, with the Opposition forcing Governor Lt Gen (retd) Ajai Singh to conclude his speech within five minutes.

As the Governor started reading out his speech, the Opposition members got on their feet and created a ruckus, disrupting the Governor. The speech was taken as read.

The members, led by Leader of Opposition Chandra Mohan Patowary, demanded that the Governor's speech should voice his own opinion, alleging that the latter was ''parroting'' the words of the Government.

They pointed out that the Government and the Governor were in disagreement over various issues and both sides had been vocal in criticism of the other.

The Opposition also displayed placards, demanding dismissal of the Government for alleged failure to control law and order situation and stormed the well of the House.

Governor Lt Gen (retd) Singh was forced to conclude the speech within five minutes, with the House accepting it as read.

The Governor, in his speech, highlighted the financial revival of the state and the return of peace in the insurgency-infested state.

''From a State passing through severe financial crisis a few years back, Assam today is a financially stable and strong one. This is reflected in the fact that there has been no overdraft even for a single day after April 2005,'' he said.

The State's annual plan size has had a substantial jump from Rs 3,800 crore for 2007-08 to Rs 5,011 crore in 2008-09, which included Rs 1,431.21 crore as the State's contribution, he added.

He said several private parties had evinced interest in investing in the State, boosted by the Government's pro-active role and improving law and order situation.

The Governor maintained that the internal security scenario had improved in the state, although some incidents of violence were perpetrated by outfits like ULFA, KLNLF, DHD and AANLA. (UNI)

Dogs to keep vigil along border with Bangladesh

Agartala: India's Border Security Force (BSF) troopers will soon use trained dogs to check infiltration and smuggling along Tripura's border with Bangladesh.

"We shall engage trained dogs for guarding the international border and check trans-border crimes," said UK Bansal, additional director general (ADG) of BSF.

"The efficiency ratio of dogs, equipment and man is 60:40:20 respectively."

The BSF dog training centre in Tekenpur in Madhya Pradesh has been providing eight types of training to sniper and tracker dogs.

"Recently, while patrolling the border areas of Assam along with a sniper dog, the jawans recovered a bag containing huge quantities of RDX," Bansal told IANS.

He said that it was decided to deploy at least four sniper or tracker dogs in each battalion of BSF posted along the international border in Tripura.

Bansal, who is looking after five frontiers along the India-Bangladesh border, said the BSF had also acquired six helicopters to step up vigil along the border in this region.

Pointing out that Harkat-ul-Jehad-e-Islami (HuJi) and other fundamentalist elements had spread their net in the bordering states of India, including the North East and West Bengal, he said the BSF was procuring modern electronic gadgets like thermal and satellite imageries, different types of radars and night vision devices.

"Cross-border crime and the movements of anti-India forces, including separatists, through the India-Bangladesh border have reduced substantially while socio-economic development projects of the bordering communities have been initiated as part of the border management programme," Bansal added.

According to the BSF official, the entire stretch of the 856-km India-Bangladesh border in Tripura would be fenced. Work in some 641 km had already been completed.

Bansal said 84 companies of border guards were being deployed in Meghalaya and Nagaland to help the Election Commission conduct Assembly elections in the two northeastern states.

"I don't agree with some of the experts that the BSF should not be deployed for internal security like in elections as the force is capable of tackling any kind of eventuality and problems," Bansal said. (IANS)



National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |

 

                                               

Make This Your HomePage! | About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery

Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.