News  of 13th February 2008

National | Shillong | Interntional | Editorial | Regional | Sports 

India, Russia agree to double trade in three years

NEW DELHI: India and Russia on Tuesday agreed to more than double their trade to 10 billion dollars by 2010, for which the two countries will consider opening markets by a Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement.

"If we grow by 30 per cent per year, we might achieve the trade figure of 10 billion dollars by 2010," Russian Prime Minister Victor A Zubkov said at the meeting of the India-Russia Forum on Trade and Investment (IRFTI) in New Delhi.

Earlier in the day, Zubkov discussed with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh the potential to double bilateral trade within the next three years by enhancing cooperation in areas of oil, gas, mining, technology, transport and energy.

Zubkov addressed the forum meeting organised jointly by industry bodies FICCI and CII. (PTI)

Maharashtra jittery over Raj ’s likely arrest

Mumbai/New Delhi: Entire Maharashtra remained on tenterhooks throughout on Tuesday over the probable arrest of MNS chief Raj Thackeray, with security forces on a high alert amid sporadic violence in parts of the state.

State Director General of Police (DGP) P.S. Pasricha said investigations in the case against Raj Thackeray, Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray's estranged nephew, were "still continuing."

He was referring to the suo moto case filed by the Mumbai police against Raj Thackeray for promoting enmity between two ethnic groups by using invectives and provocative language against north Indians. A similar case was also filed against Samajwadi Party state chief Abu Asim Azmi.

Pasricha reiterated the government's stand that it was the "duty of the police to safeguard and protect the north Indians". (IANS) 

Ban on poultry

Kolkata: With the situation in birdflu-hit districts of West Bengal improving, the state government has decided to withdraw the ban on sale and transport of poultry and poultry products from tomorrow even as fresh deaths of chicken was reported from Jalpaiguri district.

It was decided to lift the ban, imposed on February 5, from Wednesday after a high-level meeting, Animal Husbandry minister Anisur Rahaman told reporters on Tuesday. (PTI)

Violence by MNS supporters spreads
Anti-north campaign

Mumbai: The Maharashtra Government on Tuesday appeared edgy in arresting Raj Thackeray as violence spread beyond Mumbai to more cities including Pune and Nashik with his supporters intimidating North Indian migrants and stoning public transport buses.

As tension gripped the State, a day after a FIR was filed against the Leader of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena(MNS), the Centre took no chances and was rushing more paramilitary forces to the country's commercial capital.

Director General of Police PS Pasricha said incidents of stone pelting were reported from Aurangabad, Latur, Jalna, Beed,Nashik and Pune but described them as ordinary in nature.

Police had registered cases against both Raj and Samajwadi Party leader Abu Asim Azmi for "inciting" people and "promoting" enmity between groups. Yesterday, a top police official said that once the FIRs have been registered the arrest will have to be carried out some time or other.

In Mumbai, several shops downed shutters in Lower Parel, Worli, Ghatkopar, Vikhroli and Bhandup areas, anticipating trouble in the event of Raj's arrest.

In Nashik, where MNS has some presence,there were reports that some north Indian migrants had left the town by trains after attacks on fruit vendors and stone pelting of buses.

"We have made 82 preventive arrests, most of them are activists of Maharashtra Navnirman Sena," Police Commissioner, S M Sayyad said. He said the situation was now peaceful and under control.

In Mumbai, there was a strong police presence around the Dadar residence of Raj whose spokesman Shishir Shinde told PTI that there was no question of the MNS leader seeking anticipatory bail. Azmi presented himself before the police for them to arrest him but they declined for the moment.

On the issue of arresting the two leaders, DGP Pasricha said, "We cannot work with a foregone conclusion or with prejudice. I can assure that the cases will reach their logical end in a matter of days, not months."

Police said 16 cases were registered across the state (excluding Mumbai) for the fresh violence in which 39 people were arrested.

An additional 143 were detained as a preventive measure, he said.

Tension prevailed in Pune following sporadic incidents of stone-pelting in some parts of the City. (PTI)

Cross donation of kidneys brings smiles to 2 families

Balasore: Two women in Orissa -- one Hindu and another Muslim -- have opted for cross-donation of kidneys to save the lives of each other's husbands, setting an example of communal amity.

The kidney transplant restored joy to two families by saving the lives of Harekrishna Bhanja (48), a lawyer from Soro near here, and Mohammed Sayed (50), a shopkeeper in Cuttack.

Bhanja was suffering from kidney failure for the past one year and was on dialysis.

He was helpless as doctors found that none of his close family members had the same blood group as his.

The surgeries were performed successfuly in the last week of January at the hospital and Bhanja was discharged from the ICUon Monday, Roy said.

When it became difficult for the patient to get a suitable kidney for his survival, Deepak Sankar Roy, chief nephrologist of Manjulaben Kidney Hospital here, came to his rescue.

Roy persuaded the two couples who were facing the same problem of kidney transplantation.

Sayed's wife Saira donated her kidney to Bhanja, whose wife Kalpana in turn donated her kidney to Sayed, Roy said.

The surgeries were performed successfuly in the last week of January at the hospital and Bhanja was discharged from the ICU Monday, Roy said.

While Bhanja would have to remain in hospital for a few more days, Sayed has already been discharged, hospital sources said adding the patients as well as donors were in good condition.

Roy, who hails from Bhadrak, said "it was due to the grace of the almighty that the lives of two persons could be saved as their problems could be addressed at the right time."

The blood groups of both the donors were found to be matching with the respective recipients, he said. (PTI)

India’s forest cover stable at 20.6 pc

New Delhi: India has not lost much of its forest cover since 2002. It stands at 20.6 percent of the country's total land area, the Forest Survey of India (FSI) said here on Tuesday.

Releasing the latest State of Forest Report (SFR), Director of FSI Devendra Pandey said only 0.11 percent reduction in forest cover has taken place since 2002, "which means India's forest cover has remained more or less stable".

The survey report is dated 2005, and covers changes in forest cover between 2002 and 2004.

The main losses to forest cover, according to Pandey, were due to the December 2004 tsunami that devastated large tracts of forests in the Andamans, and also due to submergence of forest areas when large dams were built in Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.

Pandey said that very dense forests cover 1.66 percent of India's geographical area, moderately dense forests cover 10.12 percent and open forests 8.82 percent.

Very dense forests have a canopy density of over 70 percent, moderately dense forests have 40-70 percent and open forests have less.

According to the 2005 report, Madhya Pradesh has the largest area under forest cover - 7.6 million hectares, which is 11.22 percent of the country's forest cover. Other states with large forest cover are Arunachal Pradesh (10.01 percent), Chhattisgarh (8.25 percent), Orissa (7.15 percent) and Maharashtra (7.01 percent).

The northeastern states have a quarter of the country's forests though they constitute less than seven percent of the country's geographical area, Pandey said.

The report points to one major area of concern - the government's own policy says the country's 124 hill districts should have at least two-thirds of their area under forest cover. However, only 38.85 percent of the area of these districts is under forest cover. Even if one excludes areas at an altitude above 4,000 metres - where trees do not grow - the percentage goes up only to 52.4 percent.

The country's 188 districts with tribal majorities have done better, with 36.81 percent of their areas under forest cover. These districts account for around 60 percent of India's forests.

Pandey said India has 0.44 million hectares covered by mangroves, nearly half in the Sundarbans of West Bengal, followed by 21 percent in Gujarat and 14 percent in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.

He expressed concern that the next SFR would show a major decline in forest cover in the northeastern states due to the ongoing flowering of bamboo in parts of the region. Bamboo flowers once every 50 years, after which the existing plant dies.

The report shows that apart from forests, another 9.17 million hectares - 2.8 percent of India's total area - is under tree cover.

The total volume of wood in the country is estimated at 6.22 billion cubic metres, of which 4.6 billion cubic metres falls within the forests. (IANS)


               

Congress, UDP skip KSU-called all-party meeting
Uranium issue unites Opp, MDA allies

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: With barely three weeks left for the elections, Opposition parties and two allies of ruling MDA coalition have declared their opposition to uranium mining in the State.

While NCP, BJP and two regional parties in the ruling coalition -- HSPDP, MDP and KHNAM - voiced their concern over uranium mining in a KSU-called "all-party meeting" on the issue, Congress and its MDA ally -- UDP -- preferred to skip the meeting here on Tuesday.

Though UDP, in a letter, expressed its inability to attend the meeting due to "preoccupation in party activities", Congress did not respond to the KSU move at all.

Main objective of the student body to garner support from political parties in its effort to scrap the uranium mining project, seemed unfulfilled with the absence of representatives from Congress and UDP.

Meanwhile, representatives of political parties in the all-party meeting attributed consequences like health hazard, change of demography etc., as major reasons for their opposition to the proposed uranium mining project at Kylleng-Pyndengsohiong in West Khasi Hills district.

Speaking at the meeting, NCP State president Dr WR Kharlukhi said the party would go by the people's verdict. Since the people do not want the project in Meghalaya, the party is opposing it, he said.

BJP State general secretary Dr PM Passah advised KSU to take up the matter with international agencies to put pressure on the Central Government against uranium mining in Meghalaya.

Expressing their strong objection to uranium mining, KHNAM and HSPDP came down heavily on former KHADC chief HS Shylla for giving NOC to the Uranium Corporation of India Limited (UCIL) to go ahead with its project.

"Sixth Schedule of the Constitution has empowered the district council to look after the identity of indigenous people, and not to misuse the power to serve one's vested interest," KHNAM president Paul Lyngdoh, who also attended the meeting, said. Raising his party's objection to the project, HSPDP chief Hopingstone Lyngdoh described how uranium mining affected life and health of people in countries like in America, Russia, France and Germany.

Meanwhile, KSU has reiterated its decision to continue to fight by all means to prevent uranium mining in the State.

KSU president Samuel Jyrwa said the Union had been opposing the project since 1991 when officials of Department Atomic Energy went to Domiasiat in West Khasi Hills district to "forcibly mine uranium without consent from the local people".

Two more former CMs file papers

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Two former chief ministers -- JD Rymbai and EK Mawlong -- on Tuesday submitted their nomination papers from Jirang and Umroi Assembly constituencies respectively.

Mr Rymbai, a four-time MLA, had last month resigned from the primary membership of Congress in protest against denial of party ticket to him.

He will contest the forthcoming elections from UDP.

On Monday, another former chief minister SC Marak filed nomination.

Mr Rymbai has been representing Jirang constituency in Ri-Bhoi district ever since he joined politics in 1988.

This time, Congress has fielded William Mynsong, a member of the KHADC, in the constituency.

Mr Mawlong, who headed the only UDP-led alliance government in 2000-01, will contest from Umroi constituency.

Deputy Chief Minister in-charge of Power Dr Mukul Sangma also on Tuesday filed his nomination from Ampati constuituency.

29 in Garo Hills: A total of 29 candidates submitted their nomination papers in Garo Hills on the fourth day of nomination filing. In West Garo Hills district, 19 candidates filed their nominations, while in East Garo Hills, six candidates put forward their candidature.

South Garo Hills also opened their account with four candidates filing their nomination papers on Tuesday.

Besides Dr Mukul Sangma, other Congress candidates who filed nominations in the district on Tuesday were -- Abdus Saleh (Mahendraganj) and Semford B Sangma (Salmanpara). Independent candidate Grebith D Sangma also filed his papers from Salmanpara.

Others who filed their nominations from West Garo Hills district were -- Lemison Sangma (Ind) from Tikrikilla; Hapine M Marak (Ind) from Dadenggre; Rakkan M Sangma (Ind), Paul B Marak (Ind) and Septerwin R Sangma (Ind) all from Rongchugiri; Sisir Marak (Ind) and Ms Jahannara B Kharbhih (UDP) both from Rajabala; Henising A Sangma (GNC) and Sengman R Marak (Congress) both from Rongram; Kulert C Momin (Ind) from Tura; Enison M Marak (Ind) and Lindin Ch Momin (UDP) both from Kherapara; Sanjiv R Marak (Ind) and Saleng A Sangma (Congress) both from Dalamgre; and Adolf Lu Hitler R Marak (NCP) from Rangsakona. In East Garo Hills, Sanjay R Marak (UDP) filed from Songsak; Newton B Marak (UDP) from Rongrenggiri; Marthon Sangma (NCP) from Mendipather; Timothy D Shira (NCP) from Resubelpara and John Manner Marak (NCP) and Winsang Ch Sangma (Ind) both from Bajengdoba. In South Garo Hills, Sato R Marak (NCP) and Lazarus M Sangma (Ind) filed their nominations from Baghmara constituency. For Chokpot constituency, Mrs Sophie R Marak (Congress) and Masonsing Sangma (NCP) filed their papers. (With inputs from Our Tura Correspondent)

Junior Kyndiah plays safe, adds mom’s surname

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: After finding himself in troubled water over his Khasi status, Union Tribal Affairs Minister P R Kyndiah's son Waibha K Kyndiah on Tuesday filed his nomination paper adding, as an after thought, his mother's surname "Khyriem" in the middle.

Mr Kyndiah, who filed his candidature as "Waibha Khyriem Kyndiah" before Assistant Returning Officer V R Syiem from Nongkrem Assembly constituency, was into controversy for violating Sections 10 and 3 (1) of the Khasi Social Custom of Lineage Act, 1997.

Commenting on his decision to add his mother's surname in the middle, Mr Kyndiah told reporters that he did so hoping that everything would go smoothly.

Former KHADC chief HS Shylla, meanwhile, criticised Mr Kyndiah's stand saying "as per the Khasi matrilineal system we take only mother's surname not both".

It may be mentioned the KHADC Registration Authority had stripped off his ST status following a complaint by a local organisation "Ka Seng Tip Kur Tip Kha U Khasi".

In this regard, Deputy Commissioner's court is likely take a decision on February 22.

BJP cries foul over dual voters along Assam border

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Come elections and the issue of dual voters along the Assam--Meghalaya border rarely fails to escape any political party's attention. This time round the BJP has come out with a serious allegation against alleged attempts by "subversive elements," possibly backed by the Inter Service Intelligence (ISI) of Pakistan, to use dual voters to disturb the electoral processes in three northeastern states.

BJP's Zonal Organising Secretary in charge of North East P. Chandrashekhar, leveled these charges and said that some persons who are "registered as voters in Meghalaya have contested in the recently concluded Panchayat elections in Assam." The BJP leader displayed a poster of one Samsur Rahman Mullah Alias Mukut, and said the latter, who apparently is registered as a voter in Meghalaya had contested the Panchayat elections in Assam from Baladubi, in East Goalpara district.

"This person (Mukut) is a registered voter in Phulbari in West Garo Hills district," Mr. Chandrasehkar said displaying another document-electoral ID bearing the name and pictures of the accused.

While the poster shows the accused person contesting the recently concluded Panchayat election in Assam as an Independent from the Baladubi seat with a kettle as his symbol, the Electoral Roll of 48 Phulbari constituency shows that he is enrolled as a voter from Part No. 17, Section 2-Shyamding, District West Garo Hills, Pin-794104, Serial 1208. The ID card explicitly bears the name and photograph of Samsur Rahman who is the son of Mustafizur Mullah, resident of House No. 97.

"This seems to be the work of "subversive elements and fundamentalist organisations" who are striving to create a huge divide amongst the indigenous citizens on various lines. It is an alarming trend and if the Government of India does not check it, the future for the real citizens of the country is at stake," Mr Chandrasehkar said.

Flaunting the documents as an evidence of how "some vested interests," have are using Assam and Meghalaya to carry out its activities, Mr. Chandrashekhar said "this is just one case. Thousands of such cases would be detected if the Election Commission investigates thoroughly." "This is how they are infiltrating into the system using borders of two states to extend their activities," said Mr. Chandrashekhar. The BJP leader used the opportunity to take on other political parties. He said other parties were not interested in tackling the issue and were instead using these voters as vote banks. He said that the BJP would not take this lying down and would make all efforts to address the vital issue.

UDP candidate arrested

JOWAI/SHILLONG: Megha-laya police on Tuesday arrested UDP candidate Richard Sing Lyngdoh for "assaulting" and "intimidating" an electorate at Sutnga village in Jaintia Hills district.

Mr Lyngdoh, who is also the sitting member of JHADC, is contesting the March 3 Assembly polls from Sutnga-Shangpung constituency.

"We have arrested him (Mr Lyngdoh) on charges of criminal intimidation, assaulting and common intention," Jaintia Hills District SP MK Singh told UNI here.

On Monday, the police arrested Mr Lyndoh's brother Self Denial Lyngdoh on the same charges.

Election officials here said on February 9, Mr Lyngdoh along with his brother allegedly forced voters of Sutnga village to cast votes in his favour.

However, when one of the villagers - Jesban Chyrmang - questioned his right to vote, the candidate accompanied by his brother allegedly thrashed him severely. Mr Chyrmang later filed an FIR against the duo and later another FIR jointly signed by 71 people.

Meanwhile, the police have booked both the brothers under Section 325, 506 and 34 IPC.

Show-cause notice

Meanwhile, the Election Department on Tuesday issued show-cause notices to two teachers and an official with the Sub-Divisional Office, (SDO), Nongstoin for failing to turn up for the training of Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) and other general procedures of election.

The show-cause notices were issued to one Sainbor Blien, working under office of the SDO, Nongstoin, Assistant teacher Bronson Sangma of Sibsing Memorial Government Higher Secondary School and Hindi teacher GN Prasad of Mawlieh Government Upper Primary School.

In separate show cause notices issued to them, the West Khasi Hills District election officer said that as the trio did not attend the training on general procedures, legal aspect and also on the ways and means to handle the EVMs on January 23, the negligence tantamounts to breach of election duty which is punishable under Section 136 of the Representation of People's Act.

Meanwhile, the trio were asked to reply within three days of receiving the show casue as to why action should not be taken against them. (UNI)

Khonglam in MLA funds scam, again

By Our Reporter

SHILLONG: Sohra legislator and former Chief Minister Dr Flinder A Khonglam is once again embroiled in controversy regarding fraudulent withdrawal of money in the name of bogus NGOs.

In the latest case, which caught Dr Khonglam on the wrong foot, the Sohram MLA is accused of being involved in illegal withdrawal of about Rs 39 lakh sanctioned by Khatarshnong-Laitkroh Community Development Block under different Central schemes.

"A few persons authorised by Dr Khonglam fraudulently withdrew Rs 38.61 lakh of Rs 48.88 lakh sanctioned under MLA Scheme of 1999-2003," stated People's Movement of Sohra Constituency (PMSC), which filed an RTI and also "carried out physical inspection in the Block".

According to PMSC convener Eligius R Sawian, an agent of Dr Khonglam, one P Mawkhiew had allegedly withdrawn Rs 31.28 lakh from SRWP Scheme, Rs 1.55 lakh from IACDP scheme and Rs 1.85 lakh from CRRP scheme.

Further, the Block's cashier L Nongpyiur had allegedly withdrawn Rs 6.68 lakh under a scheme meant for construction of houses for 334 poor families on November 19, 2002. Another Rs 3.59 lakh was withdrawn by other persons, the PMSC leader informed.

"Several bogus NGOs and clubs received financial assistance from the Block. All the money had been illegally withdrawn by Mr Mawkhiew, who also submitted the utilisation certificates with authority from Dr Khonglam," Mr Sawian alleged.

Mr Mawkhiew withdrew Rs 3.75 lakh to purchase a water tanker in the name of Seng Iaraplang Socio Organisation, Dympep, an organisation "considered as bogus by local people".

Alleging deep-rooted corruption behind such "irregularities", the PMSC asked as to why important documents like utilisation certificates and pay receipts were signed and distributed outside the office by certain individuals (like Mr Mawkhiew) and not by Block officials. "Normally these works are done by Block officials," Mr Sawian said.

The PMSC sought strict action against persons involved in such "misuse of Centrally-sponsored schemes" saying more than 1,700 villagers had been cheated by Dr Khonglam "as they never received the money meant for them.

It may be mentioned here that the former Chief Minister was recently accused of fraudulent withdrawal of funds to the tune of Rs 40 lakh from Shella-Bholaganj Community Development Block. There has been no word so far from the medical practitioner-turned-politician in this regard

Two Lyngdohs in a close race

By Our Reporter

Shillong: Jaiaw constituency, considered as one of the prestigious seats in the city appeared to have been locked in a straight contest between Urban Affairs Minister Paul Lyngdoh of KHNAM and former Finance Minister Aubrey H Scott Lyngdoh of the Congress.

With each passing day, the electorate of the constituency appears to be getting polarised between pro-changers and status qouist. As the electoral battle in the constituency is getting tougher between the two Lyngdohs, most of the elderly voters and intellectuals of the constituency have expressed dissatisfaction with the present legislator who according to them has failed to live up to his election promises.

While Paul Lyngdoh is enjoying more support among the youth of the constituency, he appears to have lost the wave that catapulted him to power in the 2003 Assembly elections. Gone are the days of hot pre-poll campaigning, processions and chanting of slogans in favour of "U Khnam Bad Ka Ryntieh" (bow and arrow) as the mood has changed from emotions to a dull campaigning.

"It is very much unpredictable. Nobody knows who will win but it depends on how the candidate wins the votes of women and elderly citizens in the constituency" said a voter from Jaiaw Pdeng on condition of anonymity.

However, Scott Lyngdoh is confident of turning the table this time round. The bureaucrat turned politician who is being accused by his rivals as "too old" has started to make inroads in various parts of the constituency including those considered as KHNAM strongholds like Jaiaw Langsning and Lumdiengjri.

KHNAM supporters on the other hand said that their party leader would surely reclaim the seat despite the setback caused by resignations of several senior party leaders including Nickson Dohling - one of the party's asset in Jaiaw who has switched sides to the NCP.

With the KHNAM having lost its most favourite symbol - Bow and Arrow - independent political observers feel that the latest development which takes place less than one month before the Assembly polls would have a severe impact on the party.

The observers said that most electorates including KHNAM supporters would be caught in a confusion over the new symbol allotted to the party. Similarly, the entry of one A Paul Lyngdoh in the fray as Samajwadi Party candidate could prove as another battle of confusion for the voters as he got a name similar to that of the sitting MLA.

The Congress candidate is also banking on the support of Jaiaw MDC Martamlin Pyrbot who has a strong mass base especially among the poor and lower rungs of the constituency. It may be mentioned that Mr Pyrbot defeated Paul Lyngdoh in the 2004 KHADC elections by a wide margin.

A crucial faction in this constituency is the non-Khasi voters ho have a significant four-figure presence here. The million dollar question is which way will they swing? Understandably, both the Lyngdohs are sparing no pains to woo them.

As to the issues figuring in this election in the constituency, both the Lyngdohs are blaming each other about the lack of principles. While Scott Lyngdoh lashes out at Paul for "forgotten promises", the junior Lyngdoh said that he had done enough for the development of the constituency during his tenure.

Most of the electorate said that they are now "waiting and watching" before going to the poll booth to press their deciding button "for bringing a change" while others said that the KHNAM candidate might win this time round although by a very thin margin.

Door to door campaigning by the two strong contenders for the hot seat has nearly been completed in this constituency having a total of 14,853 voters. Bigger localities in the constituencies like Jaiaw Laitdom, Jaiaw Langsning, Lumdiengjri and Mawprem are being concentrated for campaigning as in previous Assembly polls.

KHNAM to go all out with dao

By Our Reporter

Shillong: The KHNAM has decided to go all out to ensure that it's new symbol -dao (machete) - does not confuse the people and it is accepted by the voters. The KHNAM had to settle for the dao as it was denied its earlier symbol - a bow and an arrow, which has been given to the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) by the Election Commission of India.

Lyngdoh said the party would step up its publicity campaign to make its new symbol familiar to the people. He admitted that not getting its earlier symbol had disturbed the party's preparations for the ensuing elections.

In a public meeting of the party on Tuesday at Nongkynrih under Lyngkyrdem constituency, KHNAM president Paul Lyngdoh said that as KHNAM has only two legislators in the Assembly could not do much for the needs of the people, and it needed more legislators to fulfill the aspirations of the people.

It may be mentioned that in Lyngkyrdem Legislative Assembly constituency KHNAM had fielded D Roblin Nongkynrih as its nominee from Lyngkyrdem constituency for the ensuing Assembly election slated on March 3.

Sources said that Lyngkyrdem this time would be witnessing a 'triangular fight' between Prestone Tynsong (Congress), Samuel Khongbuh (UDP) and Dominic Roblin Nongkynrih (KHNAM).

KHNAM had fielded 14 nominees on its own and supports to HSPDP in 9 constituencies. Earlier, Mr Lyngdoh hit out at the Congress for its failure to provide stable development in the State. Refusing the allegation of Congress that regional parties couldn't provide stable government, he said that it is the Congress only that indulges itself in power fight among them citing the cases between Lapang-Rymbai tussle for Chief Minister post, KHADC fight between Prestone Tynsong - HS Shylla and HS Shylla - CB Syiem for the post of CEM. "It was unfortunate that we had three CEMs in KHADC and two chief ministers within five years because of Congress itself", added Lyngdoh.

UDP candidate arrested

By Our Reporter

Shillong: UDP candidate from Sutnga-Shangpung constituency Richard Sing Lyngdoh was arrested on Tuesday for allegedly coercing voters to vote in his favour in the coming Assembly poll. Jaintia Hills Superintendent of Police Mukesh K Singh said Mr Lyngdoh was arrested after an FIR was lodged against him and his brother for criminal intimidation. Police also arrested Mr Lyngdoh's brother, Denial Lyngdoh, on Monday for assaulting one Jesban Chyrmang after he raised question on his voting rights. Mr Lyngdoh along with his brother allegedly coerced voters of Sutnga village to cast their votes in his favour on February 9 last.

Laban MLA draws flak for not releasing report

By Our Reporter

Shillong: The timing of the release of the report on the implementation of the MLA schemes in Laban constituency for the year 2004-2008 has raised many eyebrows. A press statement issued in this connection has evoked a somewhat critical response from different quarters.

The first press statement issued on February 9, by BJP Publicity & Media Secretary of 22-Laban Assembly constituency Michael Joey Thma said the sitting MLA of Laban constituency Jopsimon Phanbuh, would release the MLA Report for the year 2004-2008 at Bonnie Guest House at 4 pm on February 12. But another release, which was issued on Monday regarding cancellation of programme has led to the confusion.

In the statement, which was issued on Monday, it was mentioned that the scheduled release has been cancelled due to fear that this would violate the already enforced Model Code of Conduct.

Laban residents seemed not too happy with the BJP's turn around on the MLA Report. Some residents questioned the timing of the release while others like H Lamare claimed, "it was planned already so that the report will not see the light of day."

District Council member from Laban and also the NCP's official candidate for the ensuing Assembly election, Sanbor Shullai said "it is funny why the sitting MLA is not declaring her schemes in time".

Citing Late TH Rangad and Ardhendu Chaudhuri as leaders in whose footsteps he'd like to follow, Shullai said "this is for the people to understand and decide".

Many residents of Laban were of the opinion that even as the pioneer of publicly declaring implementation of MLA schemes was the late MLA from Laban, TH Rangad, an act that was acknowledged by none other than veteran national leader George Fernandez, sadly this is not the case in the Laban of today.

Meanwhile, questions are also being raised on the way MLA schemes in Laban were implemented. People are demanding their right to know as to how the money was spent and whether it actually benefited anyone, especially the poor.

NCP appointment

By Our Reporter

Shillong: The NCP Shillong City Youth Wing in its emergency meeting here on Tuesday appointed Pynjanai S Warjri as its new vice president in place of Emlang Shabong who resigned from the party recently. The meeting also appointed two new executive members - Samlang Warjri and Bankitbok Diengdoh to the party's city young wing.

Video album of church’s hymn released

By Our Reporter

Shillong: "Ka Jingkhawai Ki Jingrwai Shem Mynsiem Volume-1", a collection of selected hymns from the hymnal of the Church of God (Meghalaya & Assam) was produced by the Jingiaseng Samla of the Church of God, Nongthymmai-Pohkseh in the form of DVD and VCD.

According to a press note issued here, the video album was officially released by Secretary of the Church of God Business Association Rev N Starling Iangrai during the Church's General Assembly at Laitjem on February 10.

President of the Church of God, Nongthymmai-Pohkseh Jacob L Shylla gave a brief introduction of the video album which according to him was a live recording of performances held on January 5 as part of rivival of hymn singing in the Church. He also informed that the video album would be available from the Church of God, Nongthymmai-Pohkseh here.

Laban MLA draws flak for not releasing report

By Our Reporter

Shillong: The timing of the release of the report on the implementation of the MLA schemes in Laban constituency for the year 2004-2008 has raised many eyebrows. A press statement issued in this connection has evoked a somewhat critical response from different quarters.

The first press statement issued on February 9, by BJP Publicity & Media Secretary of 22-Laban Assembly constituency Michael Joey Thma said the sitting MLA of Laban constituency Jopsimon Phanbuh, would release the MLA Report for the year 2004-2008 at Bonnie Guest House at 4 pm on February 12. But another release, which was issued on Monday regarding cancellation of programme has led to the confusion.

In the statement, which was issued on Monday, it was mentioned that the scheduled release has been cancelled due to fear that this would violate the already enforced Model Code of Conduct.

Laban residents seemed not too happy with the BJP's turn around on the MLA Report. Some residents questioned the timing of the release while others like H Lamare claimed, "it was planned already so that the report will not see the light of day."

District Council member from Laban and also the NCP's official candidate for the ensuing Assembly election, Sanbor Shullai said "it is funny why the sitting MLA is not declaring her schemes in time".

Citing Late TH Rangad and Ardhendu Chaudhuri as leaders in whose footsteps he'd like to follow, Shullai said "this is for the people to understand and decide".

Many residents of Laban were of the opinion that even as the pioneer of publicly declaring implementation of MLA schemes was the late MLA from Laban, TH Rangad, an act that was acknowledged by none other than veteran national leader George Fernandez, sadly this is not the case in the Laban of today.

Meanwhile, questions are also being raised on the way MLA schemes in Laban were implemented. People are demanding their right to know as to how the money was spent and whether it actually benefited anyone, especially the poor.


Social Development Zones

India used to pride itself on the abundance of human talent in the country, which made it go great guns in the information technology industry. But that, alas, is no longer the case. With rising wages and a shallow pool of skilled labour, information technology and business process outsourcing (BPO) are not so well placed any longer. The IT industry, which was booming, is for the first time retrenching employees. IT companies report that they have to interview an average of 14-15 candidates before they find someone who fills the bill. Previously, they had to screen just two or three before selecting the right person. Fresh talent is tapering out. Doubts have arisen about whether India can grow into a knowledge hub during this century. HRD managers in the industry blame it on the stagnation of higher education in the country. The Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) has responded to the challenge by throwing up the idea of forming Social Development Zones (SDZs). The concept had, of course, been mooted by experts earlier. The SDZs will focus on education, health and social uplift. The 11th Five Year Plan has on the drawing board 30 new Central Universities , eight IITs and seven IIMs. Investment from the private sector is obligatory. The project is by no means adequate. The government has first to create an enabling atmosphere for higher education throughout the country. Official and bureaucratic controls have to be curtailed.

The National Knowledge Commission had suggested that India ’s unwieldy higher education system should be decentralised. Autonomy should be granted to colleges and universities. An Independent Regulatory Authority for Higher Education (IRAHE) should be set up on the lines of TRAI for the telecom sector. If the government were committed to big bang reform of education, these proposals would have been implemented. Besides, it is imperative that western institutions should be invited to supplement the national effort. Totalitarian China has done it in a big way. Globalisation in education should be easier in democratic India . But the snag remains in India ’s politics with its coalition problems. Add to that the vested interests crippling the higher reaches of academe. In such a context, one has to make do with marginal changes. SDZs are welcome even if they do not come up to the mark. At least, the brain drain will be largely reversed. A talented student will not have to go abroad to improve his skills. SDZs at home will meet the requirement significantly.



Turf of war between Judiciary, Legislature and Executive

By Sushil Jain

For the last 25-years there has been turf war between the legislature, executive and judiciary, which got accentuated during the time of Emergency imposed by Mrs. Indira Gandhi in 1975. But any action taken by legislature and executive is subject to review by the judiciary to safeguard the basic structure of the Constitution. Since 2004 there have been many instances where judiciary interpreted the law differently as that of legislature and executive. As such the Lok Sabha Speaker, Mr. Somnath Chatterjee, has been very critical of judicial interventions.

In a face-to-face programme at the Kolkata Press Club on January 30, the Lok Sabha Speaker, Mr. Somnath Chatterjee, went to the extent of accusing the judiciary of "taking away, undemocratically and unconstitutionally, the rights of the executive and the legislature". This is not for the first time that Mr. Chatterjee has made such a statement.

This kind of standoff does not bring credit either to the legislature or judiciary. Whether both institutions are clearly overstepping their proper domain is a debatable matter. But the form in which the argument is being conducted is generating more heat than light. Part of the difficulty is that any particular issue is subject to review by the judiciary. For some years now, the legislature has been on the back foot to redeem its own credibility, and it would be somewhat ironic if the court determined that it did not have the power to do so after all.

The standoff between the Speaker and the court can be considered at different levels. The first level is that of rhetoric. Assuming indeed that parliament is confident of its case and assuming further that it is right to insist on its jurisdiction, was it incumbent upon the Speaker and parliament to react to the court's notice the way they did in the case of expulsion of 11 members of parliament, which started the confrontation? Was it necessary to officially refuse a court notice? Were there other options that could have been exercised? For instance, the Speaker could have replied, explaining parliament's position. Or a law officer of the government could have explained parliament's position in court. This has been the practice in the past. But outright refusal of a notice, combined with a call for presiding officers of legislatures to meet, was arguably a needless escalation of rhetoric, not warranted by the substance of the notice at hand.

The first level is that of rhetoric. Assuming indeed that parliament is confident of its case and assuming further that it is right to insist on its jurisdiction, was it incumbent upon the Speaker and parliament to react to the court's notice the way they did in the case of expulsion of 11 members of parliament, which started the confrontation? Was it necessary to officially refuse a court notice? Were there other options that could have been exercised? For instance, the Speaker could have replied, explaining parliament's position.

But the escalation of this rhetoric suggests that the issue at the moment is not simply about upholding the technical validity of parliament's expulsion of its members. Parliament appears to be making an even more emphatic statement by its actions. It wants to defend a deeper theory of its jurisdictional autonomy. Ask the question: Who decides where the boundary of parliamentary prerogative lies?

The answer to this question is not as straightforward as it appears. If we say "the courts", then it is not clear there is a parliamentary prerogative at all, for that prerogative is now mediated through judicial power. The usual way the court defends its encroachment upon legislative prerogative is this. It posits a distinction between the existence of a right and its application. On this view, the court is the final authority that decides whether parliament has a right in the first place. But the Speaker's position seems to be raising a deeper point. By what authority does the court insist that it and it alone, is the final arbiter of what parliament's rights are? In this instance, an appeal to the Constitution does not help. If both branches are co-equal, does not insisting that every legislative prerogative is subject to the court's jurisdiction in effect make the court supreme over everything, a branch of government more equal than others?

Whatever the court may say about the separation of powers, or about all branches of government being under the Constitution, the fact is that the court has made itself supreme in many ways. It is a little simplistic to insist that the Constitution is supreme. This is because what the Constitution is cannot be decided with reference to a "text". Somebody has to interpret the Constitution and that institution decides what the Constitution is. Indian courts have claimed absolute and exclusive authority to interpret the Constitution. In doing so, the courts have expanded their powers beyond anything that a reasonable reading of the Constitution would warrant.

The fundamental challenge the Speaker is raising is to this state of affairs. The legislature has ceded power to the court in every instance. But, at least, when it comes to that sliver of issues dealing with legislative rules, parliament wants to assert its authority. Parliament seems to be saying that the very act of admitting a suit is encroaching upon its powers. By admitting any suit, the court is insisting that no, repeat, no issue is immune from judicial scrutiny. But if this is the doctrine then what remains of the legislature's prerogative over its own matters; a prerogative that exists at the behest of the court is not a prerogative at all. And this is what the Speaker wants to remind the court.

Is the Speaker correct in his surmise? A fair assessment would say that he is not entirely off the mark in raising this fundamental issue. Given the fact that the Constitution does seem to grant legislatures great leeway over the manner in which their proceedings are conducted, the presumption should be in favour of parliament. For instance, the Constitution says nothing about the fact that a budget should be properly discussed before it is passed. Will the Supreme Court now have the right to intervene, laying down the stipulations about what counts as proper discussion? For instance, the court's view in the Jharkhand assembly case and its admission of expulsion case suggested that there was nothing preventing the courts from regulating legislative discussion, in the name of preserving the integrity of the democratic process. The Speaker was right to register his protest, though it could have been done more reasonably.

The court's authority is inescapable. After all, even a refusal to admit would have been a court decision. But admitting the suit seems to lay down a stronger version of the court's authority than is warranted. Indian courts have become so enamoured of their power that they rarely refuse a matter on the ground that it is not within their jurisdiction. This approach has made the doctrine of the separation of powers and the equality of all branches of government a little bit of a pie in the sky, and the Speaker is beginning to express a legitimate frustration.

We of course all believe the fiction that the people are supreme. But "the people" are a nebulous entity given concrete shape through their representatives. In this particular instance, the representatives of the people decided, rightly and after following due process, that the actions of some of their colleagues vitiated the integrity of representative institutions. Hence they were expelled. Of course, ours is a constitutional, representative democracy, where there are limits to what representatives can do. And normally courts are the institutions where these limits are articulated. But it would be undesirable if the courts took it upon themselves to second guess the legislature on every matter.

It seems that in relation to the rules of conduct that apply to members of parliament, the legislature must be given more leeway. This would not have diminished the court's authority in any way. The court's authority is inescapable. After all, even a refusal to admit would have been a court decision. But admitting the suit seems to lay down a stronger version of the court's authority than is warranted. Indian courts have become so enamoured of their power that they rarely refuse a matter on the ground that it is not within their jurisdiction. This approach has made the doctrine of the separation of powers and the equality of all branches of government a little bit of a pie in the sky, and the Speaker is beginning to express a legitimate frustration.

But there is a bigger lesson in the politics of law. There is no such thing as a transparent Constitution that can settle all disputes about the allocation of power. Power flows to the institution that exercises it, and the court has learned to create its own power. Much of this has been for the good, but political prudence demands that we keep power in the system dispersed at various levels. Completely eviscerating the authority of the legislature will do no good to the system. The courts can put a finger in the dyke to prevent occasional leaks, but they cannot be a substitute locus of governance. INAV

Beware voters

Sir,

It is shameful to learn that modern day politics has taken an ugly turn and has a different meaning altogether to the political class. Most of the aspiring new politicians have exposed their greed for money and power by committing cheapest act of praising a particular political party today and condemning the same tomorrow by joining another party as what had happened in a once considered prestigious constituency like Laitumkhrah and many others in Meghalaya. If this is their discipline in a party, what can be expected when they are on their seats? Conceiving the ideology of a political party isn't a child's play which could be fully digested within seconds as was proved by many of the contesting candidates. Such acts prove that these candidates simply crave for party sponsorship and eye on government formation for future wealth. I would like to recall commendable acts done by one Malcolm Tariang and Manas Chaudhuri, who despite being offered tickets by various political parties wisely choose an independent vision of serving the people individually rather than by groups of empty vessels making the most noise.

The electorate of Meghalaya must recall a candidate's past deeds before pressing on an EVM button, as better speakers often prove to be experienced traitors. When moral and social values are superseded, least can be expected on develomental front.

Yours etc.,
A concerned citizen
Via e-mail

Beauty of Shillong

Sir,

Shillong is supposed to be a beautiful city with well civilized and disciplined citizens. Unfortunately, most of the citizens lacking a civic sense i.e spitting on the roads after consuming kwai and supari. This is the most unpleasant scene I see whenever I walk on the roads. I appeal to those people of Shillong to desist from this uncivilized act to improve the beauty of Shillong.

Yours etc.,
Chevuturi Mohan
Via e-mail

 

Kidney racket

Sir,

With reference to the news regarding the kidney racket in India, it is high time now that there needs to be a World Donor Organisation (WDO) where in it is made mandatory that all those who lend and receive any bodily donations such as blood, eye, kidney, liver or for that matter any part of the human body is registered. It can also be made online so that the supply and demand is met and not wasted.

It is very sad that such a precious lives and human organs are used to make money.

Yours etc.,
S.Sundaresan.
Burdubai.
Via e-mail


NEEPCO plant off after Black Widow strike

From Our Correspondent

GUWAHATI: Panic has gripped the employees and their families of the 275 MW Kopili power project of NEEPCO located near Umrangshu in insurgency-ravaged North Cachar Hill district of Assam in the wake of Monday's militant attack on the convoy of employees of the power plant that left four dead and two injured.

NEEPCO sources said that the militants also cut the 33 KVA line and a number of telephone lines to the Umrangshu plant of the Kopili Hydro-power Project before the attack throwing power generation out of gear.

Police informed that four persons including three security men and a driver were killed and two other security personnel injured when suspected militants belonging to Dima Halam Daogah (Jewel Garlosa) faction or Black Widow ambushed a three-vehicle convoy of NEEPCO employees coming from Umrangshu power plant to the township under police escort.

NEEPCO sources informed that the Black Widow ultras had slapped an extortion demand of Rs 2 crore, which the power company, a government of India undertaking, had ignored.

Meanwhile, the NEEPCO could generate no power from the 200 MW Umrangshu plant (Lower Kopili) on Tuesday because of disruption power transmission line. Moreover, no power could be generated from the two upstream plants (total capacity 75 MW) of the Kopili project at Khadong as panic stricken employees declined to go to work site in the wake of the fresh militants strike.

Five officials suspended for misappropriation

Imphal: Five officials, including two Deputy Directors, of Minority and Other Backward Classes (MOBC) Department of Manipur were suspended for alleged misappropriation of funds meant for development of minority communities, official sources said on Tuesday.

The officials, suspended late last week, were MOBC deputy directors K Lokhon and Th Gopal, account officer K Paokhamlung, besides agriculture officers L Mak Joute and H Gourakishore.

A departmental enquiry has been ordered against them, the sources said.

The five officials had said during preliminary investigations that about 30 per cent of the funds for the department were diverted due to pressure from different NGOs, the sources said. (PTI)

4 extortionists held

Kohima: Police arrested four extortionists including a NSCN (K) cadre and seized an AK-47 rifle and ammunition from their possession at Dimapur.

The arrests followed the state government's decision to curb the growing menace of extortion in the commercial town.

The four accused, including the NSCN(K) cadre, were arrested yesterday at Marowari Patti while they were extorting money from a businessman, police said here on Tuesday. (PTI)

ULFA interlocutor alleges threat to life

From Our Correspondent

Guwahati: A negotiator for the proscribed United Liberation Front of Asom (ULFA), Hiranya Saikia has alleged that he had received threat to his life and termed it part of a bigger conspiracy to put out the peace initiative to find a solution to the ULFA problem through negotiation with the Central Government.

A vital link between the Government of India and the banned militant group, Hiranya Saikia, who is a member of the ULFA-constituted People's Consultative Group (PCG), on Tuesday told the media that he had been warned over phone on Monday night by a person who identified himself as an ULFA cadre, Bokul Deka.

"The person, Bokul Deka warned me that commander of the ULFA's 709 battalion, Hira Sarania would kill him and me. The warning call came from mobile No 9435612707 at 10 pm and was followed by an SMS at 11-45 pm," Saikia said.

"I was totally taken aback by the call as no one in the ULFA except its chairman Arabinda Rajkhowa and commander in chief Paresh Baruah is allowed to talk to me directly over phone. I fear it is a part of conspiracy to kill me by those who want the peace process to get derailed. The ULFA will be later blamed for my killing," he alleged.

The People's Consultative Group (PCG) constituted by the ULFA in September 2005 to facilitate direct talks between the outfit and Government of India.

He said he would lodge a complaint with the police about the threat received to his life. He alleged 'a section, of police force, Army and politicians are out to scuttle the peace initiative for good'.

He also alleged that Monday's arrest of right activist Lachit Bardoloi, another PCG member, by police in connection with a foiled ULFA plan to hijack an aircraft, was aimed at damaging the peace initiative launched by the PCG on behalf of the ULFA.

Troops cut distant in North East

From Our Spl Correspondent

NEW DELHI: The security situation might have improved in North East but the Army is not prepared to thin down its forces or pull back from the volatile region in view of the build up by the mighty Chinese on the other side of the border and other factors.

The Indian Army is not in favour of Government recommendation to go for a "lean and mean force" or pull back from troubled areas, citing factors like the lack of progress in peace process, fighting militancy in North East and Jammu and Kashmir.

The army also needs to man the higher reaches of Kargil and the eastern front facing China, the Army top brass have told the Government, according to sources here. Instead of downsizing or pulling back, Indian Army is raising two divisions for deployment in the mountainous terrain facing Pakistan and China.

Over past some months, the Government here has been pushing the idea of restructuring in the forces to make it "more leaner and meaner".

Keeping in view the changed war scenario, a section in the strategic establishment has asked to rely more on technology and weapon systems rather on a huge man power.

It is believed that Army's top brass is likely to make a detailed presentation about the inadvisability of downsizing move to the top political leadership next month. The Army says, the ground situation, does not leave any room for "field force rationalisation" (troops engaged in actual combat operations) as the two fronts, Pakistan and China, need physical presence of the troops on the ground.

It has also argued that operational commitments in Jammu and Kashmir to tackle insurgency were manpower intensive. It is being argued here that much of manpower in Indian Army was in favour of tail, the non-fighting force. The government had recommended improvement in the "teeth-to-tail ratio" in favour of the "teeth".

The Army also argues that because of sustained pressure by the forces, the militants are on the run in states like Assam. If the presence of forces is thinned now the situation might come back to square one.

China has committed several intrusions in Arunachal Pradesh sectors in the past. Now it has alleged that India is building up forces in Sikkim sector. Considering all these factors the forces now do not want to thin down let alone pull back.



National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |

 

                                               

Make This Your HomePage! | About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery

Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.